Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Not a Spy Story

Socialist Organiser no. 189, 26 July 1984 · scan pp. 9–10 · Edward Ellis · about 1,280 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

SPIES ate in the news these days. In fact one of the things that never ceases to amaze me is that despite the annual discovery of yet another Soviet agent in some high-placed position in the British state, the fabric of our civilisation resolutely fails to collapse. Nevertheless, the psychology behind the decision of a well-placed upper-class Englishman to become a Russian spy is an interesting issue.

Another Country is ostensibly about such a background. It opens with Guy 'Bennett' being interviewed in Moscow about his youth, and his decision to betray his class.

His youth was that of most bourgeois/aristocratic boys in the 1920s: in a public school.

The actual plot of the film in fact deals much more with male sexuality in the school than it does with espionage -were it not for the prologue and epilogue, this theme would in fact be invisible.

Tension

The film deals with the repression of sexuality - both the internalised repression (it is not until the end of the film that Guy acknowledges that it is more than a passing phase for him), and the external repression: the school hierarchy, and especially the 'gods' (the elite of the prefects) take steps to repress and hide the extent of homosexual activity in the school, following LAST weekend, the Socialist Environment and Resources Association and Green CND held their second joint conference, this time with the theme of linking up the environmental and trade union movements.

Out of about 150 attending, there were few trade unionists who were not already involved in the environmental movement. Nevertheless, there were some very valuable workshop discussions on issues where trade unions and environmentalists have cooperated and on issues where they should and will cooperate..

Examples include campaigns against nuclear waste transport and dumping, against the sale of useless and dangerous medicines in the Third World, against multinationals like RTZ, against dampness in council housing and for bans on development in conservation areas.

Nuclear waste

Pete Wilkinson, Director Greenpeace, addressed workshop on the campai Edward Ellis reviews the film, "Another Country', which was inspired by thi story of the spy Guy Burgess the suicide of a boy found the act in a changing room.

There are grades and nuances amongst the hierarchy, ranging from the confused disillusionment of the current head boy, Menzies, to the sadism and proto-fascism of his likely successor, Fowler.

Rebellion

And there are two figures of rebellion: Judd, who spends his days and nights reading Das Kapital; and Guy Bennett himself, who has no political commitment, but deals with authority with a witty aristocratic anarchism.

The relationship between Judd and Bennett is one of the most interesting themes of the film. Judd is a stereotypical Communist - talks of nothing else, criticises "sentimentality", is cold and hard. He refuses to be a prefect so as not to "participate in the institutions of repression"

One of the most powerful moments in the film is Bennett's response to Judd's dismissal of his claim that "I am never going to love women". Bennet tells Judd that despite his belief in revolution and equality, he's the against sea dumping nuclear waste.

Greenpeace started by carrying out research into what actually happens to radioactive substances in the sea. Government policies were based on calculations literally made on the back of an envelope. Greenpeace was able to show that far from being safely diluted in the vast volume of sea water, radioactive elements were being concentrated on the sea bed, where they could enter food chains.

Then followed direct action and propaganda. The direct action (obstructing dumping by sailing rubber dinghies up to dumping ships) gained much publicity. Information directed at Spain (the nearest country to the dumping site led Spain to oppose sea-dumping at the London Dumping Convention.

When the LDC voted 19-6 to cease dumping, the UK government refused to abide by the decision.

Greenpeace had been speaking to seafarers union branches and gaining s pport same as the rest: "You still believe some people are superior to others just because of the way they make love"

Judd, true to the stereotype (and it's probably a valid one) is about the only person in the school who has never 'indulged' Nevertheless, Judd is also a powerful figure. We know that most of what he says is true, and contrasts sharply with the idiocy, prejudice and sadism of his peers. There is a tension between his position - his relative puritanism and his insistent heterosexuality, which implies criticism of homosexuality as an aspect of the bourgeoiş degeneracy of it all - and the lived experience of violence and oppression of Bennett. Bennett's predicament ultimately adds to Judd's critique, although Judd is slow to realise it.

Sexuality

The film is also extremely funny, and at times very touching. To persuade Judd to become a prefect (and thus manoeuvre against the terrifying Fowler), Bennett deliberately attends a school military presentation dressed very badly, and so loses the competition for his school 'house' . To prevent the prefects birching him, he threatens to tell the headmaster exactly who he's had sex with...

And throughout, Bennett develops a touching love affair Greenpeace protesters off Sellafield for their campaign, and were therefore in a good position to go over the heads of government for a union ban on dumping, supported by the four transport unions.

Greenpeace is repeating the process over the discharge of radioactive waste from Sellafield into the Irish Sea. They have looked at the scientific evidence on effects of waste in the Irish Sea, they have carried out a highly publicised and popular direct action campaign and are also gaining union interest and support.

The UK government have been unable to oppose calls for stopping discharge of waste, but are doing their with a boy from another house'. They meet at night on a boat and just cuddle eachother. In the end, it's his refusal to betray his lover that causes him to submit to the best to get round them. They have agreed to "minimise" discharges and say this will be achieved within ten years. meanwhile some three deaths per year at least are due to this radioactive pollution, according to government sources, and Pete Wilkinson expects this to be the start of an epidemic of cancers around Sellafield.

Greenpeace is arguing that discharges must be minimised now, using the "best available technology" , namely the "totally closed circuit" being installed at Hanford in the USA.

Waiting ten years to *minimise" discharges would violence of the prefects, convinces him of his own sexuality and - the connection with his future as a spy - loses for him the possibility of fulfilling his ambitions.

be a hollow gesture, since the type of nuclear power station causing the problems will be obsolete in ten years. Pete Wilkinson described the waste problem as the Achiles Heel of the nuclear power industry and said he felt confident that nuclear power was on the way out. The recent spectacular but largely irrelevant crash test of a waste container was a AND NATIONAL HANDSWORTH PARK :(HOLLY IBERLAIN SQUARE (Nr B'HAM HERE TO FIGHT PSP Camparan Alinat eti! at tom at c/o lol Villa k.d. Hane Birmingham.

It's beautifully filmed, beautifully scripted and convincingly acted. Don't take any notice of the adverts - this is not a spy film: it's much more interesting than that.

desperate attempt to flagging confidence.

At a workshop on the miners' strike, the majority of participants felt that a victory for the miners was essential not only for the miners but also for those campaigning for safe energy and against nuclear ‚power.

Scan page 10

no.189 July 26

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 189

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →