Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Kinnock-another Harold Wil

Socialist Organiser no. 189, 26 July 1984 · scan p. 10 · about 934 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Send letters to Socialist Organiser, 28 Middle Lane, London N8. No longer than 400 words please: longer letters are liable to be cut. I THINK Clive Bradley (SO 188) overdid his praise for Steve Cohen's book, "That's funny, you don't look anti-semitic"

I agree with Cohen's basic point: that the Left tends to refer to anti-semitism only in order to say (truly) that anti-Zionism does not imply anti-semitism, rather than considering • antisemitism worthy of attention in its own right.

But Cohen swathes that thesis in some dubious arguments.

Abram Leon's Marxist classic, "The Jewish Question' argued that the Jews retained a distinct identity because they became a people-class' , specialising in trading and money-lending.

Cohen objects on several counts. In fact, he claims, Jews were not economically specialised in that way: on this I am not The link is not entirely logical: if assimilation will not happen anyway, then why worry about it? But what is clear is that Cohen resists any notion of Jewish identity as being based on specific material conditions and therefore likely to fade if those conditions disappear.

Now assimilation does not mean forcible imposition of the majority culture on Jews, as Cohen seems to assume.

Marxists

Nathan Weinstock well:

"Marxists defend the right of the Jewish masses to freely develop their cultural life as long as they wish to assert their specificity. Not only is this the only humane and democratic I HAVE been reading with great interest your articles on Neil Kinnock and on the whole I agree with your analysis, although I think you err on the side of charity.

Unquestionably Kinnock is not a socialist, but I doubt if he is even a radical. My own impression is that he is little more than an opportunist, whose only guiding principle 1s an overwhelming desire for office. He will say anything, go anywhere, do anything and make any compromise to get himself into 10 Downing Street.

He was created by and is the creature of television. Can anyone seriously believe that Kinnock would be the leader of anything but for his skill in presenting himself on TV?

Much is made of Kinnock's decisive victory in the leadership contest, but surely that episode 1s one of the most discreditable in the Labour Party's often squalid At a time when the Party was frightened and demoralised after its defeat in the 1983 election, a group of trade union barons, headed by Clive Jenkins, persuaded Michael Foot to resign the leadership when the Left's only credible candidate, Tony Benn, was out of Parliament. With little time to think and less to organise, the Left allowed itself to be bounced into supporting Kinnock as the only alternative to the social democrat, Roy HattersEric Heffer's gallant campaign to give the Left a genuine choice never got off the ground. The right and the Labour establishment supported Kinnock because they knew his hunger for office could be manipulated to their own advantage.

Since his elevation Kinnock has convinced himself, or been convinced by others, that the Labour Party's oniy chance ef victory in the next election is by moving to the centre, hence his support for the witch-hunt. This strategy has been thrown off course by the sudden and unexpected re-emergence of a fighting socialist spirit within the Labour movement as evinced by the Liverpool councillors and the striking miners.

Kinnock's reaction to both has been worthy of Harold Wilson himself. He avoided committing himself as long as possible, only coming out with tardy and lukewarm support for the miners under strong pressure from Benn and other socialists on the NEC, while behind the scenes, l am sure, he and his cohorts are working desperately for some cobbled up compromise.

What should the Left do? Your own view and that of many sincere socialists seems to be that little can be hoped for at the moment other than to bring pressure on Kinnock to break with the Right by forcing his hand on the miners and Liverpool. With the greatest respect, I consider Kinnock will temporise while he considers it expedient to do so, but as soon as he dares he will resume his efforts to move the Labour Party back to the centre. Should the Left not start now to pian a strategy to secure a change in the leadership as soon as possible, so that we are not caught napping a second time? Above all, we must guard against falling into the trap of repiacing one opportunist with another, who seems, temporarily at least, to be rather more successful.

I refer, of course, to Ken Livingstone, who is rumoured to have his eye on Kinnock's job. I know he is the blue-eyed boy at the moment for embarrassing Mrs Thatcher, but having watched him in action at County Hall for the last three years, 1 am convinced that he has a commitment to nothing except the greater glory of Ken Livingstone. His record is far too patchy to inspire confidence.

It seems that increasingly the hopes, aspirations and views of the rank and file members of the party, including myself, are articulated by Comrade Benn, whose warm and unstinting support for both the Liverpool councillors and the miners has been in such marked contrast to Kinnock's. mean spirited performance.

Benn is being forced by circumstances to assume the de facto leadership of the party in order to fill the moral and intellectual vacuum created by Kinnock's feebleness and want of principle.

PAULA WATSON, Westminster CLP.

----- pull-quotes -----

this to be a "trimph of optimism over experience". Opportunist

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 189

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →