Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Get out of the EEC!

Socialist Organiser no. 189, 26 July 1984 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 1,342 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

ORGANISED! competent to judge. But he also seems to argue that any theory which explains anti-semitism from what Jews do or have done is necessarily blaming Jews for Not so: and Cohen's argument eads him to a very mystical view of anti-semitism. Polemicising against 'rigid determinism' , he seems to end up opposing any attempt to root an explanation of anti-semitism in the social and economic situation of Jews. Anti-semitism becomes an eternal fact.

Cohen also argues against Leon tnat no special argument at all is needed to explain the persistence of a Jewish identity outside Palestine. Other nations -the Irish or the English, for exampie - don't merge into their surroundings, and neither do the Jews. That is all there is to it.

Factually this must be wrong: the Irish in England assimilate pretty quickly, and so for centuries did the English in Ireland. Ideologically it seems to be linked to Cohen's sharp opposition of regarding assimilation of Jews into non-Jewish national majorities as progressive, as Marxists traditionally have Get Name Address policy; it is also the only approach which will enable this so frequently oppressed minority to give full expression to the internationalist and socialist currents with which the best of its children are deeply imbued *(But) only a reactionary in the full sense of the word could want to preserve artificially the specific Jewish identity To stand opposed to assimilation which occurs naturally and voluntarily through the destruction of national divisions and the disappearance of distinctions between peoples, even under capitalism, is to be, in Lenin' words, 'a supporter of all that is outmoded and connected with caste among the Jewish people' (Zionism, false messiah')

Cohen, I think, tends to make his opposition to anti-semitism into a sort of Jewish equivalent of black cultural nationalism or of radical feminism. He himself draws cut the political conclusions of his attitude in trying to justify the Jewish-separatist policy of the Bund as against the Russian Marxists in the early years of this century.

MARTIN THOMAS Islington Become a supporter of the Socialist Organiser Alliance - groups are established in most large towns. We ask £1.50 a month minimum (20p unwaged) contriution from supporters.

I want to become a Socialist Organiser supporter/ I want more information.

Send to Socialist Organiser, 28 Middle Lane, London N8 8PL.

to Martin I write in response Thomas' article in SO, dated May 31, 1984.

While correctly seeing that Bennite and Stalinist opposi tion to the EEC is characterised by petit-bourgeois nationalism, it refuses to acknowledge that the EEC represents a more advanced stage in the development of capit alism which should be opposed because of its real effects on the working class.

To outline these effects would SOCIALISTS shouid support the British Medical Association's call for an end to boxing.

Firstly, boxing kills boxers. On that there's no argument.

Secondly it is neither a 'sport nor 'fun' . Aside from the fatalities there are the injuries and brain damage.

Sugar Ray Leonard risks his sight every time he goes into the ring. Ali doesn't float like a butterfly and sting like a bee' anymore. He's permanently puddled and punchdrunk.

Boxing can't be made safe. When you get inside those ropes your head is a target for selfpropelled missiles known as fists, and there is no way of making that safe Back in 1951 in America, six boxers were killed in eight months. They said then, 'Boxing can be made a safe sport. They've been saying it for 33 years.

But there's another reason why socialists should be against boxing. I've never read it better expressed than by James P. Cannon, the great American socialist and workers' leader.

Poisonous "It's a commentary on the times and the social environment out of which the boxing business rises, like a poisonous flower from a dunghill, that nobody came forward with the simple demand to outlaw prize fighting, as it was outlawed in most of the States of this country up till the turn of the century. "Cock-fighting is illegal, it is considered inhumane to pui a couple of roosters into the pit and incite them to spur each otherbe voluminous. I concentrate on the following themes.

1) You quote Marx's and Engels' response to the unification of Germany in 1871. Marx quite clearly was aware that there were some favourable aspects to the unification that could be used by communists. He also per ceived that in the actual state of the class struggle internationally in 1871, following the defeat of the Commune, it was impossible to conceive of the class effeeuntil one of them keels over. It is also against the law to put bulldogs into the pit to fight for a side bet.

"But our cilivisation. has not yet advanced to the point where law and public opinion forbid men who have nothing against each other, to fight for money and the amusement of paying spectators. Such speactacles are part of our highly touted way of life.

Pacifism

Many socialists equate a hostility to boxing to class pacifism. Gerry Hoffa's article in Socialist Organiser no. 159 did just this. He applauds the anti-Semite Hyndman, leader of the SDF in his attack on "fabian lillies" who opposed boxing. (It's significant that Gerry doesn't stop to think in what ideology the term "lillies" is embedded - homophobia).

This is all just so much rubbish. What Gerry has to explain is how tragic deaths like that of Johnny Owen, the young Welsh boxer, help us argue, as we should, for organised workers' defence in the miners' strike.

Gerry argues that boxing is a 'noble art'. . He'd do well to remember what Joe Louis said when, after renouncing his title to turn promoter, he was asked which he preferred, boxing or promoting. His answer_ came straight away, "promotin' "

The reporter scemd surprised, *Why is that, can you explain it?". . "Sure." said Joe. "They can't hit you when youre promotin' JOHNSON tively mounting a political opposition to the creation of the Empire in 1871.

But the situation in Britain is completely distinct.

We have not suffered a major defeat. On the contrary, on the industrial front we see an enormous advance on the situation nine months ago. We can capitalise on the popular opposition to the EEC which Thatcher is using to bolster her own position. The strength of working class opposition to the EEC is such that we can mobilise significant sections of the working class against capitalism. In 1871 Marx and Engels were not in a comparable situation. To cite Marx and Engels in 1871 without positing the citations against the realities of the conjuncture of 1871 is to betray the sort of formalism that Leninists should always avoid.

2) To say with Martin Thomas that "the Common Agricultural Policy has been relatively successful in capitalist terms' shows an amazing ignorance of the facts. Although it is true that labour productivity has increased, even if not to the extent of fivefold as claimed by Thomas, it is clear from all the bourgeois literature and from any objective treatment of CAP that it has actually been a colossal failure, 3) Martin points out that 'no amount of calls for 'Britain out' will turn the economic clock back' and 'abolish the huge scale of modern capitalist industry and its interconnections. Quite correct, comrade. But that misses the point. None of us calling for withdrawal believe that this would mitigate or overturn the tendencies within capitalism which Martin points to, just as opposing redundancies in the coalfields will not of itself prevent rationalisation and unemployment in other sectors.

The problem is to ask. in what ways will opposition to the EEC develop the implantation of socialist consciousness amongst advanced sections of the proletariat? How can a fight against the effects of the EEC on the working class develop consciousness and increase the level of class struggle in the present conjuncture?

SYDNEY NICHOLSON (NATPHE. Feltham and Heston (I P)

Scan page 11

Socialist Organiser no. 189 July 26 1984 Page 11 -Industrial

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 189

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →