Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Power against the people

Socialist Organiser no. 190, 2 August 1984 · scan p. 4 · Bob Fine · about 1,597 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

THE official view of the police entatives. Democracy and the is that they serve the interests police are at opposite poles of By Bob Fine mittee. their respective councils. A mounted policeman tries to baton Lesley Boulton, a woman who tried to get help for an injured miner during the "battle of Orgreave' in June labour movement debates police controls IRT PUT De FIRST: SOPLE Baçk the miners JOHN HARRIS THE official view of the police is that they serve the interests fo the community as a whole.

In both theory and practice, however, democratic accountability of the police is restricted in the extreme. The general rule is that the more democratic the body to which the police are accountable, the fewer powers that body has.

To put the matter bluntly, real power over the police is kept well away from ordinary citizens or their elected representatives. police are social life.

In Britain mechanisms of accountability exist at local and national levels. Locally they take the form of Police Committees who are considered 'responsible' for insuring the existence of an 'efficient' police force but whose powers are insignificant.

They may call for reports from Chief Constables, but the police may refuse to provide stopped on motorways, their windows smashed and occupants arrested.

3) In Nottinghamshire where 12,000 miners are on strike, police have raided the homes of the striking miners in the middle of the night, evicting Yorkshire miners who were staying with them.

4) At Orgreave, 50 mounted police went berserk, hitting everyone in sight with their truncheons.

"Police should be truly accountable to the people through local authorities, and steps towards a national police force should be abandoned" argued Mr McKinlay.

Councillor Norman McEwan, speaking as an official of the Scottish Council for Civil Liberties, expressed similar fears. •The SCCL are very information if they consider it unwise in the 'public interest' They may advise on "policy' matters but have no say on "operational' matters. It is the police who determine what counts as 'operational' They may appoint a chief constable, but only from a list approved by the Home Office and with the approval of the Home Office. They may fire a Chief Contable for dereliction of duty, but only with the consent of the Home Office.

They may set a budget for the police, but if they fail to do so they may be overruled by the police, the Home Office and even perhaps - depending on the outcome of a recent case - the law.

The representativeness of Police Committees is also weak. They consist of two-thirds councillors and one-third unelected magistrates — to maintain 'balance'. The rules governing committees are set by the Home Office and not the local authority.

Authorities

The councils which appoint representatives to the Police Authorities have no further power over them except to question their representatives. Many Police Authorities are comprised of representatives from a number of different local authorities, making accountability all the more remote.

In the case of the largest Police Authority in Britain, the 'Met' in London, there is no local accountability at all. Since Londoners still have to pay for 'their' force it is taxation without representation.

According to the law, the polie an and control or there sole Chief Constables. Police Authorities may give their Chief Constables advice but they have no authority to tell them what to do. This relationship is the reverse of that between other local government committees and their Chief Officers.

The general idea is that the police must 'preserve their impartiality' (i.e. their bureaucratic independence from, democratic bodies) while being subjected to a. small amount of 'external supervision'. Real power at the local level lies with the Chief Con.el worried about. the issue of police accountability. It is going by default in Scotland. We are not happy either on procedures for complaints against police.

•The Chief Constable and the police are public servants, and in theory should be answerable to the public. However, the machinery for making this work is not very good" , said Norman.

Walter Douglas, Chairman of the Protective Services Committee of Central Regional Council, which is responsible for the police force in Central Region, gave more background.

"The Chief Constable decides. He is accountable to the Police Authority for expenditure, but in reality is more accountable to the Home stable and not the Police Com- stable and not the mittee.

Whatever powers the Police Committee possesses are hemmed in on the one side by the discretion of the Chief Constable and on the other by the overarching supervision of the Home Office.

The main function of Police Authorities is not to represent the people to the police but rather to represent the police to the people. Police committees are intended to be means for winning the consent of the community to decisions already taken outside them either by the police itself or by the Home Office.

Rubber stamp

This legitimising role is written into statute - and it is put into practice by most Police Committees, which serve as little more than rubber stamps for marking public approval.

Cases like this, when local Police Authorities stand up for the people they are meant to represent, have led many members of the police force to campaign for their abolition.

Even a tiny amount of democratic accountability is too much for these people.

As yet the government has not directly taken this step, though its Bill to abolish the Metropolitan counties will have the effect of doing away with those Authorities that have been most critical of the police. They still consider Police Authorities too useful a means of winning public approval for police practice to legislate them entirely out of existence.

Plastic Most Police Authorities do not in any way challenge the authority of the police. Some do not even let the publo into their meetings and most do not encourage the public to come in. Most leave financial expenditure almost entirely to the discretion of the Chief Constable.

More than half of the Polic Authorities who replied to an NCCL questionnaire on plastic bullets refused to supply the information requested, arguing for example that it would be inappropriate ... to discuss in public the level and use of operational practices and equipment."

Secretary. The ratepayers of Central Region pay 50% of the Police Budget, and Central Government, i.e. the taxpayer, pays the other 50%."

The Police Authority is responsible for appointing Senior Officers of the Police, but subject to Home Office ratification. Also subject to Home Office ratification is their responsibility for requiring regular reports from the Norman McEwan stated that the Scottish Council for Civil Liberties felt that this requirement for reports is much underused by local councillors on police authorities.

•There appears to be nothing in the legislation governing police that prevents a local authority from laying down Many do not report back to Many do not report back to their respective councils. Many leave the agenda of meetings up to the police. Many do not even call for reports from the police about controversial aspects of police behaviour.

The Authority has been forced - under threat of a court order — to withdraw its block on police funds. Lord Justice Watkins endorsed the independent powers of the police: 'I want to make sure that the Chief Constable is free to take whatever steps are necessary to maintain law an order" • In other words, the freedom of one man, the police chief, is affirmed at the expense of the unfreedom of all the rest.

Calls for the retirement of Chief Constables have been few and far between.

Where the political will exists - witness the recent case of the South Yorkshire Police Authority rejecting the police budget during the miners' strike, a budget over which the public representatives were not even consulted — local forms of accountability can be used to good effect. We should, however, harbour no illusions about their limitations.

Bypass

The policing of the miners' strike has shown how the police, Home Office bureaucracy and the judiciary, actively supported by the government, can bypass them, but it also shows how they can be used.

But in the past even militant Labour-dominated Police Authorities have tended to cave in under pressure; it requires a countervailing force of the labour movement to stop this happening again.

At the same time, sections of the labour movement have been campaigning for constitutional reform of the police to defend and increase the democratic component within it. The Labour Party is committed to such reform: to grant far greater powers to local Police Authorities, to establish a Police Authority for London, and to make their composition far more democratic. We must make sure that this formal commitment is translated both into active mobilisation in the present and into Labour Government policy in the future. standing orders requiring reports about intended action.

'Before a Chief Constable takes unusual steps he should report to the police author ty. More reports should alse be running of the police.', General required on the general Over 70 people attended the Forum and there were many contributions from the floor of the meeting. David McGeogh and Robert Stephenson were also present as part of the panel of five speakers.

Chairing the meeting, Rowland Sheret, chairperson of Stirling and District Trades Council, explained that it was their intention to hold a further Forum after the completion of the miners' dispute, and again invite the Chief Constable, lan Oliver, who had refused to come this time.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 190

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →