Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

New moves on reselection aim to protect MPs

Socialist Organiser no. 190, 2 August 1984 · scan p. 6 · Terry Connolly · about 1,227 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

The purpose of this campaign is all too clear. The Parliamentary Labour Party, if left to itself, can be relied upon to uphold the capitalist status quo. The record of Labour governments of 1964-70 and 1974-79 should leave little doubt on Those who control the media are well aware that the 'danger' of a Labour government introducing socialist policies depends on the extent of the political influence of Labour Party activists. This is why 'unrepresentative activists' are the target of the media's campaign of vilification and slander.

(Excerpt from Campaign for Labour Party Democracy trving to 'Americanise' the Tahonr P - mr immun model of militant US workers' me NEIL Kinnock's supporters argue that their proposed change in Labour Party procedures for selection of parliamentary candidates will extend democracy.

They propose that constituency Labour Parties should have the choice of the present method - selection through the General Committee of delegates from ward Labour Parties, trade union branches. and other affiliated groups -or another. Under the alternative method, members would and the ward Ward meetings vote in their votes would be totted up.

The proposals are a shift towards the 'one member one vote' postal ballot system which the present leaders of the SDP pushed for before their departure from the Tabour Party..

They are a limited shift. Many of the limitations have been introduced in response to criticisms made of the original SDP scheme * The vote will be either at ward meetings, or at a constituency aggregate meeting, or by postal ballot — 'if a General Committee so decides, PETER Shore in Bethnal Green and Stepney is one of the Labour MPs most keenly defended by the Fleet Street press agairse his local Labour Sara Das some modes criticas membership bas I te p. dad the party HE IST IT DE TIMES. NIM and Is icadershin bare farther desperal ite divide berseer him and majority opinion in the party.

Local party members criticise not only Shore's right-wing views - like his support for a wages squeeze, and his outColin Foster and John vote on the Labour Party National Executive for the pro. posals was a straight right-left split.

Motive

The immediate motive for the proposals - as newspapers like the Daily Mirror have made very clear — is to help out some sitting Labour MPs in danger of de-selection by their local Labour Party activists. People like Frank Field in Birkenhead and Peter Shore in Bethnal Green and Stepney have aroused anger among local Labour Party activists by their disregard for local and national Labour policy. But they obviously hope that under the individual ballot scheme they can wheel out sutficient inactive and relatively conservative members to vote for them.

Far from the motive of the proposals being to extend democracy, it is to protect the established elite.

There are other strong reasons for rejecting the proposals at Labour Party conference in early October.

The proposals would make the selection procedures extremely complex and quite illogical (if individual ballot is better, then why not have it for all constituencies, and why not make it a replacement for selection by General Committee rather than an alternative?). They would thus increase the scope for manoeuvres and tactical jiggery. pokery.

Also, the proposals would completely exclude trade union delegates from the selection procedure.

Despite all this; there is undoubtedly some rank and file support in the Labour Party for the notion of deciding by individual ballot. Many constituency Labour Parties decided to use individual hallos it the party leadership contestlasi rear.

There is a serioas political izIzes: di stake dare be de ais of the cument Activist Rise preses: ser-up. Hos paT. members rarel! or never attend meetings. Quite often members will be wheeled out once a year to vote for GC delegates, and never attend otherwise. Purpose that score.

privilege anc HE Lebour Party was born to end the Micted minery, ine quality which unemployment upon Britain.

4tP.т BANDER sind thed de lhan & sear hintersa Metlich suldirr heing diNrd ir Arst cinx than trrit.nt pron... Protes ir •Il tar diemals and liberty se calmans tarnal and a il atlaard the wHich ca lip the nem.

TURN TO PAGE TWO So what is the fundamental argument against the "indiv¡dual ballot' proposals?

The issue is posed differently in the unions and in the Labour Party. The unions should, and in some sectors do, include all workers in an industry or trade. They are not meant to be selective bodies of activists. Moreover, in the unions, though workplace meetings, there is a real chance of gathering all the members to take part in an all-inclusive democratic process.

A political party — even a broad federal party like the Labour Party — has to oe different. The whole purpose of a political party is to be a selection of more committed, more politically-minded, more active people.

Reason

Actually the fundamental reason why no scheme or procedure in the present-day. Labour Party can ever be properly democratic is the low general level of activity. So long as that low general level of activity continues, there will be a choice between schemes where activists represent members who have little notion of what is done in their name, or systems where any real accountability is impossible because decision-making is in the hands of those who are un-involved, un-informed, and thus easy prey to dema. gogy and media influence.

No constitutional system the the will change that grim choice -only an increased level of activity can. But not all constitutional systems are equally bad, and not all have the same implications for the prospects of increasing the level of activity.

The essence of the various individual ballot schemes is that the established Parliamentary leaders try to find a way to rally the passive membership behind them and bypass the activists. They provide no real democracy, and no chance of building a more active party.

The delegate structure can, however, be linked with a drive for accountability, for regular report-backs and mandating and right of recall of delegates, and for building large, active, lively: ward branches. It can be linked with an effort to establish close relations with trade unionists through trade union branch and Labour Party workplace branch delegates who regularly report back and seek mandates.

The delegate structure gives every member a vote, too -all they have to do is turn up to their branch meetings and help elect and mandate the delegates. What is special about the individual ballot schemes is that they cut out all the dimensions of democracy except voting. And by doing so they cut against the possibility of developing the Labour Party into a fighting socialist party.

Democracy is much mure than voting. And the rightwing proposal would tend to reduce democracy to votes and no more.

Voting, of course, is essential to democracy. But it is not sufficient.

Karl Marx wrote of the Paris Commune, when the workers seized power in Paris in 1871: 'Instead of deciding once in three or six years which member of the ruling class was to misrepresent the people in Parliament, universal suffrage was to serve the people...

----- pull-quotes -----

With his showbiz style, and now the move towards something like 'primal tion of Parliamentary candidates, Ne

ballot papers could be distri- ----Tower

circular). Marror

stop socialist policies

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 190

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →