Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[AL CONGRESO DER 1. RICK MATTHEWS (IFL) THE…]

Socialist Organiser no. 190, 2 August 1984 · scan p. 8 · Alan Johnson · about 1,321 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

AL CONGRESO DER 1. RICK MATTHEWS (IFL)

THE ITV documentary series 'Cuba - 25 years of Revolution' (Thursdays, 9.30pm) will anger both those who see Cuba as a 'Caribbean Gulag' and those on the Left who tend to go starry-eyed at the sight of all that olive-green. Both views, the six-part series will tell us, are off the mark.

The viewer is told of massive improvements in health care and education, and the rigid state censorship of what is taught and read. Of how the shackles of US imperialism have been broken, but total dependence on the Russian economy has replaced them.

The programme is tossed from side to side by this. One minute we are told, "people respect themselves now, know why they are doing what they are doing" , and a minute later that "no opportunity is ever given to any voice of dissent"

This only reflects the real contradictions of Cuba's development since the revolution.

Pre-revolutionary Cuba was completely subordinated to the needs of the US economy. 83% of cultivated land was under sugar, and most of the sugar was sold to the US. A small landowning class owned 70% it the land, in league with an even smaller class of bosses Alan Johnson examines the arguments about Cuba reliant on US capital.

Cuba was more urban than rural. The majority in the countryside were not small peasants but a rural working class — suffering massive unemployment, low wages, and atrocious conditions.

There was a revolutionary nationalist tradition from which Castro started. In 1933, following an uprising, the constitutional democrat Grau San Martin held office for 100 days before a military coup led by Batista (and backed by the US) toppled him. This lesson was not lost on Castro.

Politically the July 26 Movement, the movement Castro built to fight Batista, was nationalist, not socialist (though some of its leading members were socialists). Castro declared in 1956, Foreign investment will always be welcome and secure here". But at the same time he was employing revolutionary armed struggle to overthrow the dictatorship. - The July 26 Movement contained both people like Che Guevara whọ looked to overthrowing capitalism, and vicious anti-communists like Matos and Perez.

• After two years of civil war; Batista was overthrown in January 1959. Nationalist bosses and revolutionaries alike cheered, so hated was the dictatorship and so narrow its support in Cuba. The old state machine — always rickety and corrupt - was smashed and replaced by the revolutionary forces.

The battle for control of the revolution began straight away. The left wing of the July 26 Movement began granting the demands of the workers and peasants. In February 1959 22,500 peasants were awarded 67 acre plots. The right wing held up reform.

Castro tried to hold a balance. He denounced strikes for higher wages and encouragement of land seizures as 'antirevolutionary'.

Reform But he could not sit in the middle for long. When the US and Cuban bosses attacked his moderate capitalist land reform, he had to move against them or renounce the whole social programme of the revolution. The organised expression of the demands of the armed working class and peasants, the internal sabotage of the Cuban bosses and the economic blockade launched by the US, forced Castro to choose. He chose to break with capitalism - and he could do so because the old state machine had been smashed and replaced by a new power based on armed workers and peasants.

However; the direct power of the working class was not established. The July 26 Movement was a military force, not a democratic political movement. And from the early '60s, progressively, USSR influence worked to push Cubà towards a political structure similar to the USSR's.

Cuba today is ruled not by the workers and peasants but by a bureaucracy, undoubtedly popular, but standing above and against any expression of workers' self-activity.

In 1961, the trade unions were reorganised from above to ensure cooperation in fulfilling government production goals. In. 1962 identity cards were introduced for workers, and stringent laws on labour discipline. In 1964-5 a law was introduced which, in the words of Martinez Sanchez, Minister of Labour, would: "strengthen labour discipline and increase pro duction and productivity. It will be applied to the kind of worker who is a residue of exploiting society...

"We still find workers who have not take the revolutionary step and tend to discuss and protest any measure coming from the administration"

All this was done, not as an effort of self-discipline by the workers, but by an elite from above.

The process of bureaucratisation got worse from the late 1960s, as Cuba abandoned its attempts to spread revolution throughout Latin America and dropped its limited criticisms workers fighting to set up Solidarnosc-type union Cuba had been jailed.

The US war threat has indeed led to a strengthening of the Committees for the Defence of the Revolution (CDRs) and the militia. Two million women volunteered for service in the militia in 1982 alone. Cuba claims a six million strong 'fighting machine' from a population of ten million.

However, control lies with the bureaucracy and not the workers. The leadership of the CDRs is appointed through the central bureaucracy of the Communist Party. They have no powers to formulate policies. Their function is to defend the revolution and to report on any working-class opposition to the regime.

CDR membership is often a necessity to get an appointment, a better job, or scarce commodities. Cuba's most popular TV programme, Parabailar (For Dancing), is open only to those who participate in voluntary labour and the CDRs!

Many on the lett point to the institutions of 'Popular Power' established in the late 1970s as evidence that the Castro regime is a socialist democracy. In theory they are open, elected, legislative bodies at national, provincial and municipal levels.

Parties

The practice is somewhat different, however. At no level is there the right to form alternative political parties. No comprehensive alternative to the Cuban Communist Party policy can be presented.

Only municipal representatives are elected. At this level no candidate is allowed to campaign or to put forward legislative proposals to the electorate. When elected, they cannot discuss national or provincial matters. Their job is to enact the decisions of the higher assemblies.

The provincial assembly is to a 8-person Executive Committee which appoints the Council of Ministers. The core members in all these top committees are the same people in each case - the Cuban Communist Party Politburo. The CP itself, taken over by the Castroites by 1965, has had two congresses since 1959!

On the international front, since the late 1960s Castro has consistently supported the Communist Parties of the region in their strategy of alignment with the national bourgeoisie in a 'two-stage revolution' (first 'nationaldemocratic'. ', second socialist). He has even promoted the fiction that Cuba itself passed through these two stages after January 1959.

Cuba has been a force for pushing the El Salvadorean revolutionaries into an alliance with the liberal: bourgeoisie. It has a friendly attitude to the ruling party of the most powerful bourgeoisie in the area, Mexico's PRI.

Solidarnose

Most recently Castro supported the crackdown on Solidarnose in Poland.

Judging from the first programme, the TV series will nave an approach of 'on the one hand, on the other hand'. Socialists cannot afford this approach.

A bureaucracy rules in Cuba, denying the working class its right to organise and control its life. We must fight both to defend the Cuban revolution (its post-capitalist economy, its massive gains in health and education, its marginal improvements in women's rights) from US attack, and also solidarise with the workers and peasants of Cuba against the bureau"cracy which stands above them usurping their power.

These two tasks go hand in hand. Trotsky had nothing but contempt for those 'Friends of the USSR' who cheered the latest pig-iron

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 190

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →