Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Trade unions and

Socialist Organiser no. 190, 2 August 1984 · scan p. 10 · about 846 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

"Full-time trade union officials, even if they start out militant. are generally swaved by their social nosition which is middlo class rather than working class... " TUC leaders at the Tolpuddle Martyrs Anniversary.

This week Martin Thomas picks up the thread from his article in no.188 on the eco nomics of capitalism.

The rich get richer, and the state machine serves their interests.

But why does the working class put up with it? Brute repression is only part of the reason.

THE reason most often cited for the ideological power of the ruling class is the bias of the media.

This is half the truth. But it is dangerous to take it for the whole truth.

Doing so leads either to hopelessness or elitism. If the media are all-powerful, then how can we hope even to change the media, let alone the whole of society? And if the mass of the working class is totally befuddled by the media, then the minority of socialists who unaccountably have escaped that befuddlement are left with no choice but to manipulate and manoeuvre the majority, rather than hopelessly trying to convince them.

In fact workers are perfectly able to disagree with what they read in the press or see on TV. If they were not, we would never have had a Labour government. . Also, it is just not true that the media totally deny workers access to alternative points of view. Yes: all the press and IV assume that a strike is bad news and a sell-out settlement is good news. You would expect them to, given the class position of the people who con-. trol them.

But the system is not leakproof. A very large number of workers have heard or read socialist and trade union points of view. And a lot of information does get through the official media: the pictures STEFANO CAGNONI (IFLJ Arguing AU for permanent organisations, most of which are officially committed to an alternative society — socialism.

So why does the majority of the working class continue in practice to accept capitalism?

Last week's article mentioned a special feature of capitalist exploitation: that it arises from economic relations which are formally quite free and equal. All labour appears to be paid for. Workers appear to get "a fair day's wage for a fair day's work" - and, as Marx explained, it is fair by the standards of the system.

•'What is 'a fair distribution'? ", Marx asked socialists who put forward this slogan. it undermines the individualism on which the ideology of capitalism rests.

As long as workers see themselves as individuals, or sectional groups, selling their labour power at the going rate, the system appears fair. When a struggle becomes a general class confrontation, and workers identify themselves as part of one class counterposed to another, the appearance of fairness disappears.

In that sense the working class spontaneously moves towards socialism. It does not, however, automatically arrive at effective socialist conclusions. That depends on the ing class, and which pushes them towards elitist, compromise-mongering politics.

And they have a tremendous influence on the working class because they are the people most closely tied to the working class who have the opportunity and disposition to develop and promote general theories.

The full time trade union officials can and do use their position to limit, disperse, and betray struggles, so that they demoralise workers rather than inspiring them. And even when they lead struggles militantly, the general political perspective they tie them into AS A step in launching the journal as a national organisation, the second National Briefing conference on July 28 was a rather stumbling one.

The 40-odd Briefing supporters there were generally in favour of turning the network of local newsletters in the Labour Party into some sort of loose national organisation, but what sort was left unclear.

Socialist Action supporters who made up almost half the meeting had a blueprint for Briefing becoming the centre of a broad current linking left-wing campaign groups of all sorts.

It was portrayed as the one organisation to which Labour Party based bodies like the Women's Action Committee, the black sections steering committee, the Labour Committee on Ireland, the Lesbian and Gay YS, etc. would all turn.

Most Briefing supporters at the conference saw this whole approach as rather naive and dangerous.

The Brighton Briefing group argued for a 'harder' national network on definite politics rather than merging Briefing into an unclear left alliance.

All the grand ideas from Socialist Action came down in the end to an unsuccessful attempt to get the conference to endorse their open letter on youth: they wanted to organise an opposition in the Labour Party Young Socialists on the basis of attacking Militant for not being activist enough (rather than counterposing a comprehensive set of politics to them), and appeal to the rest of the Left to pitch into the LPYS against Militant.

The big gap between the success of the various local Briefings as newsletters in he

----- pull-quotes -----

is an inadequate one. way orwarc

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 190

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →