Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Call Kinnock to order!

Socialist Organiser no. 193, 23 August 1984 · scan p. 2 · about 1,570 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 2

Stalinism upside down Labour leading the Tories by 39% to 36%. It also found that those who felt Kinnock was proving to be a good Labour leader had fallen to 37%, as against 43% in July. 44% positively thought he was proving to be bad.

This decline is a bit of a shock for Kinnock and the that Kinnock, the sanitised and de-politicised blue-eyed boy-wonder would do Labour a power of good.

So Kinnock's advisors are developing a new image for him, intended to dispel the accusation that he is politically lightweight. In place of the playboy who appears in pop videos, Kinnock is to make a series of hard' political speeches over the next year.

The miners' strike is obviously a headache. Kinnock is terrified both of losing votes by making too firm a commitment to the miners, and of doing damage to his credibility by remaining too distant. So far he has combined lukewarm verbal support with treacherous condemnation of the miners' violence on picket lines.

His refusal to be firm 1 and principled has won him the contempt of most striking Part of the new 'Kinnock means business' image, apparently, is the attempt to clamp down on the left in the Labour Party, beginning by introducing the option of new selection procedures.

Kinnock is being helped and prodded by the campaign launched by union-busting Labour Party member Robert Maxwell's Daily Mirror.

In fact, though, the new rules - which devolve the actual decisions about selecVicki and Robert Smails from Rhodesia village in Notts spoke to Sue Carlyle about Neil Kinnock. Robert is a member of the NUM South Yorks Area, living in Nottinghamshire.

Vicki: What about Kinnock?! He's a waste of time - well in my opinion he is. He's sat on the lence, watching which way the wind blows. One minute he's on the miners' side, the next minute he's on the other side. I just don't know about Neil Kinnock.

I don't think the whole of the Labour Party are like him. Some of the Labour Party is like that. but there's a few that have come out firmly on our side, and they are brilliant - Tony Benn, Dennis Skinner, people like that.

Rob: The difference between Dennis Skinner and Neil Kinnock is that Dennis Skinner knows whose side he's on but Kinnock doesn't. Apart from thai Skinner's not only been brought up amongst us, he's actually come and seen what the fight's about instead of stopping down' in London.

Kinnock's not really a leader he? Well I don't think he is relatively timid. It is more a focus for the soft-left and right wing to organise around in localities than a head-on fight.

It is, however, an indication of the direction in which Kinnock is going. The idea that many on the left had last October, that Kinnock's leadership was at once a victory for the left and a way to unite, is being proved completely false.

Kinnock is not interested in unity to fight the Tories and for working class interests. He is interested in isolating and defeating the left who do want to fight, to support the miners and defeat the Tories.

The serious Labour Party left must treat Kinnock's latest manoeuvrings as a warning of what to expect. We must get these softer left-wingers who backed Kinnock for the leadership to draw up an honest balance sheet of his leadership so far.

The miners' strike is an acid test. A Labour leader who proves himself no good in such a class battle will never be good for anything the labour movement needs doing.

Kinnock's attempt to undermine re-selection must be defeated at this year's Labour Party conference. Kinnock must be called to order.

The leadership should have the conviction to come out and back us or come out and deny us - one way or the other.

On TV the other day Eric Heffer was after everyone donating a day's wage, which is a good thing, but it would be better if it were given freely, without any begrudging.

As I see it in this strike, we're in a war. There's no getting away from it. Don't get me wrong, don't condone a lot of this violence to scabs cars and the like. but nine times out of ten the violence is staried by the police anyway.

But when it boils down lo it and when it comes to the crunch we are in a war, a class war, a war for our jobs. You've got lo get angry about it to win the war. I mean we could all stand back and do nothing ... but if we all stopped at home we'd never win. After live months I feel bloody angry.

Every time Neil Kinnock comes out and condemns pickets. he should come out and see for himsell. He i'd know what if leels like if he w ent to a picket line.

"What is needed is for magistrates to start meting out penalties that are consistent with the level of violence. Clearly they are doing nothing but slapping the wrists of people when they put £5. or €50 fines on.

"The magistrates are entitled to levy prison sentences on people who get themselves involved" in that way to make it clear that our society is not going to stand for this sort of thing."

Who said that? Some spluttering Tory gent from the Shires? In fact it was last year's President of the TUC, Mr Frank Chapple, You will remember Jack London's famous definition of a scab. "After God had made the alligator and the rattlesnake and the slimy toad he then gathered up the left-overs and made a scab."

But do you know what He did then? He used the venom dripping rattlesnake's tongue to scrape the droppings off the floor and with the resulting poisonous goo he made Frank Chapple.

Chapple and the late Leslie Cannon were given control of the Electrical Trades Union by the courts after the incumbent leaders - who were members of the Communist Party - were declared to have got tổ power by ballot rigging. Since then they have run this union for twenty years as their own small version of a police state.

Union members are tyrannised over and subjected to vicious disciplinary procedures by the union leaders who pay more heed to the bosses and governments than to their members.

The ETU leaders are now the pioneers in negotiating binding no-strike union recognition deals, especially with foreign companies in Britain. They will lead the fight at the forthcoming TUC conference against solidarity with the miners. Chapple supports the anti-union SDP.

The good news is that Chapple is due to retire soon. That will be a good day for the British working class movement.

There is a cruious twist to the Chapple story. He was once a Communist - or rather a Stalinist counterfeit of a Communist. He left the Communist Party only in 1956, when many thousands of members of the then sizeable British CP resigned in protest when the Russians - with CPGB Chapple support - sent their soldiers and tanks to crush the Hungarian anti-Stalinist revolution.

Chapple and Cannon had got their training as hard-nosed machine operators in the CP. In fact Frank Chapple first learned to be a strikebreaker in the CP!

During World War Two, the CP was committed to boosting production, bitterly opposed to all strikes and tried to break strikes that occurred.

• Those were the days when Party Secretary Harry Pollitt could publicly declare that "Today it is the class conscious worker who will cross the picket line."

It was the time when the then very powerful US CP campaigned to have striking American coalminers conscripted and put under military discipline as a means of forcing them back to work.

This phase reached its peak in 1945 when the British CP was to the right of the right wing of the Labour Party. It opposed the Labour Party decision to break the wartime coalition and go for a Labour government. Instead of a Labour government the CP wanted a coalition of 'Labour, Liberals and Progressive Tories' Winston Churchill and Anthony Eden were the *progressive Tories!

The CP didn't become left and militant again until about 1947, when the cold war got serious. Many of the things the right wing of the CP say today, like, for example, the defeatist mouthings of Professor Eric Hobsbawm, are an identifiable throwback to those days.

Chapple and Cannon never forgot their basic Stalinist training of those days. When they went over to the right wing in the late '50s they were nothing but Stalinists who had turned themselves inside out. They served different masters with the old methods of bureaucratic gangsterism.

Chapple is now outspokenly hostile to Stalinism. He often says things which would come better from the trade union left but which nevertheless need to be said. His is a bourgeois anti-Stalinand anti-Communism in contrast to the working class socialist hatred and condemnation of police state Stalinism to be found, for example, in the pages of Socialist Organiser.

The irony of it is that if you turned this dirty little scoundrel upside down you'd probably see it plain and clear still stamped on his bum: 'Made in Moscow' .: -

----- pull-quotes -----

Labour leadership, and for those in the party who insisted

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 193

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →