Nicaragua: elections and US lies
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-08-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
BRITAIN OUT OF IRELAND Over 3,000 peopie marched from Hyde Park to Jubilee Gardens in London last Saturday, August 18, protesting at the continuing occupation of Northern Ireland by British troops. The occasion was the 15th anniversary of the sending in of the army. The demonstration also focussed on the murder of Sean Downes by the RUČ the previous Sunday NICARAGUA goes to the polls in November. But most of the important bourgeois opposition parties, some of them linked to the US CIA, who have long been clamouring for elections, are refusing to take part. This is because they know that the Sandinista government is sure to win, and that it can win more or less fairly.
By not taking part in the election they hope to avoid giving it credibility and no doubt they will say afterwards that the election was a sham.
Their boycott makes a government victory even more certain.
Arturo Cruz, a former Nicaraguan ambassador to the US, and an ex-member of the Sandinista government, was reckoned by many commentators to be the likeliest challenge to the Sandinistas.
1969-1984 Sandinistas triumph over Somoza, 1979 Part of Cruz's programme was for 'dialogue' with the US-backed 'contras, the guerrillas waging war on the borders of Nicaragua, some of whom are former thugs of the old Somoza dictatorship.
He established a political party - Democratic Coordinator' composed of an alliance of four parties, two trade unions and private businessmen.
Since the Sandinistas predictably refused to hold such a 'dialogue, Democratic Coordinator has withdrawn from the election and Cruz has returned to Washington.
Opposition
Six opposition parties are standing - three to the right of the government and three, apparently, to its left. None are likely to pick up much support, although they will probably pick up a few seats in the 90-member assembly.
94% of the eligible population have registered to vote; and the voting age has been lowered to sixteen. In particular it is revolutionary youth who are likely to give the Sandinistas their majority.
The right wing parties are alleging government obstruction of their campaign, but it is too early to judge. What is certain is that the Sandinistas do have, and will prove to have, a popular mandate: Their victory will go a long way to disproving the hypocritical lies of the US that the Nicaraguan government does not have the support of the Nicaraguan people.
Scan page 9
Socialist Organiser no. 193. August 23, 1984 Page 9 the war Clive Bradley reviews "Argentina - The Malvinas the End of Military Rule" by Alejandro Dabat Luis Lorenzano, published by Verso at £5.95. and WHEN the Tories took Britain to war against Argentina in the spring of 1982, the first concern of most socialists was to argue and campaign against the Tories and oppose their war.
For it was a sickening adventure designed to restore the prestige of British imperialism and boost the popularity of the Thatcher government.
The 'Falklands factor' - a potent brew of national pride amounting to chauvinism -certainly helped the Tories win last year's election.
One reason why was that the leaders of the labour movement did not fight the beat-the-drums chauvinism of the Tories and thereby helped them cash in on the war.
Some left wing' intellectuals, like Eric Hobsbawm of the Communist Party, afterwards even drew the ridiculous conclusion that what the war proved was the need for socialists to compete with the Dabat and Lorenzano put forward an impassioned case against Argentinian nationalism, which pits them politically and theoretically against many of the myths of the Latin American and international left. Many of the political and theoretical points they make are similar or identical to what Socialist Organiser supporters said during the war and in its immediate aftermath.
The first point of their argument would be hotly contested not only by Argentine nationalists, but also by the majority of those in the world today who call themselves Tories on their own terms -to try to be more nationalist than they are.
Socialist Organiser campaigned against the war, and argued that a victory for Britain was a defeat for British workers.
The re-election of the Tories proved us right about that. But we argued that it was the job of Argentinian workers to oppose their own ruling class as well. That the seizure of the Falklands/ Malvinas islands was not part of a genuine national liberation struggle but & reactionary, nationalist adventure.
For the Argentinian bourgeoisie and the ruling military junta, the Falklands war served the same purpose as it did for the British ruling class.
This book, written by two Argentinian socialists living in exile in Mexico argues that the Argentinian working class should have opposed the junta's war.
by many socialists are at odds both with reality and with the classical Marxist positions.
As they put it, "the right to national self-determination ... is a political claim of a democratic character which has nothing to do with economic or cultural nationalism" (p.9, emphasis in original).
Party THE Tory 'War Cabinet' of 1982 lied to the House of Commons about its battle plans in the South Atlantic.
Mrs Thatcher has continued to lie ever since.
In particular they lied about the circumstances in which the battleship Belgrano went to the bottom of the sea taking 368 of the crew with it.
Secret papers leaked to Labour MP Tam Dalyell suggest that there was a secret decision to 18 Luis Lorenzaro The Sou socialists have defined it as a 'sub-imperialism').
Their second major claim is that 'Britain... plays a completely marginal role in Argentinian political and economic life" (p.1). Therefore; they argue that what they consider to be "Argentina's legitimate claim for the return of the Falklands/Malvinas is a non-essential point, less important than, for example, the recovery of popular sovereignty, the surmounting of the socioeconomic crisis and the establishment of social and political democracy" (p.2).
Dabat and Lorenzano analyse the development of the workers' movement in Argentina. Argentinian capitalism, they argue, is undergoing a deep-rooted crisis which can be resolved either through its destruction and social and political reorganisation under popular, working class control, or through state terror and 'genocide' carried out against the Argentinian extend the sn-called 'exclusion limit' around the Falklands in order to sink the Belgrano.
In fact the Belgrano had been heading for home and therefore was no threat to British lives, when it was sunk.
It was sunk because Mrs Thatcher wanted to undermine a peace initiative then being made by Peru. Nothing but the victory and the prestige and political boost it would bring would satisfy her.
The Argentine military junta th Atlantic war: the sinking of HMS Sheffield Mass strike movements continued after Peron's regime was replace by the military in 1976, particularly in those sections worst hit by the economic crisis. The dictatorship responded with massive repression, carrying out the 'dirty war' in which thousands of people disappeared.
Opposition
The official opposition parties — the bourgeois Radicals, the Peronist Justicialista Party, the Intransigent Party and the Movement for Integration and Development and the Christian Democrats — united in thé Multipartidaria, were forced to lead the mass movement. By the end of 1981 huge demonstrations 50,000 in November opposed the regime. By March 1982 violent confrontations were breaking out throughout the country between the mass movement and an increasingly had invaded the Falklands to head off a rising wave of discontent and opposition within Argentine. In turn, the then very unpopular Thatcher used the war they started to her own political advantage.
In the war, reactionary on both sides, Mrs Thatcher won and went on to the election victory of June 1983; the junta lost and quickly crumbled, opening the way for a restoration of with varying degrees of qualification.
On the main "Trotskyist' group, the PST of Nahuel Moreno, they comment that their position "was pure fantasy... In reality, all these currents supported the war tout court (completely), the rest of their positions being exposed as empty rhetoric"
In varying degrees this was also true of most of those throughout the world who called themselves Trotskyists.
The authors list a number of organisations who opposed the war, including some Trotskyists.
The Tories deliberately con cealed the truth about the sinking of the Belgrano from Parliament at the time and later blocked attempts by a Commons Select Committee to get at the truth.
Now lying is the daily bread of ruling class politics. It is. Mrs Thatcher's trade. But to get caught out blatantly lying to the House of Commons is a serious matter for which mininsters have usually been sacked. This revelation is therefore a serious blow to Mrs Thatcher.
If this is only half true it adds a new dimension to the condemnation deserved by those socialists inside and outside Argentina who supported the junta's war: Not only did they part company with Marxist principles, but they were also stupid victims of the official propaganda of an extremely vicious military dictatorship!
There are, I think, some weaknesses in Dabat's and Lorenzano's position. They argue strongly for the development of a mass anti-militarist movement, independent of the bourgeois parties that could link together the struggle for democracy and the struggle to solve the economic crisis in the interests of the masses -i.e. for socialism. The programme they put forward, however, is very limited and is not fundamentally a revolutionary one.
it calls for price controls rather than working class control over wages; a reduc-
----- pull-quotes -----
THE ENEMY IS AT HOME!RAIL Foin the Socialist BOSSES' Organiser UNIONS
-THE MALVINAS AND THE ENOCFL NUTARY RULE
democracy in Argentina. socialists who supported it,
THE ENEMY IS AT HOME! E Socialist Organiser nON THE STREETS. AGAINSȚ !r91 WAR! BLOODY MARGARET