Victory Is Not
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-08-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Trotskyists.
"Argentina is a politically independent country which is inserted into the world market in a way that combines financial and technological dependence with its emergence as a regional power". (p.1).
The authors take up Marxist arguments "on the national question, and persuasively counter standard left wing assumptions that non-imperialist countries like Argentina necessarily suffer from "national oppression' . What is particularly forceful in their argument is that they locate their analysis firmly in the tradition of Lenin, showing that theories of 'neo-colonialism' or 'semi-colonialism' held
OURS
In other words, assessing political independence is distinct from assessing the relative strength of weakness of particular 'national economies': and from that point of view, Argentina is indisputably an independent state which has developed as a regional power in Latin America (some In the face of this crisis and attempts to drive down working class living standards and destroy the popular organisations, the Argentinian masses have waged a militant struggle against a succession of dictatorships.
In the mid-1970s, a series of mass strikes developed that began to challenge the foundation of the system. In July 1975, action by workers in the capital, Buenos Aires, quickly spread into a national general strike. Known as the 'Rodrigazo' (after the economics minister Celestino Rodrigo against whose policies it was aimed), it lasted for eleven days until Isabel Peron gave in to the workers' terrified repressive state machine.
The junta's adventure in seizing the Falklands/Malvinas islands was intended to head off this movement by reuniting the 'nation' around a 'patriotic' project. It was also, Dabat and Lorenzano argue, an attempt to boost 'the claim of Argentinian monopoly and finance capital to have a major stake in the distribution of the world market, and hence in the oppression and exploitation of proletariats other than their own" (p.79).
It was consequently a completely reactionary war; and the authors have harsh words to say about those Argentinian YOU ARE WRONG.
The authors claim that real Argentine working class support for the war was minimal: "During the two months or more of the conflict there was not a single truly proletarian mass demonstration, not single pro-war demonstration emanating from the rank and file. The workers retreated to their factories and refused to involve themselves in the jingoistic fervour" (p.109). tion in military spending and military salaries rather than abolishing these institutions and arming the masses; and a tax on big capital and landowners, rather than their expropriation.
Their resolute opposition to Argentine nationalism is not in doubt; but sometimes they still use populist and nationalist expressions - and their programme calls for 'the expropriation under workers' control of enterprises acting against the national and popular económy" (p. 192).
Nevertheless, this is an important and valuable book, a healthy tonic antidote to the nationalist myths often passed off as revolutionary socialism.
Scan page 10
193. August 23,