The Mafia and
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-08-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Andrew Hornung reviews "Crime Inc.", 9.00pm Wednesdays, ITV. Last week's episode dealt with the involvenent of organised crime in the American trade union Top: three scenes from the Edgewood strike. Bottom: street battles Deputies attack a crowd of pickets near Pittsburgh, 1923. Photo: Library of movement.
THE huge success of Mario racy, violent tale it told, but in the author's ability to make gangsterism look like nothing more than another version • of the American Dream. In the mob wars no one gets hurt except the other side's soldiers or, occasionally a cop - really also another soldier.
The key to this was the virtual omission of any references to ordinary people: wars are fought without so much as a stray bullet, men become masters but you never see the slaves and fortunes are amassed with nobody coming out the loser except other fortune hunters. It is as if there is a horrific boardgame called "Mob Monopoly" which doesn't affect non-players at all.
Puzzo's preference for cheap thrills and reactionary sentimentalism - albeit accompanied by a great deal of fine observation - was wholly predictable. The author claimed no other purpose than to make a million out of writing a novel.
But, is it not reasonable to expect a little better from ITV's much proclaimed documentary, "Crime Inc. "? Unfortunately, "Crime Inc." isn't better, and its recent section devoted to the involvement of organised crime in the US trade union movement was Puzzo all over again - minus the thrills.
The programme concentrated on Mafia links with transport unions, in the Teamsters Union and in the docks of the eastern seaboard. It focussed on the FRI's successful indictment of several hoods operating out of Miami, an action made possible by using as bait a small-time container-yard operator who had been forced into working with the crooks.
His own workers are invisible. Were they unjonised before the mob arrived or not? What was their reaction to having mobsters on the payroll? Silence. Apart from a single reference to a worker killed reputedly by the nob lor opposing them, the real victims of the hoods are ignored Again, in the section devoted to the Teamsters, a single brief reference was made to a union reform committee, but not enough to counterbalance the cops and robbers focus of the programme.
Other documentaries have managed to paint the real living picture of union corruption, mob violence, rank and file resistance and state activity. "Harlan County USA" , for instance, gives a moving and accurate picture of Tony Boyle's rule over the United Mineworkers of America, his ordering of the slaying of the Yablonsky family, the subsequent victory of the Miller-led coalition that reformed the union and, indeed, that coalition's shortcomings.
The message of the ITV documentary is basically that the FBI is the only agency that can curb the mobsters. This is not only absurd by revolutionary socialist standards, but inconsistent with what other sections of the same documentary series have shown: that the FBI has often worked hand in hand with the Mafia.
According to "Crime Inc" gangsters got their first foothold in US trade unionism when union defence Euards. this evidencet comes from an ex-Mafia boss.
Illustrating this statement were unattributed film clips accompanied by an anonymous voice declaring that what we were watching was a battle between thugs hired by the union and thugs hired by the employers with the pigs in the middle (no, that's not how the voice put it).
Now this is a straightforward lie, if lies can ever be said to be in Minneapolis, 1934. straightforward. The longest of the clips actually showed a shootout between armed deputies, enlisted by the police, and pickets in the 1933 Tube Company Plant near Pittsburg.
As other pictures (not shown by ITV) reveal, the cops played an active part killing pickets and federation, the CIO didn't leave the job only to the deputies, many of whom quite likely were hoods.
What is of greater political strikes. importance is that the period of the Tube Company strike, the tsky gone to sleep, but for ever. been 61 on November 7, 1940. was World War I.
renamed Petrograd).
October revolution then the leader of the newly created Red Army. to lead to their destruction. period of the late Depression ised labour and the employers tiny handful of supporters. years, when the industrial unions who were backed both by the created in the early 1930s were state (cops, national guard and still being shaped, was not charac- deputies) and mobsters. These terised by increased gangster con- clashes, the Autolite strike, the trol over unions. It was character- Flint sit-down, the Akron strike ised by the emergence of a more and others saw the creation of militant, less corrupt trade union organised workers' armed squads.
The best documented and one It was further characterised by of the best organised of these was organisation of armed the "citizen's army" that beat workers' defence squads in many back the bosses in the great Minneapolis Teamsters strike in The Tube Company strike was 1934. only one in a rash of ferocious Of course, to show this class depression clashes between organ- war in its true light would be to invite very different conclusions from those flattering to the FBI.
It would be to show how workers have fought violence with violence and purged their unions themselves of rottenness and corruption, both by gangsters and by reactionary conspiracies like Catholic Action.
To show this, and in the middle of the miners' strike too ... well, that really is asking too But it is really a very modest plea to ask of the ITV to give an account of Mafia involvement in US trade unions which shows the union rank and file both as the with love and gratitude. real victims and as the actual and potential agents of change. After all, even the film had to admit that the FBi took years to make their arrests and that it merely led to one gangster taking over where another had left off.
ITV claim that "Crime Inc." was in the days of my youth. cost a fortune to make. Maybe so.
But so long as it adopts the themes of the cheap dime novel it will be no more than an occasionally titillating and historically trivial documentary.
Scan page 11
Socialist Organiser no. 193. August 23, 1984 Page Extend the scheme locks
----- pull-quotes -----
Puzzo's book, "The God- father", , lay not simply in the