Why strikers should oin the Labour party
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-08-30Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
WE HEAR that scab miners are tearing up their cards in Nottinghamshire.
Most Labour Party activists will say: good riddance! In their own way the scabs thus recognise that the rank and file of the Labour Party is solidly behind the NUM. Local Labour Parties have been levying their members and collecting money, putting up pickets, and sending members to miners' pickets and demonstrations.
The other side of the picture is Labour Party leader Neil Kinnock and his supporters in the Parliamentary Labour Party.
Neil Kinnock lets himself be photographed with Arthur Scargill and expresses sympathy with the miners. He blames the Tories for the strike, not the miners. But at the same time he adds his voice to the chorus of Tory propaganda blaming picket line violence — for which the police are responsible — on the Neil Kinnock thus shamelessly throws the weight of his authority as leader of the political wing of the labour movement into the scales against the miners. He helps give credibility to the dirty class-war propaganda of the Tories, which is aimed to undermine working-class sympathy and solidarity with the miners. And that propaganda is a key Tory weapon in the most vital front. of the miners' strike right now — the fight for solidarity.
Neil Kinnock wants to play the role of a responsible statesman and a future prime minister, and he doesn't mind stabbing the miners in the back if that will help.
Kinnock knows the miners are being smeared and misrepresented. He knows that the only point of view from which the miners who stand up to the armies of police thugs can be condemned is the view that the bosses and their police forces and armies have a right to a monopoly of violence and that the working class does not have the right to defend itself against them when attacked or to go on the offensive against them when the police are being used to herd scabs.
This is either a nakedly and unashamedly upper-class way of looking at the issue — or else it rests on the weaseling and cowardly double standard which allows one law for the rich and powerful and their hired thugs, and a different law for the poor and oppressed. The police have rights, but there are no rights for the miners who are fighting for their livelihoods, for their children's future, and to stop their communities being offered up by Mrs Thatcher as collective human sacrifices to the capitalist god, profit.
Kinnock knows what's what. But he is running scared before the Tories, afraid that some of their vicious smear-propaganda against the miners will stick to him and damage him politically.
This is not only cowardly and pathetic. It is stupid and short-sighted also.
A miners' victory will be a hammer-blow to the Tories. A miners' defeat will inevitably weaken the labour movement and therefore also undermine both Labour' s ability to fight tor vote ind its crediblity. Helping the Tories damage the labour move ment is an over-ambitious fool's way of preparing for the next election.
As one Notts miner said at the Socialist Organiser school last weekend, the danger is that while the scab miners are tearing up Kimock i rang the Kinnock is behaving like the political equivalent of a scab. their Labour Party cards because they are scabs, the militant striking miners will tear theirs up because they think Neil It is understandable that striking miners should demand that Neil Kinnock, the elected leader of the political labour movement, should give them his unqualified support — and that they should feel bitter when he chooses instead to talk out of both sides of his politician's mouth.
Nevertheless, striking miners should not be leaving the Labour Party. They should be flocking into it, to help the serious Left fight the right wing and the Kinnock-spirited 'Left' The trade unions need a reliable, honest, militant and principled political wing, led by leaders who have all those qualities. The Labour Party is the political wing of the trade unions. Miners should take part in the continuing fight to reclaim it for the working class, out of the hands of careerist politicians.
Despite Neil Kinnock, the Labour Party has helped the miners, though of course it would be a far greater help if it had leaders with guts and properly strung backbones — Tony Benn or Eric Heffer or Dennis Skinner, for example.
Militant miners could give the fight for a transformed Labour Party a great boost. For a start, the NUM could strike a powerful blow for a healthier labour movement by clearing out the bats and rodents who inhabit its own parliamentary lumber room. Some of the creatures sent to the House of Commons with NUM sponsorship make Neil Kinnock look good by contrast - men like Roy Mason, or Don Concannon, known to striking Notts miners as "the copper's nark"
But more than that. We can win "he best man lost. Newly elected Labour 'arty leader Neil Kinnock and deputy Loy Hattersley congratulate each other batched by the defeated left wing cand late for leader, Eric Heffer es MIRER this