The best way to fight
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-08-30Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
difficulties between the Coal Board and the NUM"
By • "amicable resolution" he explained, he merely meant "solution acceptable to both the miners and the NCB', • But, especially by this stage in the dispute, it is nonsense to believe there can be a "solution" acceptable to both sides. Not for Milne, though, who concluded by stressing that a "settlement to the strike has to be found"
Scottish miners' leader Mick McGahey stressed the readiness of the NUM to hold talks and the need to 'find a solution, but it must be a principled solution. There will be secret talks but no secret deals."
He also called for "the quickest possible solution, but a principled solution which meets the needs not only of the Scottish miners, but also of the Scottish economy and Mick McGahey.
Dear comrades, By any means necessary! (SO editorial, no. 193). No, not by any means necessary -but by the best means to build working class solidarity against MacGregor, the Tories and their police thugs. The way to do that is to organise serious mass pickets at the targets that matter. Llanwern, Orgreave, Hunterston, the Trent Valley power stations -if these targets were hịt properly by successful and sustained mass pickets the miners' strike would be shortened by months.
It is not guod enough to counterpose the SWP fetish of 'mass pickets and nothing else' to guerrilla actions against scab trucks. You claim "There is no evidence of a drift by militant miners into indiscriminate petty terrorism and away from mass picketing"
Absolutely right, comrades, but only because there has been no consistent mass picketing in the first place. The prime targets have been ignored: the Yorks NUM leaders have shied away from a serious fight at Orgreave; the South Wales leaders have followed suit over Lianwern; the Scottish leaders at Ravenscraig.
None of them have taken the mass picketing of power stations seriously. There have been one or two days when pickets have turned up in numbers, but not the kind of sustained picketing needed to bring these places to a halt.
The editorial's claim that in these circumstances, it is alright to resort to hit and run raids is so much nonsense.
We've had the sabotage, now let's have the kind of picketing we need to stop these places — the kind of mass picketing that socialists throughout the labour movement can build on and use to call for support in their own workplaces. Remember Saltley Gates!
In comradeship, BARCLAY, Cardiff Editor's reply Martin Barclay mixes up a number of things. The subject of the editorial was what attitude we should take to sabotage activities to put scab trucks out of action, etc. An assessment of the state of mass picketing — whether it has been adequate, or needs to be radically stepped up - that is a separate question, which I won't try to deal with here, though I think Martin is mainly right in what he says about it.
There is no evidence that smashing up scab trucks at their bases necessarily diminishes the level of mass picketing. And it is not the same sort of thing as the South Wales decision to go for the stunt of occupying the sequestrators' office in Birmingham instead of a local picket.
Right now the cutting edge of the propaganda war against the miners and against solidarity with the miners focuses on 'violence'. It is necessary to defend the right of the miners to fight back in every way necessary - on the picket lines and, if striking miners so decide, in the loading yards of scab truckers.
That was the point of the editorial.
JOHN O'MAHONY A written appeal for money to help the anti-strike miners is being circulated among chairmen, chief executives and managing directors of major companies. The appeal is thought to have gone to senior people in manufacturing and commercial companies, clearing banks, merchant banks and insurance groups.
The appeal is headed by al quotation from Edmund Burke: "All that is needed for evil to triumph is that good men do nothing." It goes on to point out that striking miners and NUM pickets are receiving financial support from sympathetic local councils, from collections at factory gates and from other sources.
"On the other side are thel Nottinghamshire and other miners who have carried on working," the appeal says. •They are now actively trying to persuade miners in other coalfields to return to work."
"But they are stretched for funds to pay for petrol, telephone bills, postage and printing. They have already scored a significant victory with their injunction against the NUM. However, the legall fees are likely to be very substantial and at a level they cannot possibly afford to meet themselves.
"They therefore need help not least because they are in the front line fighting for what we believe in and they need to know they have friends."
The appeal ends with a request tor recipients to make personal contributions towards the miners' expenses.