Dollar democracy
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-08-30Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Manhattan Island. many people in the US dreamed of an equal society of small property-owners. and cursed Wall Street for spoiling the dream Franklin D Roosevelt co-opted working class militancy in the '30s with his 'New Deal' programme For the first half-century after the United States was founded 200 years ago, its policies were dominated by aristocrats from the longersettled areas. The Democratio Party originated in a revolt against that domination by the more newly-settled West and the middle class in the growing cities of the East.
They elected Andrew Jackson as president in 1828. Jackson — the first president who went 'from a log cabin to the White House" — alarmed the wealthiest citizens by abolishing the Bank of the United States (US equivalent of the Bank of England). "Ever since Iread the history of the South Sea Bubble" , la famous swindle of the 18th century) he explained, "1 have been afraid of banks."
The Democrats - and in particular Martin Van Buren, their leader in New York -originated most of the techniques of modern party politics. The New York Democrats, indeed, believed that efficient party organisation, linked to a "spoils" system for allocating public offices to the election winners was in and of itself democratic. The party policies were secondary; but the party organisation could enable 'the people' to challenge the long-established wealthy families.
Within this doctrine of the supremacy of the party machine, 'the Democrats spread their net wide enough both to win support from a sizeable share of the upper class and to absorb into their ranks the world's first-ever self-proclaimed workers' party.
The fate of the New York Was a Workingmen's Party - which was absorbed into a radical wing of the Democrats in the 1830s — illustrates a recurrent pattern in US politics. It was a populist party, a party aspiring to represent working people in general as against a few rich parasites, rather than a socialist party of class struggle. By its definition, farmers, shopkeepers, even industrial capitalists, were all workers 100.
Such ideas of "people's politics" rather than class politics have been a recurrent theme in US radicalism. PopuThe US, from many points of view, is the most democratic country in the world. Yet this capitalist democracy is an empty democracy - because radical movements have always, so far, been diverted into the two big political machines, Democrats and Republicans. Martin Thomas looks at the history.
lism is always unstable. It tends to go in for quack schemes of social reform, and to be easily hoodwinked by capitalist politicians who can present themselves as "of the In the 19th century there was a real social basis for such politics. Right up to 1880, more people worked on farms in the US than in all, other occupations combined, and as late as 1900 nearly ten million out of a total labour force of 29 million were farmers or their immediate families 'managers and proprietors' With new territory constantly being opened up in the West, every wage worker could hope to become a small proprietor. The ideal of an equal society of small property owners had a real grip.
The Democrats ruled almost without a break from 1828 to the eve of the Civil War in 1861. The issue that led to the rise of America's second big party, the Republicans, was slavery.
The Democrats had never wanted democracy for the blacks (nor for the Indians). Andrew Jackson himself was one of the biggest slaveowners in Tennessee.
The issue became sharp with growing revolts among the slaves and with the opening-up of new territories in the West. Slavery had been legal or illegal in the US according to individual state law. What would happen in the new states?
The Republican Party was formed to resist the extension of slavery. Its initial base was among the settlers of the Northwest, alarmed at the prospect of newly-settled territories being made into slave plantations rather than free homesteads.
Under Abraham Lincoln, it led the Union side in the Civil War of 1861-65. The Democrats split several ways, some frankly supporting slavery, some advocating conciliation, and some supporting Lincoln.
Marx and Engels most enthusiastically acclaimed Liricoln and the anti-slavery war: 'The workingmen of Europe felt instinctively that the star-spangled banner carried the destiny of their class". So how did the party of Lincoln become the party of Richard Nixon and Ronald Reagan?
The Republicans dominated US politics from 1860 through to 1884, with the Democrats discredited.
The Radical Republicans — who initially had the upper hand - imposed military governors on the southern states, to retorm them by force. Blacks were given the right to vote and brought into politics, universal free education was established, and other social reforms pushed through.
But this regime of Reconstruction in the South soon degenerated disastrously. Many of the officials who had moved down from the North used the chance to line their own pockets. And during the hectic boom period of 1865-73 corruption was even worse in the Northern states. One city politician ripped off maybe $200 million from New York.
Large-scale industrial capitalism was growing fast out of the "property-owning democracy". By the mid-1870s, the Republicans were the party of big business and the Democrats could come forward once made a lot of their hostility to British and Jewish bankers. (The US in the 19th century had a huge foreign debt).
But what led the Populists finally into being captured by the Democratic Party was their search for an economic quack remedy which would somehow give them an economy based on individual profit without its oppressive capitalist consequences. They hit on the idea of bi-metallism.
The idea was this. The farmers were crippled by debts and high interest rates. They demanded that silver be coined for money, as well as CONTINUED NEXT PAGE