Two sorts of democracy
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-08-30Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
FRIEDRICH Engels, writing in 1891, saw the USA as an example of the limitations of even the best capitalist democracy. At that time the USA did not even have a sizeable permanent state bureaucracy or standing army. Yet Engels saw a radical difference between the USA's democracy and the workers' democracy created in the Paris Commune, when the working class took power in Paris for two NOWHERE do "politicians" form a more separate and powerful section of the nation than precisely in North America. There, each of the two major parties which alternately succeed each other in power is itself in turn controlled by people who make a business of politics, who speculate on seats in the legislative assemblies of the Union as well as of the separate states, or who make a living by carrying on agitation for their party and on its victory are rewarded with positions:..
It is precisely in America that we see best how there takes place this process of the state power making itself independent in relation to society, whose mere instrument it was originally intended to be. Here there exists no dynasty, no nobility, no standing army, beyond the few men keeping watch on the Indians, no bureaucracy with permanent posts or the right to pensions. And nevertheless we find here two great gangs of political speculators, who alternately take possession of the state power and exploit it by the most corrupt means Against this transformation of the state and the organs of the state from servants of society into masters of society - an inevitable transformation in all previous states - the Commune made use of two infallible means. In the first place, it filled all posts - administrative, judicial and educational - by election on the basis of universal suffrage of all concerned, subject to the right of recall at any time by the same electors. And, in the second place, all officials, high or low, were paid only the wages received by other workers... In this way an effective barrier to place-hunting and careerism was set up, even apart from the binding mandates to delegates to represThis shattering of the former state power and its replacement by a new and truly democratic one is described in detail again as the party of reform.
Around the turn of the century both parties revived themselves by absorbing new waves of populist radicalism.
The Populist party, founded in 1890, declared in its platform: 'The fruits of the toil of millions are boldly stolen to build up colossal fortunes for a few ... From the same prolific womb of governmental injustice we breed two classes - paupers and millionaires There were many elements of genuine radicalism in this party. It grew out of militant farmers' movements in the South which had united black tenant farmers with whites. Although its main base was in the West, it had some strength in the South, too: and Populists courageously argued against racism because it divided the working people. They demanded an 8 hour working day and public ownership of the railways.
But they were still populist - based on the impossible dream of a society of independent small producers.
The profiteering of Wall Street and the great corporations was an inevitable consequence of the market economy; but the populists hoped somehow to lop off the wealthy few at the top and keep their "property-owning democracy" in its primitive virtue.
The Populists also tended towards nationalism: immigration controls were one of their major demands, and they: months in 1871. and for the most corrupt ends.... entative bodies which were added besides.
(by Marx]. From Engels' Introduction to 'The Civil War in France, by Karl Marx.
Scan page 9
Eugene Debs got nearly one million votes as Socialist candidate for pre 1912. But the US working class is still crippled politically by not havin William Jennings Bryan drew the late 19th century Populist movement under the Democrats' wing gold, to increase the supply of money, make credit easier, and break the power banks.
The silver-mining capitalists supported this idea too, for their own reasons! And they built up a powerful lobby within the Democratic Party. By 1896 the 'Silver Democrats' had the upper hand, nominating William Jennings Bryan for president.
Bryan declared: 'You come to us and tell us that the great cities are in favour of the gold standard: we reply that the great cities rest upon our broad and fertile prairies. Burn down your cities and leave our farms, and your cities will springup again as if by magic; but destroy our farms and the grass will grow in the streets of every city in the country ...
Cross of gold
'Having behind us the producing masses of the nation • we wil answer their demands for a gold standard by saying to them: You shall not press down upon the brow of labour this crown of thorns, you shall not crucify mankind upon a cross of gold."
That was enough for most of the Populists.
Bryan never won the presidency, but he did become Secretary of State under Woodrow Wilson in 1912. His last appearance in public life was to speak for the prosecution in the Scopes trial of 1925, in which a school teacher was indicted for teaching the theory of evolution, contrary to the Bible.
The remarkable thing is how many of Bryan's ideas - the vague identification with the 'producing masses' , the praise for small-town virtues as against the big cities, the religious fundamentalism — are still alive, in diluted form, in US politics, even though today nearly 80% of the American people live in cities.
They can be found in Reagan's party, and were a theme of Goldwater's: 'Sometimes I think this country would be better off it we could just saw off the Eastern seaboard and let it float out to sea:" .
The Republicans had _also in a milder form, with the Progressive movement. Its themes were municipal reform, welfare measures, trust-busting, and imperialism.
Lenin defined imperialism as the monopoly stage of capitalism. The Progressives wanted imperialism without the monopolies. They presented themselves as champions of the nation and the common people - and, implicitly, of ordinary capitalism — against monopoly capitalism. But capitalism breeds monopolies like swamps breed disease. They got the empire: the Philippines were made a US colony (after two years of war against the Filipinos); so was Puerto Rico. ' Cuba and Panama, and to varying extents much of Central America were made semi-colonies. But the trusts were not busted. •Theodore Roosevelt, Progressive Republican president in 1905-8, made a private agreement with the great JP Morgan business empire. The Morgan companies would cooperate with anti-trust investigations in return for a promise that they would not be harmed.
By 1920 the Progressives had faded and both parties had become solidly conservative. But their talent for absorbing and deflecting radicąlism had not been exhausted.
In 1932 Franklin D Roosevelt won the presidency for the Deincrats with a campaign criticising the Republican, Herbert Hoover, as a spendthrift. But — under the pressure of the great slump of the '30s, when millions were living in shanty-towns round the cities of the US - he proved, paradoxically, more radical in office than he promised. The New Deal was pushed through, with big public-spending programmes, public works, and welfare measures.
The working class won some benefits from the New Deal. More important, however, was that the New Deal Democrats managed to absorb the most promising moves yet by the US working class towards independent politics.
The US trade union movement expanded enormously and waged huge struggles in the mid-'30s; but it never got to the point of forming its own labour party. Many factors led to that result, including the policy of the Communist Party, which still had the reputation of a genuinely revolutionary party but in fact had been corrupted and diverted by Stalinism. The result, however,. was that yet another move for radical politics had been absorbed, via the ideology of populism, into the existing system.
Soon enough the Democratic Party was once again solidly conservative. A Democratic president dropped the atom bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, opend the Cold War, and sent US troops to Korea.
Black revolt
A Democratic Congress passed the anti-union TaftHartley Act in 1947.
Through all the apparently radical phases of the Democratic Party, its most solid voting base had been the white racists of the South. Insofar as blacks had got to vote at all, they had mostly been for the Republicans: But the Democrats' most recent operation in absorbing popular protest has been in the black communities. They are counting on a huge majority of the black vote for Walter Mondale.
The process began in 1948, when Strom Thurmond (now a Republican) led a Southern Democrat split to form "States' Rights" party. But as late as 1960 the Democratic candidate — Kennedy - still had his major base in the South.
It was only in 1964, after great struggles had forced the Democratic administration to do something about implementing civil rights for blacks, that the black vote swung over to the Democrats and the Southern white racist vote to the Republicans.
Class politics
Part of the reason for the character of US polities is the elaborate system of checks and balances built into the constituțion by its 18th century authors, who feared i strong centralised government. The president can obstruct Congress, Congress can obstruct the president, the Supreme Court can obstruct both, and the individual states can obstruct any federal decision. The end result is that change can be brought about only by very militant campaigns -such as the blacks waged in the 1960s — or by behind-the-scenes consensus in the ruling class. Electoral politics is merely the means for gaining consent to whatever has already been decided, and for deciding which contender gets the spoils of office.
But Britain is not so much different. And the leaders of the Labour Party - with all their talk about "common sense" and "the national interest" - use the same sort of debased populism as their stock-in-trade as do US politicians. Our advantage is that the Labour Party, through its trade union connections, is anchored to something other than the career ambitions of its leaders.
Many Labour leaders would like to let slip that anchor. Our job is not only to stop them doing that, but to tip them overboard, and fight for a leadership that. will. represent class politics.
party.
TAKE your pick. Any one of a dozen features of the US Republican Party's recent convention was enough to condemn the leading party in the world's richest, oldest capitalist democracy.
It could be their commercial for Ronald Reagan: brought up with small-town virtues and "pro-defence, pro-America, anti-socialism and antiliberalism' It could be the Republican platform, with its call for the death penalty, for a ban on abortions, and for a return to the economies of the early '30s by putting the dollar back on the gold standards.
Or it could be the well-heeled delegates' wild cheers for every reference to the US invasion of Grenada.
The way the Republican Party presented itself could almost make you think that the Democrats must be better — or at least the lesser evil.
In fact there is little difference between Democrats and Republicans:
Jimmy Carter's Democratic administration launched the new Cold War and the new military build-up long before Reagan took over. The plans to site Cruise and Pershing missiles in Europe, and the US involvement in El Salvador, both date back to Carter's time, as does the Rapid Deployment Force for the Middle East.
The Democratic platform now differs from Reagan's policies mostly in tone and emphasis. It is thoroughly conservative on social questions.
Or look back to 1964. The Republican candidate was Barry Goldwater, a self-proclaimed right wing extremist (''extremism in the defence of liberty is no vice").
Radicals were particularly alarmed by Goldwater's call to extend the US war in Vietnam (then relatively low-key) and bomb North Vietnam.
But what did the Democrats do?
Lyndon B. Johnson — who became president after John F. Kennedy's assassination in 1963 — had already sent US bombers over North Vietnam in August 1964. After his reelection as president, he massively increased the bombing. In May 1965 US combat troops (as distinct from 'military advisers) were officially sent to Vietnam. By the middle of 1968 there were over half a million US troops there. Martin Thomas looks at the Reagan/Mondale contest, and its lessons for us in the The Democrats and the Republicans, in short, are exactly the same sort of party. They both represent the bosses and bankers who rule America. At any given time one will present itself as more liberal, and the other as more conservative, for the purposes ot • electoral competition. Sometimes candidates are liberal when campaigning in one state' and conservative in another — for example, Gary Hart in the contest for the Democratic candidacy.
Generally the Democrats claim to be the liberals. But that means very little.
Neil Kinnock Elections in Britain are less of a sham. But it is only a matter of degree. And Neil Kinnock's moves to reduce the role of the trade unions in the Labour party and to transform the party into more of a personality-oriented electionwinning machine bring us closer to the US situation.
For it is the trade union base of the Labour Party 'which decisively distinguishes it from parties like the US Democratic Party. That may be difficult to believe when we look at the rows of grey-suited, grey-minded bureaucrats at Labour Party conference, but it is true.
Trade unions, however conservative, are firmly rooted in the working class. However sluggish their internal life, they cannot avoid some -00 Two pamphlets summing up the ideas of Socialist Organiser.
Where We Stand - 20p plus 16p postage. 'How to fight the Tories' - 10p plus 16p postage. Or the two together for 45p including postage. From Socialist Organiser, 28 Middle Lane, London N8 concern for debating as policies, from the view of the working rather than just devis ulas which can attt support because they satisty "the peol general, all classes to This or that radic at this or that time v save the Labour Pa degeneration if its li the unions were cut.
Showbiz Capitalist politics a to some extent an e dupery, and the l highest stage of cap this respect. A bett ted population than any other in the wor long tradition of quits tial democratic rig duces something scarcely politics at i specialised branch of The Democratic ec in several days of pro had just four hours o of political debate; ti lican, none at all.
The democratic p polities is a matter • the right phrases an the right formulas this or that candidate Deal"' Truman h Roosevelt had h Kennedy 1 Frontier, LBJ hi Society' It is a t advertising, not pr Britain the equivale be Saatchi and Mrs. Thatcher's taking over the Co:
Party.
It is very little tr deciding serious policy. Those are r behind the scenes ruling few.
"ORGANISER Socialist How to fight the Tories Them Where agi Te we stand the Join Socialist ORGANISER for Fight socialist policies!!
Fant =
Scan page 10
Socialist Organiser weekend sch Organiser no.194 August Page
----- pull-quotes -----
10004 their own infusion of populism,