Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

The South Wales miners and the doctrine of Extreme socialism

Socialist Organiser no. 195, 6 September 1984 · scan pp. 6–8 · Martin Barclay · about 2,411 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

BEFORE AND during World War 1 powerful rank and file movements existed not only in the coalfields but also in engineering and on the Those movements suffered heavily from a slump and severe indusleading force could make was shown when the Communist Party pulled as urals '' 1740-44. Dul ine alterence that a politically coherent the pieces together by founding the Minority Movement in Aug. 1924.

A Miners' Minority Movement was set up in January 1924, and industrial sections of the Minority Movement were also formed in engThe Minority Movement ran into problems when the Communist Party became disoriented by Stalinism. In the run-up to the General Strike of 1926, it allowed necessary criticism of the TUC leadership to be overshadowed by the slogan 'All power to the General Council'. And then, after 1929, the CP went on an ultra-left, ultra-militant binge. The cE th at 'The impression conveyed to my mind i regard to the actions of the strikers aroughout these disturbances, and re motives for rioting, is that the docine of extreme socialism preached by small but energetic section is entire• responsible for the premeditated Itempts to destroy property." It could be 1984, but in fact it is eneral Macready speaking about onypandy in November 1910. He was laming these 'extreme socialists' for rusing riots and running battles with le police in the main street and tacks on scabs and collieries that ere still open for scabs.

Macready blamed the Reds, but the $,000 striking miners of the Camian Combine Co. and their families eferred to blame Macready and his ›alowner friends, who had moved 300 police, 120 mounted police, one impany of infantry and two squad. ins of Hussars into the Rhondda, ith 300 infantry and 200 cavalry in serve, to intimidate them back to ork.

But they weren't intimidated and e strike lasted a bitter 12 months, aking Tonypandy a symbol of workg class militarcy that bordered on e revolutionary. Schoolkids in the londda still sing songs about Churill, Home Secretary at the time; obably the majority believe that ›ops shot down striking miners in inypandy.

Mi railways.

trial defeate in 1090 99 incering and rail.

Minority Movement was wound up in 1932.

Martin Barclay looks at the South Wales coalfield befor There was one death - police batonned Samuel Reys to death — but what Tonypandy also killed was the support inside the South Wales Miners' Federation (the 'Fed') for class collaborationist policies of the leadership.

Out of the experience of this leadership selling out the strike came the pamphlet, 'The Miners' Next Step', published in 1912.

Determined It bitterly attacked their determined attempts to do a deal with the employers when wages were being reduced and the cost of living was soaring. Generalising from this it declared, "All leaders become corrupt"" - they take away the 'power of initiative' from the rank and file and fight against democratic accountability.

As long as these shepherds were in charge there could be no real solidarity because "sheep cannot be said to have solidarity". "But the remedy is not new leaders". The remedy was one big union covering mining and quarrying in Britain, "which, recognising the war of interest between workers and employers, is constructed nority militant history of the e and during World War along fighting lines, allowing for a rapid and simultaneous stoppage of wheels throughout the mining industry" for a seven hour day and a minimum wage of 8 shillings for those seven hours.

•The Executive would be made up of working miners and nothing could be negotiated or become law in the organisation without sanction from the lodges. The more perfect the organisations, the more militant the policy, the more profits are reduced and the capitalists squeezed out, to be replaced not by nationalisation but direct workers' control with elected local officials, and a central board to control production.

lashepusand during the Goneral Strike of 1920 'The Miners' Next Step' in its turn became a symbol and a declaration of war against the old leadership. The pamphlet was written by the 'Unofficial Reform Committee' which included local strike leaders Noah Rees and Will Hopla, and Marxists and syndicalists like W.H. Mainwaring and Noah Ablett.

They had been sent to Ruskin College in Oxford on a union scholarship where they had come into contact with the Socialist Labour Party (SLP) in Ablett's case, and the Marxist Social Democratic Federation (SDF) in Mainwaring's.

All of them had been influenced to some extent by Tom Mann's syndicalist ideas. When they returned to the pits they put their knowledge to use by running education classes, drawing about 50 supporters around them, mainly in the Rhondda and Aberdare.

'The Miners' Next Step' represented the collective ideas of the 'extreme socialists' thrashed out it series of meetings in 1911 and 1 effect it had was electric. The lead ship of the Fed was exposed and 1 minimum wage became a natio issue, leading to the first natio miners' strike in 1912.

URC leaders were elected to 1 Executive in 1911 and up-and-comi militants like A.J. Cook and Artf Horner were magnetised by the co mittee and by Ablett, more of teacher than an agitator.

Patriotism But the URC, like every other l wing organisations, was swamped the wave of patriotism which swe the còuntry when war was declared 1914. The Fed leaders literally becar army recruiting agents and the rate voluntary enlistment was high South Wales in the first years. /

Scan page 7

valley in South Wales. It was the scene of fierce battles between police and striking miners during the strike of NovemChurchill sent 300 extra police to the Rhondda, and kept a cavalry squadron in reserve at Cardiff and infantry units at Swindon. The police freely used their truncheons and killed It is not strictly true that Churchill sent in the troops in November 1910, but troops were encamped at Penycraig, a In August 1911 Churchill did send in the troops against strikers who were trying to stop a train at Llanelli. The troops an immediate appeal to the railway able of challenging capitalism. It workers over Thomas' head would had • sustained an anti-imperialist opposition, apart from a few pacifis - rI - 7 members of the Independent Labou Party (ILP), was effectively silenced -until, that is. the 1915 strike droppe out of the air.

In that year, the whole coalfiel came out for an increase in wages t compensate for the rise in food price caused by war profiteering. It wa completely unofficial and as nea spontaneous as possible. In defianc of their own officials and a wartim government backed up by a bayin! press, they won.

They won higher wages and thi anti-war forces won some breathin space to regroup, setting up thi Rhondda Valley Anti-Conscriptior Committee. The mainstream was stil pacifist, but James Connolly, the Irisl Marxist, was fairly well known in thi Unofficial Movement in South Wale because of his writings on industria unionism, and the British presence Ireland was as loudlv denounced as its intervention in Russia following the 1917 Bolshevik Revolution.

Cooke is typical — he started out agitating against food shortages but ended up denouncing the war as a capitalist war with no benefit for the working class.

Atter the impact of the first Russian Revolution of February 1917, Tom Mann was getting audiences of up to 2,000 on a speaking tour, and at one of these meetings, Ablett called for peace negotitions with no annexations or indemnities, the formula used by the Menshevik-dominated Soviets at the time. He wasn't aware of the finer points of the debate with the Bolsheviks.

This is fairly symptomatic of the isolation of the British left, and in particular the left in South Wales from the international movement. but the Unofficial Movement (UM) embraced Bolshevism in October 1917, seeing it as an expression of workers' control. The political consequences of the - Г 11. -Bolshevik victory took a little longer to sink in.

Councils of Action

In 1920 Councils of Action were set up to oppose British intervention against the new Soviet government, and Cook, in the Rhondda, saw them as potential Soviets in their own right - that is, powerful workers' councils that might contest for power with the ruling class.

In fact, the UM had reached its peak in 1919 when education classes were 500 strong and a South Wales Socialist Society had been set up. Politically it was an unstable coalition of the Independent Labour Party, the British Socialist Party (formerly the SDF), and some Socialist Labour Party members, which flew apart under the strain of the negotiations to set up a Communist Party. Most of the ILP members withdrew into the Labour Party, while the BSP and some members of the SLP joined the Communist Party. A group around Cook set up the syndicalist Communist Party of South Wales and the West of England before following Sylvia Pankhurst's group into the Communist Party in 1921. Ablett and the true syndicalists stayed aloof - and increasingly alcoholic.

1919 was also the year when the UM launched an attack on the miners' leaders' proposals for nationalisation before the Sankey Commission. The Miners Federation of Great Britain (MFGB) would agree to increase production by local cooperation hetween management and union L 11/1. ww.. .5.... officials to reach state-determined targets. In return the miners would get a six-hour day, pit-head baths; and the maintenance of the national wages structure built up before the war.

The only clear alternative was presented by the UM in their pamphlet, 'Industrial Democracy for Miners'.

Amplifying the ideas in the Miners' Next Step', this pamphlet set out a complete blueprint for workers' control when a detailed technical argument was needed. Responsibility for nationally agreed production targets would rest with local pit committees controlled by the lodges and all district and national committees were to be elected and accountable to delegate conferences.

It was an elaboration of the 'encroaching control' idea in •The Miners' Next Step' By 191y this laea naa decome stas- 1 611 / 1L:_ ible in the minds of most miners. The South Wales Miners' Federation, SWMF, was the biggest union in Britain before the war. Industrial militancy secured the minimum wage in 1912. In 1915 in South Wales, industrial action won out against all the odds. It began to appear as though a reformed Fed could challenge the state and the capitalist economy.

At a time when the shop stewards' movement had gone from strength to strength in engineering it appeared to many that maybe all that was needed was that extra shove.

In reality the initiative was already slipping away from the UM. The Sankey Commission was ignored by Lloyd George, the Prime Minister; it had only ever been a delaying tactic.

By 1921 industrial militancy was ebbing and the government felt safe enough to return the mines it had run during the war, to their private owners.

Black Friday The story of Black Friday is well-known — the miners were locked out, the employers wanted wage cuts, the Triple Alliance were set to come out in support, but Jimmy Thomas, the NUR leader betrayed them at the last minute, just as today Bill Sirs and the leaders of the ISTC have betrayed their pledge to the miners.

The UM's response was TONYPANDY is a mining village in ber 1910.

one striker, Samuel Reys.

few miles south of Tonypandy after the strike.

opened fire and four men were killed.

have brought them out. but tney 1. 1 11. D..d 1XT..11 didn't even meet for two weeks and let the moment slip by. In response to the movement of the Army and Navy into industrial areas Ablett advised "masterly inactivity". Ablett and Cook recommended acceptance of the terms offered and a couple of lodges in Cook's district called for his resignation.

Minority Movement Just then, Cook left the CP claiming they were "causing divisions in the movement". The CP was left to pick up the reins in 1923 with the Minority Movement. The Minority Movement at its peak had affiliated to it about a quarter of all the trade unionists in Britain. It organised all across industry and was the most powerful organised militant rank and file movement in our history.

The URC was effectively eclipsed as an active force. One consequence was that the question of workers' control was dead and buried for two generations.

Unemployment and economic crisis after 1921 buried syndicalism as an organised movement, but its basic ideas had already been absorbed by most militants in the unions.

That syndicalism hadn't just consisted of 'pure militancy'. The education classes were an attempt to create an educated Marxist vanguard capthe Rhondda movement in woria vyar d. AnO In fact it gave the Minority Movement its basic ideas for reforming the trade union structures.

Their central mistake was that they placed their Marxist vanguard, not at the head of a disciplined revolutionary organisation able to challenge the state, but at the head of the MFGB and this tied them to the routine, reformist rhythm of the trade union movement, unable to act and react quickly.

Despite the experience of Tonypandy, where the state used force and was prepared to use armed force, to defeat the miners, they were left with nothing to say about how to defeat the state violence and eliminate it once and for all.

The UM derived both its strengths and weaknesses from the Fed. It was strong because its ideas struck very deep roots in the movement. It was weak because it didn't get beyond the level of spreading ideas, issuing occasional manifestos and pamphlets, keeping militants in touch and generally playing the role of a ginger group when what was needed was a revolutionary organisation.

It is a chapter in our history which offers vital and essential lessons for our movement today and immediately for the miners who face the clenched fist of the state every day on the picket lines.

Scan page 8

Through its 'rate-capping' the Tory government hopes to give a further decisive twist to its squeeze on local services and local democracy. Michael O'Sullivan, a UCATT shop steward in Haringey Direct Labour department, looks at the policies for fighting back, and argues that Labour needs to turn to politics based on working class mobilisation rather than ben

----- pull-quotes -----

AND: TRANSPORT T movement

2L HOURS PELAY WORKERS STOP TONICHT.

WLL THE TROOPS FIRETE TO MORONEr

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 195

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →