'Nobody owns me
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-09-06Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Asian women on strike at Supreme Quilting. Mollroy focuses on the neer Clive Bradley reviews Clive Bradley reviews "STRIKE! How to fig ht, how to win" by John Mellroy, published by Pluto Press at £5.95.
"I realised that the workers are the people who give their blood for management and that they should have good conditions, good pay and should be well fed. The trade unions are the best thing here - they are not so powerful in other countries. They are a nice power and we should keep it on." (Jayaben Desai after the Grunwicks strike).
"I was against unions before then. From what I saw on the TV and read in the papers I thought they were a complete waste of time and the damage done to the country was the result of them ... It's just a start as far as I'm concerned. I've always been pretty outspoken. It's even been the cause of arguments at home. I'm my own person. Nobody owns me. The future? I'll fight the fight. But because of what's happened I'il always be politically involved". (Elsie Broad, striker, Royal Pride, Salford).
These two quotations sum up the experience of many workers during the course of strikes. The miners' strike now is an indication of the kinds of lessons that can be learned and links that can be made.
However, most strikes are badly prepared, badly led, and many workers including members of trade unions — are opposed to s: les, and accept many of the i sic arguments of the bosses tha: strikes damage the country"
This book by John Mellroy, a regular contributor to Socialist Organiser, tackles these arguments, and is a handbook on how to successfully organise and win strike action.
Forced to Mellroy's basic case is that workers are forced to fight for their interests against the employers by the nature of a class divided society. Strike action is simply one weapon, and generally the most effective one, of defending those interests. Indeed it is lack of strike action which leads to so many sections of workers being so badly off and so demoralised.
As Mallroy puts it, 'In many workplaces in many industries Notts miners picket Ratcliffe power station PLUTO PRESS in NIT.
we need more strikes. Workers are forced to put up with atrocious wages and conditions of work because they have not realised that such things are not inevitable. They can be changed and the power of industrial action can play a part in that change. " (p.29).
Useful
Mollroy's book will be enormously useful to many militants. It is specifically aimed at generally inexperienced militants, giving a basic outline of very simple tactical necessities in a strike, as well as looking at bigger questions and detailing management tactics and the This, incidentally, explains the way some of the book is written: Socialist Worker, for example, complained that Mollroy is hazy on the treacherous role played by the trade union bureaucracy. This is not true — and the tone of what Mollroy writes is addressed to workers who do not yet know what experienced socialists know, and is intended as a rational warning of future betrayals rather than a headbanging denunciation.
The book shows how management is usually well prepared in advance for strike action, whilst the unions are not. It also shows how trade union officials, who see their role as negotiation and who feel threatened by independent rank and file action, fail to use strike action, or even the threat of it, as a successful weapon in negotiations.
"Not only are strike preparations essential to effective negotiations but the ability to organise a strike should be seen as an essential quality for all negotiators.
io SErwgnp www...
countries ''The situation is often the contrary. Even when a strike is declared, too many union officials are still psychologically adjusted to "jaw, jaw" to the exclusion of 'war, war", see their job as that of the diplomat, not that of the general, and the organisation and impact of the strike suffers. " (p.48).
Moliroy discusses important tactical and political questions involved in organising effective strikes. As well as giving useful advice on how to keep the rank and file informed and involved, how to organise effective mass meetings and so on, he emphasises a number of crucial points.
and file *The need for democratic, rank and file organisation to run and win the strike. Both the demands of the strike and the actual running of the strike must come from the rank and file. All decisions - including the decision to strike and the decision to go back — must be democratic, rank and file decisions. Strike committees, involving militants on the ground with various talents, are vital. The strike committee must seek to organise and involve the membership as a whole.
*The need to develop the widest possible action and unite different sections of workers. Mollroy discusses practical ways to get the message over to other workers — often, of necessity, quite independently of the official union structures — and encourage necessary solidarity action from blacking to strikes.
He also discusses the need to link together different issues so as to unite wider groups of workers, and gives examples of the consequences of failure to do this.
For example, the failure of the ISTC leadership to bring the issue of closures into that of wages in the strike of 1980 was fatal to its outcome, as was the calling off of the strike just as a dock strike was starting; and the parochialism of the local leaders of the Leyland Vehicles dispute in 1982 was likewise fatal.
WWWW for solidarity Mellroy looks, too, at the question of solidarity with workers in other countries, and with black and women workers, showing how nationalist, racist and sexist prejudices, along with the failure of the official union structures to fight for the interests of these workers, is damaging to the whole movement.
Different tactics
The book covers various ways of dealing with different kinds of disputes — recognition disputes, victimisation and so on. And it looks at different possible tactics, ranging from various kinds of occupation, sit-ins, work-ins, to methods of picketing. It deals with the inadequacies of many forms of partial action, such as one-day strikes or sectional strikes, arguing that whilst they may be a way of mobilising support they can often simply lead to confusion and demoralisation.
Mcllroy touches on the topical question of the general strike. He writes: 'If a sit-in raises the question of who runs a workplace, a general strike poses far more starkly the question, who runs the country? It can easily lead to a full-scale confrontation between the trade union movement and the state, a confrontation where the workers have to country or step back and accept defeat... Because the economy is gradually paralysed, at a certain stage workers have to organise their own production, transport and administration' (pp103-4). Some of this could do with being spelt out more, but the basic argument is a sound one. Equally valid is Mollroy's comment that: "It is wrong to argue that because a general strike can escalate quickly into a full-scale confrontation and civil war, it can never be used unless the labour movement is prepared for this. A general strike can achieve limited objectives and it can strengthen the labour movement. It can lead to a government withdrawing a intimacilit. piece of legislation, changing policies or calling an election. In 1968, De Gaulle eventually defused the strike by calling an election. In 1972 the English courts ordered the release of the dockers. It can, of course, fail to achieve limited objectives and weaken the working class. But it is not necessarily a once-and for-all struggle." (p.104).
He looks at the anti-union legislation, and necessary ways of fighting it, including:
*Union democracy to avoid the strike weapon being blunted from the top to avoid confrontation with the law.
*All union members to be prepared for industrial action to protect the union if funds are at risk.
*Every union to call for immediate strike action to answer any legal threats.
*A united fight against anti-union legislation led by the TUC. And the book also looks briefly at the Emergency Powers Acts of 1920 and 1964. Troops have been used in no less than 23 disputes since 1945, seven of which have been since 1970. Mollroy: notes that "the best protection against undermining of a dispute by the military is the extension of the dispute as happened in the docks in 1949 and 1950. " (p.195).
Distinguish
Finally, he stresses the need sometimes to make compromises and keep the union intact, to be able to distinguish between a retreat and a sellout.
It is a snappily-written and enjoyable book, crammed full of useful examples — of successes and failures, good and bad strike strate ias if makes it quiendear how in practice a militant, that is a socialist policy is the best way to defend workers' interests and win in the here and now. Mellroy says in his introduction: "If this book produces more successful strikes it will have done its job". It will certainly help.
Scan page 11
TRADES UNION CONGRESSE BRIGHTO Ray Buckton addressing the conference on Monday : a delegate's dia ON Monday; September 3, at least 22 protestors were shot dead in South Africa, and scores more injured, as unrest appeared to be rapidly spreading through black townships south and east of Johannesburg. Monday's slaughter in South Africa was the work of armed police and military contingents who had been unleashed by the apartheid state to beat down protest actions sparked by last week's police killings of at least seven people, several of them children, in black and Asian townships outside Johannesburg.
Late on Monday afternoon a retaliatory bomb went off in the passport and immigration offices of the Department of Internal Affairs in central Johannesburg.
The focus of the escalating violence seemed to be the black township of Sharpeville. Sharpeville was the scene of the slaughter of 69 people in 1960 when police fired on a crowd demonstrating against the Pass Laws, which restrict the movement of non-whites. 178 people were wounded then.
Fires are raging in several parts of Sharpeville and the deputy mayor, Sam Dlamini, was killed by blacks after he had shot dead two black youths.
Similar unrest is reported in neighbouring townships of Sebokeng and Evaton.
The police and Army are using helicopters, armoured troop carriers, automatic Mr Kader Hassim has been arrested and detained by the South Atrican government under their Internal Security Act.
Kader Hassim, chair of the Maritzburg branch of the African Peoples Democratic Union of South Africa, an organisation affiliated to the Unity Movement of South Africa (UMSA), is a former Robben Island prisoner who served an eight year sentence for his opposition to the regime in weapons and tear gas against the black population. Hundreds of arrests are being made as the security forces sweep through these areas.
The unrest was sparked initiaIly by anger over rent increases, enforced by black officials hated as government stooges. Discontent has been seething amongst youth over the grossly inferior and authoritarian quality of black education.
This comes on top of the recent rejection by the Coloured and Indian communities of the new apartheid constitution in last week's election, when over four-fifths of them abstained. The regime is setting up a sham triple chamber democracy which excludes the majority of South Africa's population — the blacks — and leaves all power in the hands of the whites.
The police killings at the weekend only provided the spark for the eruption of the present fury.
This is the most serious and sustained black unrest in South Africa since the riots in Soweto in 1976 which started and spread in very much the same way, lasting for almost a year and leaving 600 people dead.
Non-whites in South Africa are having to endure daily an increasingly harsh state. Now the black masses are fighting back against their oppressors.
a time when UMSA was campaigning to boycott the elections being conducted by the racist regime in their attempt to give apartheid a new look, by establishing separate Parliaments for the different ethnic groups.
The Unity movement appeals to all freedom-loving people all over the world to demand the release of Kader Hassim and the other militants arrested with him and to create solidarity movements in support of the struggle of the blacks of South Africa against racial oppression Sunday: Involved in delegation meetings all day, discussing motions and amendments. At the end of those meetings we end up having a free vote on only one motion. Most of the amendments are straightforward and warrant little discussion, but all need careful attention. The right wing try to push through seemingly meaningless amendments that can water down a good motion.
Most of the time is taken up debating support for the NUM motion and the General Council statement which we eventually agree to support.
By the afternoon I begin to wonder why anyone bothers to come to Brighton at all. The unions go in each day with their vote already decided. What use is the debate then _ but a chance for those who want a career in the TUC or in their own unions to have a free platform.
All the speakers are chosen beforehand. Only those who are 'Established" can speak. We might as well go along on the first day, put our votes in a box and all go home.
The only body who seems to have power is the General Council and representatives on this are decided upor by how many votes they've got to exchange with other unions in wheeling and dealing for their candidates.
Oh well, let's see how this media event goes on!
Monday morning: Things were looking bad after yesterday. But today it picked up with the lobby By Ann Crowder, NALGO delegate. by 3,000 striking miners.
Meanwhile, on the inside, we spent the morning presenting each other with awards and slapping eachother on the back. Then Ray Buckton went through the disputes of the year — GCHQ, the NGA - and forgot to mention the miners.
By the time the miners' debate started we were biting our fingernails: would Congress back the miners or buckle under pressure from the right and the press?
Legless Len tried to convince us that the compromise statement was just as good as the withdrawn motions; and the EETPU delegation were working out how to split the movement.
The Rev. Hammond delivered a lecture to us about how striking miners were in fact not workers fighting for their jobs at all, but Hitler's grandchildren.
Fortunately the tension broke when Hammond got what he deserved — a load of heckling and booing.
Even the AUEW came down on the right side with Gavin Laird announcing their support. Something must have happened in their delegation -only a couple of days ago Duffy was sounding off, supporting the EETPU. Still, where there's life there's hope...
Monday night: One cocktail party after another. As much as you can guzzle, drink and smoke on the members. In these flashy hotels no-one talks politics; there's just gossip and vote trading.
All the bureaucrats lounging around — if the waitresses were in unions they must have wondered why they paid their dues. And if the waitresses weren't in a union, they're not going to join on last night's showing. To my mind, those cocktail parties are more fitting for the foxhunting set.
Tuesday: Len Murray — presumably still legless from the night before - defended his comer ver his role in the NGA dispute.
Surprisingly, the most stick didn't come from the NGA delegates, but from McGahey and Rodney Bickerstaffe. Len's mates staggered up to his rescue. Roy Grantham from APEX came out with a novel line: It was all the NGA's fault. If they'd gone to the TUC and asked them what to do, we could have won it for them -single-handed. Which rather contradicted his opinion that the TUC shouldn't have supported the NGA anyway, because we should only back winners. Tuesday afternoon: Enter Neil THE STRIKE by civil servants at the Crown Agents Pensions Division (PD) in East Kilbride, near Glasgow, is entering its sixth month.
130 of the 158 PD staff (members of CPSA, SCPS and CSU), began their strike on April 4 in the wake of the announcement ry Kinnock, playing right into th hands of the press by putting th blame for violence on the NUT pickets, not on the police. Ot and women are involved, appal ently, because it's a famil dispute, not just an economi one.
Kinnock missed a big oppor tunity to argue for socialism an condemn a system that force people to go on strike for si months to fight for their liveli hoods. I noticed some Conser vative trade unionists giving hir a standing ovation.
This conference belongs to th press and the bureaucrats. Th bureaucrats are professional who switch from one union t another like football players of the transfer market. When dele gates get up to speak, they seer just to want to boost their repu tation.
You can tell the sort of peopl who go to a conference by th creche. This one isn't bad, but i is only open during conferena sessions so parents can't go t fringe events. And parents hav to pay to use it.
But most telling is that then are only six kids in it, for onl 152 delegates out of 1150 ar women.
s strike By Stan that no other section of th movement yet has. This unde lines the need for increase support for their fight from th rest of the movement.
The second basic principle: Crooke
----- pull-quotes -----
PLUTO HANDBOOKS PLUTO HANDBOOKS _Stmike! STOP CLOSURES SAVE PITS
think about moving forward to take over the running of the
sara sa TUC