Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Stumbling and fudging

Socialist Organiser no. 196, 13 September 1984 · scan p. 10 · about 584 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

retirement: best thing he's done (NALGO delegate, personal Capacity)

The press predicted a certain split at the Brighton TUC. Instead we got the pledge to back the miners.

So far, however, the pledge has produced only words. No doubt some of the leaders supported the statement cynically and with tongue in cheek. But militants can use the TUC pledge. Our number one task is to build on it to gain real solidarity with the miners. We must insist that the trade union leaders act on it.

But all in all it was disappointing Congress.

The only working class answer to the vicious propaganda war of the Tories and the media against the labour movement is a vigorous, self-confident counter-offensive. So we need a massive campaign of agitation and education i the working class and we need the educative action of building solidarity with any and every group of workers who come up against the employers or the Tory government.

But this stumbling and faltering TUC — which didn't even condemn Len Murray for ratting on the NGA last December — is a long way from being able to provide either the one or the other.

The decisive test was its response to the Tory anti-union laws — yet more of which are being got ready. It failed the test as miserably in Congress as in real life.

At every point there was fudging, complacency, spiritLen Murray and his successor Norman Willis lessness and confusion.

The TUC was criticised for its betrayal of the NGA -but the motion passed did not commit the TUC to automatic support for any union running foul of the laws.

Tony Dubbins, NGA general secretary elect, put it well: "It's just not possible to have an effective industrial dispute and remain within the law". And again: 'It's no good waiting for the right ground because we will never be able to choose the ground for a fight"

Murray, Grantham and the right wing justified the TUC's failure last year with the argument that it was wrong to back losers. As Murray put it: "To tell someone they are in a nowin situation is not new realism, it's the oldest realism in the book"

On GCHQ, a motion from the CPSA criticising no-disruption agreements was heavily defeated. And the decision to withdraw from the NEDC, over the banning of the GCHQ unions was reversed.

Taken as a whole, the TUC decisions on fighting the anti-union laws do not commit it to much. Serious action in defence of victimised unions will have to be fought for.

was very much Len Murray's doing. For one brief moment, in a mediocre career, Len Murray took a stand and spoke out boldly — against striking workers. Legless Len became King Rat for a day.

Murray might have been censured and condemned by Congress for what he did then. But conference instead gave him the send-off traditional on these occasions.

In eleven years as TUC general secretary, Murray has presided over the loss of two mllion members. Worse, he has presided over the TUC in the years when it has proved unable to defend the working class or itself against the Tory onslaught.

At the point of its worst crisis in many decades it was the misfortune of the trade union movement to have a spineless, grey, time-serving office-boy at its helm.

He goes in the middle of a very bitter and prolonged working class battle which marks the utter failure of his attempt after

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 196

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →