Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Are women really the weaker sex?

Socialist Organiser no. 196, 13 September 1984 · scan p. 10 · about 563 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Les Hearn asks whether women can beat men at sport IN SPORT, women have always been discriminated against, béing discouraged and denied facilities and opportunities. For instance, in the Olympics (arntcha sick of them?), women are not allowed to compete in hammer throwing, pole-vaulting and triple jumping, as well as distances over 3,000 metres (except for the marathon, introduced this year).

The reason is of course male prejudice about the "weaker" sex - but instead of helping the "weak" , male bigots have hindered and discouraged. * Weaker?

But are women necessarily the weaker sex? Two articles in a recent New Scientist examine women's athletic performance. Craig. 'Sharp compares the anatomy and physiology of men and women, while Kenneth Dyer looks at how the gap between women's and men's athjetic records has been narrowing...

Sharp looks first at height. On average; men are 7% taller than women but there is a large overlap with the tallest women being taller than the vast majority of men.

Women's wider hips mean that the angle of the thigh bone is different on average and makes many women throw their heels out when running (wht difference this makes, I don't know). More seriously, this different angle tends to cause aching knees, but this can be corrected by strengthening the muscle on the inside of the thigh.

Balancing

Hormone differences tend to broaden male shoulders, making the muscles longer and broader (and therefore stronger). However, this raises the centre of gravity of the body, so women may have a better balancing ability.

Men's arms are relatively longer, too, giving an advantage in some throwing events.

Sharp identifies three main areas where women may be at a real disadvantage in many sports:

Lower muscle mass.

Lower oxygen-carrying capa icity of blood.

High proportion of body fat.

1. 'Lower mass of muscle may be a disadvantage in events calling for a burst of energy, such as throwing ot sprinting, while the extra weight of fat would make things worse.

2. Oxygen capacity of blood Seems lower in women, but may not actually make much difference. After allowing for body fat, men's and women's bodies have the same maximum rate of oxygen use, so both must be able to get adequate oxygen from their blood.

3. Body fat actually seems to be an advantage in events calling for endurance, providing a store of extra energy for use when the glucose and starch stored in the tissues has been used up.

Women seem better able to use their fat for energy production and it also helps in floating in water and in insulating from the cold. Put these factors together, and we find that the fastest long-distance swimmers are... women!

Record swims

Women hold the records for channel and two-way channel swims.

Women can withstand dehydration better and can acclimatise to high altitudes faster: Their muscles seem less prone to painful exhaustion and may be less susceptible to damage through exercise.

Sharp thinks that the fastest, etc., men will always beat the fastest, etc., women in the present-day selection: of athletic events, though he points out the considerable overlap of achievements between men and women.

But Sharp says it would be a different story in a competition involving a long swim, followed by a run through deserts and mountains. In this women could probably out-perform men.

More next week

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 196

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →