Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Railworkers call for strike

Socialist Organiser no. 197, 20 September 1984 · scan pp. 2–5 · about 4,587 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 2

picketing at both the pits and the power stations. But the importance of money does mean that the rest of the labour movement needs to step up its work of collecting money, not only for food, but to finance picketing ana allow the NUM to go out to other workers.

Reinforcements

Powerful reinforcements may be on hand for the NUM. NACODS, the pit supervisors' union, is ballotting all its 16,000 members next week with a recommendation for strike action Railworkers carrying out union policy of not handling coal have been demanding that our unions respond to management harassment.

But the NUR and ASLEF have delayed and delayed on this issue.

Guards and drivers at Shirebrook, Coalville, and Westhouses. and signalmen at Worksop, have faced threats.

Rob Now they have appealed to other members in North Notts, South Yorkshire, and North Derbyshire to strike for 24 hours unless management withdraw the threats.

Overtime has been withdrawn, workers have been threatened with the sack, and guards and drivers at Shirebrook have been classified as 'on strike' so that they don't get tax rebates.

A local meeting of the NUR/ASLEF Rail Federation in Doncaster last Saturday, 15th, supported the 24 hour strike call, and so did the Sheffield and Chesterfield NUR District Council.

Fi se

Scan page 3

Socialist Organiser no.197 September 20 1984 Page 3 MacGregor was recalled to fiasco ended with the break London for a new briefing, down of the talks in London. based on the government's I think that the problem for assessment that the docks' us is that we didn't know from strike was crumbling. I think start to finish of the talks what Selby: MacGregor told Scargill agreement. It seems that other nrenared to make it with the trade union leaders know far Arthur Scargill speaking at the miners' rally in Barnsley last Saturday. ¡There has been a lot of talk in the last 24 hours about the breakdown of talks between the Coal Board and the NUM. What ought to be said in the newspapers, on radio and on television, if they had a degree of objectivity and integrity, is that Ian MacGregor and the National Coal Board invited the NUM to talks on the basis of a false pretext.

On September 6, the Coal Board wrote to the NUM, asking for a recommencement of negotiations. On behalf of our union Peter Heathfield wrote back and said we were willing to meet the Board on the following Sunday provided that the National Coal Board were prepared to sit down and negotiate a settlement on the basis of the documentation presented by the NUM to the Coal Board on July 18.

That documentation there must be:

*A withdrawal of the closure programme.

*The five pits threatened closure must be kept open.

*No insistence from the NCB now, or in the future, on a pit closure programme or closure on "economic' grounds.

The Coal Board replied that they were prepared to meet this union on the basis of Mr Heathfield's letter.

And yet, when we met in Scotland to discuss this, it was obvious that Mrs Thatcher had given marching: orders to lan MacGregor: and either, he was glue sniffing when he put that bag over his head or he was on a microphone to No. 10 to see what his latest instructions should be.

It was perfectly clear throughout those discussions that the Board have not got a case. We put it to them in negotiations, how can you possibly defend the position that you adopted on March 6, when you said you wanted to close 20 pits and make redundant 20,000 miners?

They said that their main emphasis was dictated by a desire to take four million tonnes of coal production out of the industry.

• MacGregor said . we are producing too much coal. Büt once we've reduced it by four million tonhes, this. industry will have balanced demand and supply and there will be no further contraction.

He even went so far as to the first year and 100 million tonnes in the four succeeding years - making a total output of 497.4 million tonnes. That programme, with that output, would involve at least 20 pit closures this year, working towards 70 pit closures, which means the destruction of 70,000 jobs.

Bevercotes NUM.

THE main problem during the week of NUM-NCB talks was not knowing what was going on at the talks in Edinburgh, Selby, Doncaster and London. All we knew was what we saw on television or read in the papers. We were left to guess what was happening. • My guess 1s that, atter two days of talks an agreement was nearly reached but the government was not prepared to accept that agreement. It was no coincidence that at this stage Leon Brittan made a statement to the press about life sentences for miners' pickets, thereby creating the backdrop needed to break the talks.

In the negotiations this week the Coal Board have admitted that because of the strike itself, because of the overtime ban, we have already lost 54 million tonnes of coal production and even if they kept open every single pit over the next five years, the maximum coal production they could get would be 480 million tonnes - 17 million tonnes less than what they were planning with the pit closure programme.

Why then are they continuing to have this dispute with the NUM?

The real intention of the Coal Board in this dispute is to smash the effectiveness of the NUM. That is the intention of this government as part of its plan to weaken the whole labour and trade union movement.

Nottingham

This is- nothing new to lan MacGregor. He was in charge of an American mining company called AMAX. This weekend although you will have read of the collections made by Soviet miners towards our strike fund, you will not have read in these unbiased newspapers, written by these Piranha fish, of the fact that we've got coming today, tour United States miners bringing a substantial amount of American dollars for the British miners' strike fund.

One of those American miners comes from Harlan County where lan MacGregor and people like him were prepared to deploy state troopers, armed to the teeth, to try and defeat the Us miners.

The hat I wear on demonstrations is an American miners' hat. It was worn by US miners who fought lan MacGregor. Do you want to know the outcome? The miners beat him! Just as our people are beating him today.

We are told there are a number of uneconomic pits that have got to close. Not true. I say without fear of contradiction there are no uneconomic pits in Britain. There are only pits which have been starved of investment.

The NUM in this area planned to close a whole number of pits over the last 14 years. They haven't done so and the reason has nothing to do with economics. It has to do with the fact that miners in this area would not accept pit closures and redundancies.

We have in this industry a plan for coal. The Plan for Coal was devised by a Labour governthat when talks resumed in that he had an offer but wasn't press around.

This led to the NCB-NUM attack on the media. The meeting moved to Doncaster where, I guess, MacGregor's offer was not the compromise Scargill expected but the hard line Thatcher told him to put. The ment, the trade unions and the National Coal Board. And this document does not contain in any section any reference to the closure of pits on economic grounds.

This document was updated in 1977 and presented to Parliament and Parliament adopted that. document. There was a secret memo at NCB HQ that we shouldn't see so l'll read it to you. It says, "in negotiations with the. NUM we should avoid reference to the 1977 Plan for Coal. It does not help the Board's position. Concentrate on the 1974 version because we are better able justify our argument." Do you know why they don't want to talk about the "77 version? It was presented to Parliament by he person who drew it up - Towy Benn, the secretary of state for industry. In that dooument it provided for investment policy into existing pits to maintain them, to expand existing collieries with new capacity, to develop new pits to the tune of 100 million tonnes of new capacity and above all it said there would be government assistance to protect this industry in common with all other coal industries. in Europe against the ravages of the market economy.

That was the policy laid down in Parliament, and it's because Plan for Coal supports the union's policy that lan MacGregor and the Coal Board want to depart from its terms.

What is wrong with arguing to stand by a signed agreement? We have an agreement between the Coal Board, the government and the union. We signed it as recently as 1981. Ian MacGregor at the beginning of this year said he pledged his support for the Plan for Coal. Why is it then that lan MacGregor and the Board will not withdraw the pit closure programme in the knowledge that it has now been overtaken by events and agree to settle this dispute on the basis of the Plan for Coal?

81% of investment in the last ten years has gone into new collieries like Selby and only 19% into the old collieries which should have been maintained.

We've had during the course of this dispute 7,000 people arrested. Well over 90% of those people have never encountered the law before in their lives. They've not even had a parking ticket and they are being des cribed by Tory ministers as hooligans. I'll tell you what crime our membership have committed -there's only one crime - they're fighting for the right to work!

Over 3,000 of our people have been injured on picket lines. We've young lads with broken legs and broken arms. We've had five of our colleagues killed during the course of this dispute. And there are still people in the wider movement who question whether the time is right to come in and stand firmly beside us.

When five of our colleagues have died fighting for the right to work, we say we've come too far, in there ores would have been the basis of any more about the talks than the miners on strike have ever known.

I would like to see talks held in the open, as they were during Solidarnosc's negotiations with the Polish government in the Polish shipyards four years ago. Then, the discussion was broadcast to the membership as and when it was happéning. Guards at Piccadilly Statio nesday, September 12th. ( miners on station premises: we've suffered too much to accept any other than fulfillment of what we set out to do - maintain our pits, keep open our industry and ensure that no-one destroys our communities and our way of life.

I tell you we're not negotiating with the Coal Board, there's another hand on the table. We're negotiating by proxy with the Thatcher government. That's the main problem.

Why do you think MacGregor flew back from Scotland Wednesday night? Um not suggesting he went to get his orders. He might have wanted a chat. But it's significant that the temperature rose considerably when we met him the next time in London. This government, • right from the beginning of the dispute, have been pulling the strings and instructing MacGregor not to resolve this dispute.

When people talk about a word or eight words, we're not talking about words, we're talking about a whole concept, a whole philosophy. We're trying to reconcile the irreconcilable.

There's only one way we can resolve this dispute, and that is the National Coal Board withdrawing the plan to close pits, withdrawing the threat to the five pits in question, and reaffirming their commitment to a Plan for Coal that is signed by them, signed by us and endorsed by this government as recently as 1981.

I met the TUC yesterday. And is significant that the TUC did 1 in Manchester went on si 'uards had been arrested fo not merely reaffirm Congress policy. The TUC went on record supporting what we have done in the negotiations and deplored what the Coal Board had done. They said it was obvious that the : Coal Board are refusing to settle this dispute.

If those people who built this union could look upon us today they would salute with pride the finest example in these young men and women that the trade unicil movement has ever seen. They would also look with pride at a new phenomenon in British politics - for the first time women have formed themselves into groups and called themselves women's support groups,. backing the fight against pit Power they've not done it because they support men - they've done it because they're beginning to realise the potential power that they themselves have - they're not fighting for their husbands or their boy friends, they're fighting for themselves, their children and their communities, and we should salute the tremendous efforts that women have made.

What we have to do now is to redouble our efforts. We have to say to miners on strike - it's not sufficient to be merely out on strike in this struggle, you have to become a picket involved in the struggle. We have to say to our colleagues in other industries -there is a golden rule in the trade union and about movement, it'sa rice for 24 hours last Wed•collecting money for the.

tenet on which we've built. that when workers are in struggle don't cross picket lines.

Finally, we should say to the whole trade union and labour movement - we're only asking one thing. Give to the NUM in financial terms the same kind of assistance the Tories are giving to theirs in the NCB. We're suffer ing terrific hardship in the mining communities - we need help. For gods sake give it, and give it now Give us physical assistance. And give us the same commitment thai the, CBI and the Institute of Directors have given to the NCB. We have a right to ask for that kind of support from the wider labour and trade union. move. ment.

I'm convinced that, provided we continue with the resolve that we've displayed in the past 26 weeks, there is no question of the outcome of this dispute. The miners are on the way to a vic tory. We will win not only. the right to keep open our pits, to save our jobs, but we'll also gel the demands to which we're entitled in the most dangerou: and arduous industry in Britain Decent wages, better conditions. a rate protection scheme, and yes, an early retirement without having to resort to redundancy pay - the same terms for early retirement as those who are offered redundancy. If we keep on with the kind of policies that we've indicated throughout this dispute, I say to you, to this government and to the Coal Board. make no mistake we're on our way. do a victory... .....

Scan page 4

Social Orgamsor n0. * . . emiber 20 1084 Page done to th IT MUST be one of two things:

either the miners will win, or the whole working class will be defeated.

Every class-conscious worker knows that this is the sober truth - and knows also that there is no half-way house now.

They will win or we will win.

The Tories will suffer a terrible defeat, or we will.

The Tories know this, too. They have deliberately engineered the situation. They are going for the kill, believing that they have got militant trade unionism in their sights and can wipe it out for years to come.

They call it 'Scargillism' or 'picket line violence', but the proper name for it is militant trade unionism, the force that time and time again over the last 20 years has defeated and thwarted the ruling class in this country.

Therefore the Tories are throwing everything they can at the miners. They hit miners' families by withholding social security money. They use the viciously biased and unfair press and their other media to bludgeon the miners and the rest of the working class: They use vast concentrations of semi-militarised police, antique laws, and compliant courts.

And they make eager use of every person or grouping within the labour movement willing to help their campaign to demoralise and defeat the miners.

The miners' strike is now the great dividing line in British society, in British politics, and within the labour movement. You are either with the miners or you are against them. There is no neutral ground.

Everyone in the labour movemert is faced with a stark choice: either help the miners win, or, because of your indifference, inertia, cowardice, or incapacity to understand, allow Thatcher to win.

The propaganda war is one of the key fronts in this conflict — for it is there, to a considerable extent, that the crucial fight for working class solidarity is being decided.

The Tories have nortrayed their intended victims as villains for fighting back; scabs as heroes; bloodlusty police as defenders of peace and quiet; pickets as mindless thugs.

JOHN HARRIS!

Pickets confront police at a power station John O'Mahony Arthur Scargill, the trade union leader who has had the guts to take on the entire Establishment (including much of the labour movement Establishment) in defence of his members, is portrayed as a vain and petty-minded little man out to tear Britain apart for his own personal and political ends.

And Mrs Thatcher, leader of the vandal Tories who have demolished Britain over the last five years, is painted as a constructive politician; lan MacGregor, her professional pit butcher, as a responsible industrialist.

The double standards of the media are outrageous! This strike started because the government and the Coal Board decided to close down 20 pits and axe 20,000 jobs. Neither the NUM nor the miners directly concerned, nor their families, nor the communities that would be decimated as a result, were to be given any say at all in the matter. They would have to accept the dictates of MacGregor and Thatcher.

Nobody but the NUM and the Left talked about how viciously undemocratic that was.

Now the Tories, their bellycrawling press, and their allies in the labour movement, base their campaign against the NUM on the ballot issue. Though 80% of the miners are on strike, and democratic delegate conferences of the union have endorsed the strike, there has not been a formal ballet of the members.

So now they all scream at the niners: 'Democracy is the ssue'.

The Tories have sent armies of policemen and police cavalry against the striking miners, ¡urned pit villages into minipolice states. Where — as in Kiveton Park, South Yorkshire - even a paltry half-doz scabs could be found, the poli have used unrestrained violen‹ to defend their right to scab ar work.

Yet the Tories, and their pre: and TV, supported by powerf voices within the labour mov ment, base their press campaig against the miners on denunci tions of "picket line violence' The blame for the violence put on the miners who defer their jobs, and not on the Co Board which employs scabs ar the government which has tur ed the police force into the bij gest scab-herding agency British history!

These obscene double stanı ards are themselves proof thi there is no common ground bi tween the working class movi ment and the bosses, the government, and their media, i this strike = no ground of 'na ional interest upon which 1 meet, and no terrain whel people of reason and goodwi can find a common viewpoint.

This is war — class war. I war, they say, truth is the fir casualty. In this class war th truth is being massacred.

The propaganda war of th le ruling class has had seriol IS effects on the working clas hindering the movement f for solidarity with the miners. Thi at is what it is meant to do.

That is why those in the lal our movement who pick up an repeat the media claptrap abor democracy and picket line vio ence are nothing less tha second-string - ideological -scab-herders.

Neil Kinnock has played th: role — and the forthcoming Lal our Party conference should ca him to account for it.

Jimmy Reid, the one-tin Communist Party leader wt fronted the sit-in at Upper Clyc Shipbuilders in 1971 and is no in the Labour Party, is close 1 making a profession of ideolog cal scab-herding. These days t specialises in writing polemic at Itto re ill in st le nas TN. WHATEVER way the present and now sadfy continuing coal strike ends, the main casuaity will undoubtedly be Dole will undermine eft in British for the against ine For the Tories? Yes, for the Tories! He has published articles attacking the miners and Arthur Scargill in the Guardian, the Scottish Daily Record, and now last Sunday's Observer.

This last long screed of vituperation — "The damage Scargill has done to the Left' -appeared on the Observer's editorial page as the main feature article.

Public Mr Reid says things in public, bluntly and crudely, that are said privately by many of the Labour and trade union leaders, and for that reason his article is important.

The author's viewpoint seems to be that , of the Kinnockite Left - though he frequently sounds like Mrs Thatcher or David Owen. His concern, Reid says, is that the miners' strike and the picketing that sustains it are damaging both democracy and Labour's electoral prospects.

They have created a climate of opinion among British workers favourable to the Tory anti-union legislation, he says. However the strike ends, "the main casualty will undoubtedly be the democratic Left in British politics". It "could even mean a further decline in the Party's mass base among the working class"

''The miners' union will come out of this strike bleeding, torn apart and demoralised by a surfeit of rhetoric unrelated to reality. The likelihood is that the union will be finished as an effective fighting force for the rest of this century"

All these evils will flow, says Reid, from one great crime committed by the NUM leaders -their failure to have a national 'This raised an issue of fundamental importance for all democratic socialists. The ballot bo x is not an expendable luxury, something which can be abandoned to suit the tactics of any individual or group"

Reid condemns the labour movement for collusion in the NUM leaders' crinies against democracy•.

What does he want us to do? What Neil Kinnock has done.

The only words of praise in the article go tr. Neil Kinnock: eXception of Neil innock ale failed] to say one word of criticism about the refusal to hold a ballot and the conduct of the strike?"

The main jet of Reid's venom is spurted over Arthur Scargill himself. Reid does say that the appointment of the industrial gunslinger' MacGregor was a 'provocation' by the Tories. But he still manages to blame Arthur Scargill for more or less everything. Scargill's psychology and 'adventurist' politics are the biggest problem faced by the labour movement in Britain today, it seems!

"Scargill had been desperate for a fight ever since winning the NUM Presidency". '. He considered the previous two votes against strike action as "'a personal rebuff". • Reid vouches for it.

"As someone who has known Arthur for nearly 30 years I understand how bitter he must have felt at what he was bound to consider a personal rebuff Much of Reid's article is like that: Jimmy, the 'trade union activist for many years', knows these things.

He also knows this of Scargill: "His nature seems to demand that he must be the centre of attraction around which everything must revolve" • All typical Stalinist polemica: tricks learned by Reid back in the '50s.

"To be blunt and honest", he goes on, "many Labour MPs are intimidated. Arthur Scargill has become the Ayatollah, the focal point, for all the hard sectarian groupings within the labour movement"

These forces, spearheaded by Scargill, threaten democracy and therefore undermine the credibility of the labour movement within the working class.

Sacred democracy

For Reid, the sacredness of democracy is best preserved when the militant working class is meek and mild, and the Tories and the police can rampage unchecked.

Reid's arguments about the ballot are claptrap. Of course it would be better if there had been a ballot vote for strike action, and a united NUM. on strike. It may even be that it would have been tactically wise for the NUM to call a ballot in April, once the strike was firm. But the leaders of the NUM were in the best position eve say relatives who are iners?' The answer wat seed, Well, we are a special presumably no, for he comThe of mocking judge that.

Faced with divisions in the ranks of the miners, the militant areas had a right to act and a right not to be held back by areas like Notts which did not feel threatened and would probably have voted peacefully to accept closures in other areas:

To make a principle of a national ballot at all costs meant letting people other than those immediately affected decide to let MacGregor decimate the coalfields.

Once on strike, miners had the right to appeal to other workers by picketing them, and to other miners by picketing them out.

Credit It is to the credit and honour of the NUM leaders that they stood with the militants. It is to the credit and honour of Arthur Scargill as a working-class fighter that he has given a determined lead ever since.

The whole working class needed the stand the militants in the NUM have made in defence of jobs. A united NUM would have been better, but not every fight can be conducted under the best conditions.

Reid blames the militants and not the scabs. He blames and attacks the union leaders, and uses the bosses' press to join the Tories' propaganda war against His philosophy reproduces the basic idea of liberalism, that trouble and strife could be avoided if only the oppressed and exploited would be more docile and wait for reform through the proper channels. Indeed it could: there would be no union-busting if there had not been rough and bitter struggles to set up unions in the first place.

The idea that ballot rules are the highest principle is selfevidently faise. Suppose, for example, the scabs in Notts had tipped the balance against strike action in a ballot in March. Would Reid advocate that the militants, the miners directly affected, and the NUM leaders sigh, shrug their shoulders, and submit to pit closures?

The fact is that the NUM was divided. Why, once the militants were out, did they not have the right to i picket out the less militant? Does Reid - or Kinnock, for that matter — support

Scan page 5

the Tory laws against secondary

----- pull-quotes -----

predict five yeart atoad, i to produce 97.4 million tonnes in

NUR PICKFT LINE

Back the miners

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 197

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →