[The organised violence of the bosses' state: riot…]
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-09-20Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
The organised violence of the bosses' state: riot police at Orgreave picketing?
Reid argues that the strike may damage Labour electorally. He may well be right. Labour certainly will be damaged if the miners lose. At present Labour suffers both from the Tories' propaganda war and from its own weaseling leaders.
The best way to stop the propaganda damaging both the NUM and Labour is to face up to it fair and square. By running away from it or echoing it, Labour leaders will only make sure it gets at them. Nothing short of outright condemnation (and maybe not even that) can distance Labour sufficiently from the miners to avoid being hit by the stream of Tory propaganda. Nothing can protect Labour from the terrible consequences that will come to the labour movement from a Tory victory.
The notion that the labour movement could or should have avoided this confrontation underlies most of what Reid (and Kinnock) say. The militants of the NUM should have chosen peace and avoided the strike... by accepting the But the miners rightly did not choose to submit, and they refused to be daunted by the splits in their own ranks. The labour movement owes them an eternal debt of gratitude for it.
If they lose, it will be our fault for not backing them and joining them sufficiently. The fault will not be with the miners who started this fight back for jobs which is so necessary and was so long overdue.
But, says Reid, to fight without a ballot majority is not socialism, but Stalinism.
Now Reid should know about Stalinism. He was in the Communist Party for nearly 30 years oefore he left in 1977, and for much of that time he was a leading Party functionary. He called his autobiography, 'Clyde-Built Man'. ', but he was given his final shape and rebuilt in the CP and on courses for Party functionaries in Eastern Europe and the USSR.
He knows about Stalinism all right. From Stalinism he has swung to crass middle-of-theroad Labourism. He identifies militant class struggle with Stalinism, and rejects both. He identified them before, but favoured them. Now he sees a refusal by fighting workers to treat constitutional legalities as gods to be worshipped, as the seed of a future Stalinist dictatorship!
Socialist Organiser 1s opposed to Stalinism in all its shades and periods, and no-one who reads the paper can doubt it. We are democratic revolutionary socialists who know that there can never be socialism without liberty and democracy.
We understand, however, that Stalinism is not an expression of working class struggle, but the action of a bureaucracy against the working class; and that right now we live in a bourgeois democraçy.
This bourgeois democracy allows large areas of liberty to the labour movement, areas which are now being attacked by the Tories.
But still the state and the institutions of this democracy serve the ruling class in a thousand ways. Despite what Kinnock, Reid and the official Labour leaders say, the state does not stand impartially above the classes. The law protects bourgeois property and enshrines the values that subordinate life to bourgeois property.
The police protect the Coal Board and the scabs at the behest of the government, and throw their full weight against the miners fighting for jobs. There is no democracy in industry.
This is a class-riddled democracy, hollowed out and undermined by the savage inequality which gives the rich in our society so many advantages over "Arthur Scargill has become the Ayatollah, the focal point for all the hard sectarian groups in the movement.
Jimmy Reid The idea that the working class should and must treat the institutions, rules, regulations and accidental majorities of this democracy as binding and even don labour militancy. Even the most reformist labour movement would not have got anywhere if it had been so deferential. We would have no unions at all if it were not for workers breaking the laws passed by Parliament which banned trade What Reid's idea means here and now is that we should let the Tories steamroller the mining industry. The class struggle cannot be reduced to a few basic "democratic' ground rules without becoming impossible in a complex society ruled over by a clever and cunning bourgeoisie with agents throughout the labour movement.
Especially so since the ruling class themselves do not respect their own rules. A lot of what the police have done during the miners' strike is illegal by their own laws. There Is no force standing above the class struggle that will call them to account for it — or give workers prizes for good behaviour when we stick by the rules.
Socialists who remain committed to democracy and believe there can be no socialism without democracy have to combine our commitment and education against Stalinism and totalitarianism, our fight to preserve and expand liberty and democracy, with an understanding that our aims can only be realised by class struggle.
Capitalist democracy does not function impartially between workers and bosses, and does not make them equal before the law except in the most empty, formal, and legalistic sense. We have to pursue our own class interests. If that fight demands breaking the bosses' rules in society, we break them.
The tragedy of Reid and the many others who swing from Stalinism to vapid bourgeois democracy (or the other way) is that they are wrong in both their phases. They are wrong that bourgeois democracy is a working class alternative to Stalinism — or that there is secure protection within it for the working class.
The working class has to prepare for, defend and carve out its own historic version of democracy, in opposition to both the bourgeoisie and Stalinism. But in the first place it must defend itself, whatever the legalities — even the legalities of its own organisations.
Right now the miners are in front line of working class self-defence. They deserve our active support. Reid and the other ideological scab-herders deserve our contempt and hatred.
Victory to the miners! SEVERAL programmes this past week dealt with scabbing in the South Yorks/North Derbyshire coalfield and depicted its effect on the community life of those areas.
However much such proa sared of the time, several of the participants in the films found their contributions severely distorted by editing.
Thus the programmes still reflected what the media men wanted to see and not what their interviewees saw. They did not reflect or adequately portray the strength of the strike movement which has expressed itself with such overwhelming power against the tiny nest of scabs and the vast armies of scabherding policemen.
The Channel 4 feature on Shirebrook, for instance, gave a wide picture of the area and focussed on one family with a husband scabbing. It became quite obvious that his wife had tried to dissuade him from going to work, but he was determined.
So she was left in a hellish situation, having to watch her children through the streets where she was jeered, and spat at. One child cried not to go to school because she'd been called 'scab' in the playground.
Channel 4 'balanced' their portrayal of that family's dilemma with coverage of striking miners and their families. They were shown getting up at 4 am to picket every day, eating cheap meals, run off their feet to make ends meet and facing police bullying and arrests in the street.
But the next night they showed a follow-up story of the poor scabs. Now we saw their caravan home with wrecked windows. They had moved to a quiet new "temporary" house in a village housing estate, having received numerous offers of holidays and finance. They were happy at last away from the confrontations in Shirebrook itself.
No questions were asked of cllr the family as to how they will cope after the strike is over and whether peace will reign after the police and TV cameras have departed. That 'happy ending' was obviously going to be temporary — the equivalent of a "Jim will fix it' stunt.
The TV Eye film was intended to convey a picture of scabbing at Kiveton Park. It showed the daily routine of picketing early morning and lunchtime, food parcels at the welfare club, fundraising socials and interviews with scabs, strikers and their families.
Many interviews and viewpoints from all kinds of people in that village were filmed but by the time the programme went on the air it was all reduced to a macho-battle between Harold Laws,. secretary of the NUM branch, and Norman Heywood (and wife), chief instigator of the scabbing!
The rank and file strikers' views were confined to a few quick shots while they focussed on Harold weeding his back garden, singing in the Welfare, and emerging from court. The viewsehe expressed were admirable and consistent with the union's fighting policies. But the programme presented him as though he carried all the weight of the strike.
Heywood, the chief scab, was treated differently. He was shown in the pit and in the scabs' van, being filmed at home with his wife and then driven to a rendezvous with the High Court applicants Bob Taylor and Ken Foulsden. ''They're my heroes," crooned Norman.
Finally, the Panorama programme on Monday.. 10th, looking at the traditionally 'moderate' North Derbyshire area took a more truly balanced 4l10,, obies and measured approach. It showed quite clearly management working with a deliberate strategy to bring miners in to work from outlying districts, bringing in several hundred. But it also showed the NCB failing to persuade the thousands who remain on strike.
It was interspersed with MORI poll findings which, although never fülly trustworthy showed that 'violence on the picket lines' did not contribute to scabbing and that now only four out of ten, compared to an original six out of ten, would support the call fot a national It showed that over 50% of striking miners were actively supporting the strike and that their attitudes had hardened. Their anger was submerged into a deep feeling that no-one would give in and the strike was not crumbling.
The mass branch meeting at Whitwell, which included women supporters, said it all. Back in March, feelings had been 50-5C for and against a ballot and the strike. Now a Panorama poll showed that seven out of ten people supported the NUM's policy and would stay out to win.
The viciously exploitative NCB strategy for scab-herding was presented - or rather exposed. Devised by Ken Moses, Derbyshire Area Director of the NCB, their plan was first to make a village-byvillage survey; then select those miners with good work records, mortgages and a wife not working and living in outlying areas away from the pit and not easily in range of the strikers. Then they did door to door visiting...
Other factors taken into consideration were the proximity of neighbours who might be hardened strikers and pickets. Then they arranged police cover to bring in the crop of scabs across what was referred to as "bandit country' in grilled buses driven by helmeted escorts and drivers.
THERE has been a general acceptance of the TV programme by the members of my Branch and other NUM members who I have spoken to. But I myself was rather critical of the programme, mainly because I know what sections had been edited out.
The programme was too concerned with two characters -Norman Heywood, scab, vs.
Harold Laws, striking miner and branch secretary. There is no criticism of Harold intended, because like me, he thought the programme would be of a broader nature, covering all sections of the strike equally, i.e. the women's action group's role in the strike, police harassment, the individual comments of the striking miners about the situation in the village, the effect on the village people in general.
As we now know all these sections which were filmed and spoken about by Harold and myself, by rank and file members and the women's action group were cut. In their place was only a confrontation between two people, Harold Laws and Norman Haywood, and their different views on the strike situation.
I was also appalled that seven scabs should have 50% of the programme to air their views while 711 strikers received the Moses admitted that withou police 'cover" - intimidation o strikers and paramilitary scab herding services — "we woul have had a complete stoppage"
By contrast the NUM did no even have a list of all miners addresses! Their so-caller co-ordinated attacks that causi so much fear in the media, reall are contined to maintainin/ picketing and the welfare o strikers.
Again we had great coverag of scabs being shouted at, an accounts of their windows bein put in - but nothing aboi strikers being harassed whe scabs finger them to the police This has been very prevalent i this area during the dispute.
Moses' comments on a sca who had had his car unsuccess fully petrol-bombed were ver revealing. "Serves him right, h should have come back to wor sooner", his benevolent boc joked.
Of pickets facing cow charges he said 'If they gr found guilty, we sack them".
The NCB is determined 1 pursue its revenge and it it wir the strike there will be n stopping it.
Between August 29 to the da of the programme, Septemb 17, the NCB boss predicted doubling of the number of scat - now 737. In fact, despit spending so much money, tim and effort the number had onl risen to 869.
As the NUM's Gordon Bu ler remarked, "At the rate r getting 20 more in a week, hor long will it take to get 10,500 Probably till the next century."
The women gathered at Wa sop Main Scabs' Alley ever afternoon summed it up, th media and the polls bein incapable, 'We've got ur we're standing up and we'r sticking out for as long as i takes. We'll go to this Christ mas, we'll even go to the nes one. We'll win.
Albert Bowns other 50%. If this is impartialit as recognised by the media, the surely organisations like th National Front and the Commut ist Party should have equal T time to the Conservatives and th Labour Party during the nex election.
The producers were mor concerned with the confrontatio of the two major characters tha with the major issue - th betrayal by seven scabs of a NUM branch and the village.
The fact that police haras ment was never mentioned in th whole programme also concerne me. They were shown to be play ing a quiet role of amiable refe ees when in fact the massi police presence in the village w: the sole reason for there being scab presence at Kiveton Parl Without the police, TV Ey would not have had a story t film in the first place.
Also on the question of poli ing and general harassment, th fact that we havé had 80 men bers arrested and four imprisor ed was a glaring omission as wi the uniqueness of the minir community. Both these question would have given the viewer th answer as to why mining con munities in Yorkshire are 1 strong in their support of th union and their communities.
Scan page 6
‹WILLWIN THE M ALCULOS with
Scan page 7
JOHN HARRIS Socialist Organiser 101mm read ALL
Scan page 8
September
----- pull-quotes -----
COALL STOP