Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Songs on our side

Socialist Organiser no. 197, 20 September 1984 · scan p. 10 · about 1,152 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Brian O'Neill talked

FOR anyone with more than a passing interest in popular music it's been an interesting year. So far, I would pick out three high points. First there was the release of the Specials' "Free Nelson Mandela" , then New Order was the first nationally known group to play a benefit for the miners, and now the latest release from Robert Wyatt.

Called "Work in progress" it is a fourtrack, 12 inch single. The choice of songs reflects Robert's continuing interest. in performing songs that focus on issues for which he feels it is important to show his support.

The tune most reviewers are picking as the outstanding track is Peter Gabriel's "er o" Stale with there in Steve Biko while in South African government custody, but the others are equally enthralling. "Amber and Aubergines" is his salute to those involved in the Grenadan struggle, with Robert's words set to music by Hugh Hopper. .The other two songs are "Yolanda' by the Cuban musician Pablo Milanes and «Te Recuerdo Amanda" by Victor Jara, sadly now dead, who was one of the more well known victims of the military regime in Chile.

For most of the record he is his own accompanist on a synthesizer programmed to sound almost like a harmonium which gives a suitably warm background to his highly individual and compelling voice.

Recently I interviewed Robert. It is best to let him speak for himself, but since I've had to edit the razversation it doesn't truly show his warm sense of humour and deep feeling for the oppressed peoples everywhere, especially at this moment, Latin America. What maved you to choose the songs you use?

I tend to get my inspiration and encouragement from looking at wherever people are standing up to big money, power. Steve Biko, for example, represents a spirit I really admire. So I look for any examples I can find in the form of a suitable song. I like the folk tradition that if it's a useful song it can be done by lots of people in lots of places but we have particular responsibility to songwriters or people who've been killed or silenced, to carry on their work. In the case of Cuba it is to help indicate that they do have a flourishing culture.

How do you feel about the media tending to make you some sort of icon of the Left?

I think I'm treated with quite a lot of circumspect caution about • what I'm doing having political meaning, and it I'm not, I think should be, because in the end musicians don't do the trick. But I don't hedge my bets and I do take sides.

There is a tendency for musicians to be frightened of losing audiences and saying things like "I want to sing about Ireland but I don't want to be rude about the Catholics or the Protestants": so they end up with a neutered record. I haven't addressed myself to that issue at all, but I don't mind losing half my potential audience if it means making clear what side I am on with any given issue.

Do you ever think about your participation in the pop world with its capitalist axis?

I don't have the freedom to choose. There is only this way of doing it available to me, and to that extent capitalism is absolutely totalitarian - I have to participate in that machinery in order to earn a living. I take it as given that that is the situation and try to jaywalk my way around, holding up little flags which are morale boosting signals towards people. The only thing I can do is find the most honourable record company to do it through, and look for material that has no ambiguity whatsoever - you don't have to guess what thinking.

In a way I'm part of the protest tradition but having seen so many protest movements absorbed into the mainstream, I'm very cautious about making claims - for rock musicians reflect current tensions and are not capable of creating them. After all, how can a few songs that I sing about what is wrong with NATO compète with a Hollywood blockbuster glorifying US soldiers?

In a similar way I've never seen any aesthetic avant-garde movement that hasn't been absorbed . by mainstream capital. After all Saatchi and Saatchi are leading collections of it; they have it and don't feel threatened. One can't underestimate the gargantuan power of capitalism.

You've been living recently Yes, it was a very happy six months, but the overall picture there is ominous. They've done what the French did with Mitterrand, that is voted for a 'nice' left which effectively means letting the conservatives have a holiday for a few years. The situation is a bit grim as I think Gonzales is basically a coward, a Harold Wilson. It makes me wonder how long people will go on voting for figures like that just because they call themselves socialists.

How did you come to the Communist Party?

Well I heard about this bunch of people who wanted to undermine international capitalism and thought, that sounds like a good idea!

So I joined and found there is no great left wing plot to undermine capitalism, just a bunch of nationalistic groups trying to up the local wages. Practically speaking, for serious communists, the trade union fight for wage claims and recognition is the main priority and I'm happy to be part of any body of people who will support, say, the miners to the hilt without sitting on the fence.

At the same time I'm exasperated at the establishment of the CP and other left wing parties not reclaiming the issues. They tend to react defensively, building negative personality cults around people such as the current Prime Minister, that the right wing press build positive personality cults around. They don't do enough to say that these are not the arguments, that it's about the rich getting richer and the poor getting poorer.

They also spend a lot of time bickering internally.

Too true. The right seems to have adopted our slogan "Unite and Fight" - perhaps we should readopt it! Tensions between the left can be healthy, but it's getting to the point where we're destroying each other. That's what is sad. I hoped that when the SDP lot split, all those old Labour careerists would have gone and left the Labour Party alone to be a party of change.

It comes down to specific points - do you support the miners? - of course you do. If you even have to think about it you shouldn't be in There are plenty of parties willing to sit on the fence -join one of them. If you can't make radical change happen, you should support it wherever you can, be it the miners or the struggle in

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 197

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →