Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Courts versus NUM

Socialist Organiser no. 198, 27 September 1984 · scan pp. 3–4 · Dave Barter · about 1,640 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

THIS Monday, 24th, the Yorkshire NUM refused to appear in court to reply to a case brought by two members at Manton colliery, aiming to force the area NUM to call a ballot.

Area officials said that the reason was that they had not been given sufficient time to prepare their case; they had asked for a two-week adjournment and were given only eight hours.

Kiveton Park NUM delegate Albert Bowns told me:

"On August 6 proceedings were taken by Foulstone and Taylor. There were 36 affidavits taken out, and the High Court was asked for a wide range of orders against the union.

"During the previous ion complaints procedure which is open to all members.

*The allegations cover 200 pages of detailed legal argument. The union has had only 12 working days to study and assimilate the documents.

*The union was asked to prepare a case while taking responsibility for 55,000 members in a critical period for the dispute"

Albert Bowns added:

*I believe that the union has been denied the right to defend itself in a proper manner. It only reinforces the belief in the mining community that every arm of the Tory government, and that includes the judicial system, will be used to defeat us

Scan page 4

Socialist Organiser no. 198 September 27 1984 Page 4 the rate-cap British SaRA I NUM picket at BSC terminal, Hunterston, on 21 September. strategy of tension? Paul Whetton, secretary of the Notts miners' rank and file strike committee [in a personal capacity] writes his weekly diary.

I DON'T know how much of it is going to come out into the open, but I certainly hope that at Labour Party conference the error of his ways is pointed out to Neil Kinnock in no uncertain terms.

I would imagine the NUM delegation would have something to say about Kinnock's attitude to the miners' strike, and I would hope that the constituency delegates will have something to say.

As recently as yesterday you had an organised police riot — there's no other way to describe it - against defenceless pickets at Maltby. That really points to where the violence originates.

It started in Nottinghamshire, and the way things are going, we'll have a national riot police force for every occasion. It will Hunte Constituency Labour Party to the Labour Party conference. and we have got a resolution down on the miners' dispute. If I get a chance to speak, I want to try to point out to people what the present police action could lead to.

With the Police Bill, what we have been experiencing in the way of police roadblocks, stopand-search, entering homes, and all the rest of it, is going to become law - and therefore nobody can do anything against it, if you're going according to the book. But of course people aren't going to accept it like that. We're going to see an escalation of the opposition to the sort of things the police are doing.

Then you get the Tories using a strategy of tension, and the sort of measures used during the miners' strike becoming an everyday occurrence.

But I think the Labour Party conference is going to be pretty much like the TUC - signed, sealed and delivered in advance. I think the job of rank and file miners, and others who are involved in this dispute, is to point out the dangerous path that the State is taking. egy going to do anything that might undermine their position in the event of strikes taking place against their government. I can see them wanting the police to play a lower-key, but essentially similar role to under the Tories.

The reaction of the rank and file of the Labour Party to the dispute has been very uplifting. Newark has only got a few pits in its area, and the people right at the centre have really got no strong ties with mining communities. Yet they've really come over 100%.

Right from the start they've been taking the levies, doing the street collections — no big sums of money, but regular small donations.

Then they set up a support group and have forged strong links with the few pits that are in Newark constituency. I only wish the other constituencies in stronger parts of the coalfield had done half as well.

We've found that scabs have lashed out in all directions -withdrawing from the political levy, and so on. I think it's a reflection of conscience.

Photo: Rick Matthews On the other hand, from the striking miners we've had massive applications to join the Labour Party, because they've identified the political arguments behind the strike.

The politicisation of the women has also been marvellous. We want to make sure that's an ongoing thing after the dispute is over.

On the TUC decision, our original fears were well-founded, that the TUC was just going to be words and nothing more. Attempts to join rank and file members together across industries have born fruit in some cases, but in other areas they don't want to know.

I think that reflects leadership.

We're not expecting any great revolutionary surge forward from NACODS. It will be a great morale-booster if the deputies pull off their two-thirds majority, and I think they will.! think that the Coal Board will rush to buy them off. We' pinning no great hopes on it, but if a deputies' strike does come off, it'll be great. Hilda Kean, Labour leader of Hackney council, in London, spoke to Martin Thomas about the fight against 'rate-capping. The Tory government proposes to force 18 local authorities - of which Hackney is one — to cut services and jobs drastically by making it illegal for their budget to be above a certain level. AFTER the rate-cap was announced in July Hackney took a very clear position.

The figure that the Tory minister Patrick Jenkin is setting for our expenditure level next year is about £82 million. That doesn't sound too bad at first, because our budget for grantrelated purposes is about that figure at the moment.

However, our real budget, the money that we are actually budgeting for, is t106 million this year. The difference is made up from creative accounting, which is putting money into special funds, so it creates less penalties [the Tory government has been imposing penalties on councils that spend above centrally-decreed targets], and money we receive from the Greater London Council.

This is perfectly legitimate. and many authorities do this, but it does mean that if Hackney went along with the ratecap we would be faced with very severe cuts.

Our suggested budget for next year is in the region of £112 to £115 million, and yet the government is saying that we can only spend £82 million. There is no way that we could implement such cuts.

The position that we have taken is one of recognising that we do have to fight the rate-cap in the first year. The experience of Scotland [where rate-capping has already been introduced has shown us that if we do not fight in the first year then the government will continue to erode any control that we have over local finance. The first year is absolutely crucial.

The policy that we passed through the Labour group in July, and was passed through the council in July with every Labour councillor present voting for it, was to say that we will be presenting a budget for next year which will preserve jobs and services, and we will not pass on government cuts to defend jobs and services, and I think we have to learn the lessons of Liverpool. Their success was due to working with the unions and building a local mass campaign. That is where our attention has to be focused, rather than over-emphasising particular tactics which may appear esoteric and just manoeuvres in the council chamber.

I think we must also recognise that one of the reasons why Liverpool were successful is that they were putting forward a very clear position of a deficit budget - a position that was understood by local people, and one which they were able to mobilise local people on.

We also have to take on the argument about rates. An option that says that a rate won't be set does imply that rates are the issue. Rates aren't the issue. The issue is cuts.

That option also means that it is not clear to local people what we are saying. We have to be aware of the reputation of Labour councils. Unfortunately they are not as popular as one would like, and there has been a cynicism about promises made in the past by local councils.

So you have to have a very clear position that local people can see you are keeping to.

I think a deficit budget is the preferable option, but the main thing is that we have said clearly that we are going for a strategy of confrontation.

Mobilise?

The position taken at the national Labour Party local government conference in July, and which was subsequently adopted by the National Executive Committee, is generally one I would support.

It did recognise the necessity for a strategy of confrontation. It emphasised that within that there might be local differences, and that tactics need to be discussed on a local basis.

However, the main issue now is to what extent the Labour Party will actually mobilise support nationally for councils taking such action.

We also need to keep hammering home to the Labour Party that it isn't a question of rates. Some people have argued that what authorities should be doing is saying that we should be allowed to spend at higher

----- pull-quotes -----

weeks of the strike, these two didn't complain through the un-

Back the niners

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 198

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →