Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Move to gut reselection

Socialist Organiser no. 198, 27 September 1984 · scan p. 5 · about 1,209 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

APART from the miners' strike this year's Labour Party conference will be dominated once again by the issue of democracy in the Party.

The left will be fighting for proper representation for women and for women to have a real voice in the Party. The left is also supporting the demand of black members to have the recognised right to organise independently.

The right is backing Kinnock's attempt to start gutting mandatory reselection and shift the balance of power back towards the Party establishment.

Women's rights and black sections will be debated on Wednesday; re-selection on Tuesday.

The NEC majority advocate reselection, where there are sitting Labour MPs, by way of individual ballots of Party members instead of the present collective procedure whereby branch and general committee meetings select and reselect. They propose to cut out delegates from affiliated trade unions. Under their proposed new procedure Party members wouldn't even have the chance to interview the candidate, let alone make the sort of balanced political assessment GCs can make now.

The NEC is backing the *Evans' proposal which has been cobbled together to try to win a majority this year. But its anomalies are well-known and widely happy atects only affects CLPs with sitting criticised and even the right is not happy with it. For example, it MPs, and is voluntary. Some the right wing see it as irrelevant. Parties that are likely to kick out Peter Shore or Gerald Kaufman will be Parties unlikely to throw them the lifeline of a membership ballot. For the lett the point is that it is a first step, and its implications are clear.

Labour Party chair, Eric Heffer, told Socialist Organiser:

*What is being suggested involves a very fundamental change in the Constitution. Trade unions have had a real input into the Party, and the proposal will involve excluding them. They might pay their money, but they won't get their say. Of course, it's excluding the rank and Da 1 Eric Heffer Vladimir Derer, CLPD secretary, also saw the attack as 'fundamental':

"The implementation of "one member one vote is really a recipe for destroying the Labour Party as a political party, as a decision-making party, and to reduce it to the US model of a party existing solely for the purpose of elections. In this, Conferences have nothing to say.

"What the proposal is really about is reducing the influence of the rank and file on policies by attacking accountability. It is only by making the Party's representatives accountable that anything can be achieved. This is what the proposal is really about under the smokescreen of extending the franchise.

The right want the proposal carried this year in time for this round of reselections, due to start on December 9. But there are also amendments which suggest that the issue be postponed until next year's conference when a 'better' resolution than the "Evans' proposal can be put.

The Constitution says that timing of a selection must be agreed between a CLP and the NEC. This means that if the "Evans' proposal is defeated or withdrawn, Kinnock and the right can use this technical provision, together with a conference decision to postpone the decision to impose a moratorium on selecting until next year, Some leftists advocate postponement in order to avoid a defeat on re-selection. Postponement would be preferable to defeat, of course, but only if re-selection under the existing procedure is allowed to start after December 9. If it isn't, postponement will have played into the hands of Kinnock and the right. The problem is that there will be no procedure, apart from winning a majority on the incoming NEC to ensure that re-selection will go ahead after Some other people want post ponement because they don't want to be tied to the 'Evans' proposal, which they see as inadequate: They want a moratorium.

Inspired by the ILP and an important section of the LCC, the amendments from Glasgow Hillhead and Birmingham Selly Oak the proposal for a moratorium."

The widespread use of indivlidual ballots in last year's leadership elections shows that a number of CLPs are attracted by the idea - but a majority will probably vote against the 'Evans' proposal, some because of its anomalies and the lack of discussion on it, others because they oppose it in principle. 37 CLPs and ASTMS have submitted resolutions and amendments opposing the move. The decisive vote will, as always, be that of the trade union section.

Until recently, Kinnock expected the support of the union leaders. But a series of recent executive decisions has now put this in doubt.

The TGWU EC decided firstly to ask for remission, and then it necessary, to vote against the "Evans' proposal (decided 27-7). The NUR EC decided to vote against, reportedly against the advice of Jimmy Knapp. ASTMS and UCATT will vote against. If the union delegations follow their EC votes, then the outcome on Tuesday will be very close.

If the 'Evans' proposal is carried, then the left must organise an immediate campaign to get as many CLPs as possible to publicly pledge that they will stick to the existing reselection procedure. The battle won't be over, but if "Evans' or postponement, (giving Kinnock the option of a moratorium) is carried, the left will have suffered a major By Judith Bonner, CND National Council, [in a personal capacity]. DELEGATES should reject the NEC's defence statement Defence and Security for Britain".

It is being presented to conference without any prior discussion in the Constituency Parties or affiliated trade unions and without any possibility of amendments being added to the text.

It maintains, more or less, a commitment to unilateralism. But it abandons the previous commitment to reduce defence spending - even to the level of Britain's European allies.

And it calls for continuing British membership of NATO. It calls for *changing NATO strategy' to secure a 'non-nuclear defence policy within NATO'. Precisely why membership of NATO is in the labour movement's interests or how it is possible to commit NATO to anything other than a nuclear policy is not explained. are expected over the weekend.

In fact, membership of NATO and unilateralism are incompatible. NATO's current policy is to break down the distinction between conventional and nuclear weapons by producing conventional weapons of incredible power and integrating them into its nuclear programme.

So the NEC's view of what should be done about NATO is based on complete fantasy. It fails to recognise that NATO's aggressive stance is not accidental, or a mistaken policy, but essential to its whole reason for existence, which is the defence of Western capitalism. In fact the NEC's call for greater spending on conventional weapons fits well with NATO proposals.

the document cannot, given this perspective, propose any action, and it does not. It leaves everything in the fight for 'peace' up to govern ment negotiations.

Labour has organised no major disarmament event since 1981. Even for those few elements of what the NEC proposes are desirable - the commitment to getting rid of Cruise and Trident, for example — it proposes no action whatsoever. The document should be kicked out.

----- pull-quotes -----

What's being suggested is just a ploy to defend certain people." gut HARRIS NHO

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 198

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →