Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[tion, which the defence policy statement has in…]

Socialist Organiser no. 198, 27 September 1984 · scan pp. 6–8 · about 1,834 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

tion, which the defence policy statement has in my opinion rather naively omitted -if you did try to close the American nuclear bases in Britain, would they go? I don't for one moment believé they would pack up their missiles and go without a very serious argument.

But at least we've launched into the argument. We've launched into it from the weapons technology, or unilateralist, aspect. But once you open up that argument at any point, the whole argument goes into the melting pot and has to be looked at again. The question is, what is the right way to do it, if we want to win majority support for a different foreign policy.

JB. How serious a set back do you think the change on reselection could be?

TB: It's very difficult to say. Some people would like to roll back the whole democratic reform, without any doubt.

This has been presented as extension of democracy Party members. Actually This proposal deneunces the proposition ... by Frank Field ИР .. that an electoral pact be initiated between the Labour Party had this Alliance • • • to defeat this Conservative administratic at the next Genet U"lection.

#riote, Conterence halls EC and the MLP to make that it is the siness of this fort to work sonarus=a-traly socialist society and not simply.to..attain a government of contenionce to gain porter at ray cost."

Resolution 404 -frem.- Bolton South East CLFTE 1984 Annual Conference.

Resolutions

Anyone who th issue of Frank Fields Has one Circle alliance with the Leatals and SDP, is just a matter for local *that. there. are resolutions and amendments on this issue, from York, St. Helens and Deptford, as well as the above from Bolton, at this year's conference,

Scan page 7

"Katner than changing our policy on nuclear weapons, we should change our entatives in the yard. Thet Their ar nat loos can be suved by! Lairds hair urged Lairds workers to accep yorker -tamery walking out the secretary of management's plans for redum Occupation dancies - and even privat: tion! - to keep a piece of the BuT-Controe Merseyside сара When some of us refused to recent m ing in support of the accept sackings and wiccupied-an-. upation, th xperience unfinished warship and an oil- ferse that WI Tak rig he condemned i as sust a tethin pting redundan ects Jespent IS by the mOSs depe ned «been given their support for the incup will ive up to ed tradition, who uppor majority ation. Hundredstol stikine miners will be full have @ rnerever-to-jaum locat Sile cocal party and who relent - Unfot amately, their MP has arionist rifF the occupation i and tesslycontinue - to oopose the local pickets I to thow their Larit:- of the party arty on these androther issues. Dockerg and tagbeat eec MP They Latest to have refused to remove the went Thick- Latt defe antoditionall gere the slee move- Mersey side group-of- Lab-kir. MPsi The astru workers ent # Tank Held's refusal to have given their fall. public- local jobs ule apport.the fight against redun- port. words we Socialis lancies at Camell. Lairds ship- Yet, after three months.. not We dons Pinks Field tard, one word of support for the He should đo the wap ent thing He gave us the impression occupation has come from Віг- and take himself to joill the mat he would rather meet local kenhead's Labour MP artin Thomas IB How record of eader over in office, by the electoral college, is the thing we should be pushing.

Whether now is the right time to do it, in terms of winning support, is another matter, but until that question is resolved you're going to have some elements of the Parliamentary Party trying to reverse the democratic gains.

do you see the Neil Kinnock as the last year?

TB. I worked very hard on the electoral college, and we got it and elected a leader. I think we have a commitment to get him to 10 Downing St.

And I think that over the last year the Party has been glad that the particular question of the leadership has not been on the agenda, in order to free us for the struggles we have had to undertake.

MT. The Campaign for Labour Party Democracy has argued that, as a matter of principle, the electoral college should be put into motion each year - that the leader and deputy leader should be elected each year, just as in a on TUn# -past of Party inemers fade fend the gains made a ecent years internal emocracy and In socialist NCONCE - all of which ted by the m Birkennend Party mem. Bers ingered the local labour moveConstituency Labour Party the officers are elected each TB: The central question at the moment is how you can mobilise the Labour and trade union movement in support of those who are engaged in struggle, and anything else might be held to be a diversion.

I can understand the logic of the CLPD position. On the other hand, I think from a point of view of putting first things first, the decision this year was a correct one - to concentrate on the other aspects and not reopen that particular matter.

JB Some other questions are likely to be important at the Labour Party conference. One is the question of black sections...

TB: Yes. I'm all in favour of them...

JB: And another is the question of how to fight the attack on local government and local democracy.

What's your assessment of the Liverpool experience? TB: Liverpool fought with considerable skill. They were absolutely a case on their own, because they were way out in terms of their crisis.

They had to resist the way they did. They won. They got concessions. They very sensibly accepted what they got, which wasn't everything they wanted, but far more than they expected.

And now they're marking time, and next year all the MPs this group of hot-heads' Solidarity The Wirral Trades Council. tha District Labour Party: Labour local authorities will be in line, and then, I think, the thing will go forward.

There's been an enormous change in people's perceptions. The statement.of non-compliance that was issued after the Sheffield [Labour local government] conference represents a major change.

But more generally, what has come forward is the whole strategy of victory.

There is one strategy that believes that if you keep a low profile and are moderate, then you will pick up enough Guardian readers from the SDP to win.

The other view is the view that Liverpool adopted, and the miners have adopted, and we adopted in Chesterfield -if you go absolutely out on a clear policy, you win support.

I would think that in America Jesse Jackson, by mobilising the black vote, has been in a strange way engaged in the same thing - the idea that you win by bringing into an involvement in the political process people who hitherto haven't voted at all.

I think that the strategy of victory is a strategy of mobilisation and not of going for the centre ground of politics.

MT: Do you think the idea of a coalition - which was quite common last year - is now dead?

TB: I think the Hobsbawm argument, which was a deep pessimism based on a faulty analysis, has had a terrible Pd. " Field tinks and down the sad. But as Coombes." roduc or the UnE cornel, printer out a0 cies: ti nly - defend jobs militant actions and by gaining the but movemen, support the labour movement kenhead 'is a label aưwn fine -tradition-s clas desaints an MP Are socialist policies SDP. The sooner better policy on NATO"

knock this year.

There's a phrase from Hobsbawm which Michael Foot quotes in his book, in which he says that industrial militancy has no particular role to play...

This idea that you can draw the anti-Thatcher forces into a winning coalition is an absolute dead duck.

The SDP now itself is uneasy with Owen, and Owen has appeared as a figure of the hard, hard Right - well to the right of Heath and Pym and all these wets in the Tory party.

To that extent, coalitionism is dead, because it has been proved in struggle to be ineffective. Look at Owen on the miners - how could you ever talk about the SDP being part of our anti-Thatcher alliance? The so-called anti-Thatcher alliance is even more an anti-socialist alliance.

So that idea of an anti-Thatcher alliance is in decline.

But if you ask whether the strategy *of the Establishment could be to go for a coalition in order to beat a growing strength of the labour movement, I think that is the strategy, and I think that explains why Owen personally has had such an absolutely glittering press coverage.

I have no doubt at all in my mind that if the movement of opinion got to the point that the miners' strike and the GLC and the fight against rate-capping and the black community and Ireland all came together, the Establishment would go very, very hard for a government of national unity.

JB: How do you see the general political situation now? TB: I think it is important that we don't appear to be defensive. We are in a defensive posture in terms of local government, health service, trade unionism, and so on, but we shouldn't be defensive really.

We have to take all this energy which has been generated and try to direct it in clearer and more specific socialist demands. People will make an effort to defend who are hesitant about it had their immediate interests, but better be quite clear in their you have to channel that minds that the prospect of energy to making demands of success for Labour depends a more explicitly political and upon this mobilisation. general character. For individuals, I feel at the moment that the only I think, personally, that choice that each of us has is that is the key to our success. whether to be relevant or irIf the miners were by any relevant to the struggle. The chance defeated - which capacity to stop what's hapthey won't be - then the pro- pening doesn't exist. spect of a Labour government The question of whether being elected would be zero. we're prepared to be a part of Therefore you have absolute- this movement for change, or ly no alternative but to sup- not a part of it, is a decision port the miners - I mean, I that every individual has to want to anyway, but those make.

LE IO AAA ATAT Demonstration in support of Liverpool Cit

Scan page 8

black sections! no.198 September 27

----- pull-quotes -----

trategy tory

Linity is sh PHO alicies - such tipeson int Birkawles Labour Party ha

leadership, local overnment. Next ispute and the

Tory MPs than workers' reprist a | personal yard open at any cost.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 198

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →