Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Poland: support ›lidarno

Socialist Organiser no. 198, 27 September 1984 · scan p. 12 · about 459 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

the law' from day to day, according to what they needed to do to suppress the miners.

Thatcher preaches law and order for propaganda — but she isn't hooked on her own phrases. She has not let her propaganda determine what she has done in the battle with the Mrs Thatcher believes in the rule of law — as long as it serves the rule of Capital.

In contrast to Thatcher, you, Neil Kinnock, seem constantly to feel abashed before Tory propaganda. You accept their biased partisan definition of the rule of law and of what democracy is. to keep some contact with 'middle of the road' and middle class voters, and you fear losing that contact if you are too closely identified with the miners depicted in the press as 'violent' subverting the rule of law' , and so on.

So you add your weight to the propaganda campaign against uS.

I think your choice is both short-sighted and unprincipled.

There is no way Labour can avoid being linked with the miners - probably not even if you joined the Tories and the SDP in a full condemnation of us. And if the miners go down to defeat, then the whole labour movement will inevitably be depressed and at least to a degree demoralised.

The Tories would follow up their victory with an offensive in every industry, believing that they had the whole movement on the run. They would step up their attacks on the welfare state.

The electoral consequences for Labour from a defeat for us would be crippling. Your condemnations of us would not save you from those consequences. We can deny the Tories such advantage only by denying them victory over the miners.

The miners' strike has become a decisive battle between the working class movement and the ruling class - the most important working class struggle for over a decade. Its outcome will probably shape British political life for a long time to come. You can, if you like, make smart-alec half-baked unjust comparisons between Arthur Scargill and a First World War general. Whatever you say, Scargill has the confidence of his "troops' because he, too, knows what side he is on and he knows how to lead.

The question is, what side are you on, Neil Kinnock? So far you have been on the fence for most of the strike. You should get off that fence and come down on the miners' side - the side of the working class.

If you don't, then you will certainly not be forgiven by the miners — and not, I venture to predict, by the rest of the labour movement either.

The miners will win!

Yours sincerely, Paul Whetton. example of internationalism. ERIC HEFFER MP

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 198

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →