Taking sides
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-10-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
THE LABOUR Party conference was right to condemn In a class war — and this miners' dispute is a class war — the job of the Labour Party should be to side with the workers in struggle, not to pose uselessly as an umpire between the workers and the The mining communities are fighting for their livelihoods, and for They face a vengeful boss-class government which started the strike by closing pits - without consultation, elections, ballots or The miners face anti-union laws - passed by an elected parliament, to be sure, but laws which aim to stop the very lifeblood of real democracy, the right to resist of the working people. And where the laws are not harsh enough, the police make up The miners face a national riot police, organised outside the control of Parliament or the local authorities, making up the law as it goes along. Through roadblocks, arbitrary arrest by snatch squads, and bail conditions, the police have hit against the miners without any due The police are trained, highly paid, heavily equipped, and tightly Are they right to do so? No, if you believe the claims of profit, which require pit closures, should dominate. No, if you believe that the working class should not resist whatever is decreed by a governprofits and the profit system. Yes, if you believe we have a right to resist the government and its scab-herding police force. From the rest of the working class, the miners need full support. If rash or inappropriate tactics are used in the struggle, then that's a problem that the miners — who are sober, serious, responsible Pious even-handedness, condemning 'violence on both sides', is a Usually it is quite hypocritical. On Tuesday Neil Kinnock said that he was against all violence, "without fear or favour" been proposing that Labour pledge itself to scrap all armed forces and police. For armed forces and police are certainly no use unless In fact Neil Kinnock wants more conventional armed forces. He the police. He accepts violence for British national defence or defence of the established order. All he doesn't accept is violence in defence of working class interests. No ruling class and no police force was ever won over by speeches against violence. They are bold, confident and immovable in their The only effect of preaching against 'all' violence can be to weaken the self-confidence of working people who are already pushed toRule of law? Yes! But whose law? All law, ultimately, is clas impartially or to settle disputes by giving prizes for good behaviour.
five years for most of us, and between times rule by 'the people who know best' — the judges, police chiefs, bankers, and top civil servThe rule of law, in the Tory version, means that the only people permitter to use violence are the police and the armed forces — speThe prime civil right, for them, is the right of property - and they ped miners' right to the rule of law in order to make it easier for the For the Tories, when lan MacGregor tries to take away the livelihoods of thousands of miners without any voting or even consultamanage' The miners' dispute is a head-on clash between the rights of property and the rights of labour. The police uphold the 'right to work' of scabs, by violence. The miners defend the right of every worker to a livelihood, as something And between equal rights, as Karl Marx put it, force decides.
for 3 months; £8.50 for { months; and £16 To: Soctalist Organiser, 28, Middle Lane, London THE National Executive defence statement, Defence and Security for Britain , is to be presented on Wednesday, 3rd, to be voted on without amendments.
It will not be taken in sections. No major debate the life of effective trade unionism. on it will be allowed.
• This is highly undemocratic. The statement reverses much of Labour Party policy democracy. on disarmament. It is a sellout aimed to silence the Left and CND activists in the Party. In exchange for a halfnew ones. hearted commitment to Party policy on nuclear weapons, we will be forced to agree to. 1. Unconditional support CONCILOES for NATO and NATO's warprocess of law. fighting strategies.
2. No reduction in organised. defence spending for the foreseeable future. -3. Massive spending on modern conventional weapons, greater than that planment in office.
ned by the Tories.
The document contains an obvious subservience to US control and agreement to the continued presence in Britain of the US bases and the US army of occupation. It also retains all the trappings of the sneaky way of helping the Tories. capitalist war machine, including the assumption of a Soviet threat.
There is no commitment to release money and resources for alternative jobs for dethey employ violence. fence workers. There is no Democracy commitment to release money for hospitals, schools, ANDREW WIARD (REPORT)
use of violence to defend the rights of property.
pressures.
Democracy? What sort of democracy?
- spe• Labour CND rallv in Blackpool "I think this miners' dispute has haa shown two totally unprecedented things in the history of industrial disputes.
One is the involvement of women in this dispute - I think it is disappointing that the resolution doesn't make much more of that, because I am sure that Arthur Scargill, Peter Heathfield and the rest, would agree that without the support, which has been magnificent, from the door by post! for 6 months; and women in the mining communiRATES: £5 ties, this strike would not have for al year. had the strength that it has today. I think the other unprecedenName ted thing which is very shockAddress ing to us, is the scale of police violence. People always stari Please send me months' sub, I enclose & handing out these even-handed N8 8PL comments, we condemn violence from wherever it comes, and they
----- pull-quotes -----
Subscribe! Get SOCIALIST ORGANISER each week delivered to