Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Genera strike

Socialist Organiser no. 199, 3 October 1984 · scan pp. 6–7 · about 1,514 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

But I think you have to be ionists refusing to cross careful of sitting on the side- ers' picket lines to an I think the expectation that they will have to use troops to move the coal from the pits to the power stations is very great. As this goes on, it becomes clear that they are really desperate, and therefore they are making one last throw to break the miners.

But there is no indication that this is succeeding. Miners and their families are holding firm. They are not being beaten - the drift back to work, MacGregor's letters, the threat of a ballot which never came off, and so failed.

ANDREW MOORE Kent miners collecting funds in London now, after the TUC?

TB: It's certainly true that if the Nottinghamshire miners had been out throughout, 100%, it would have shortened the strike. It's certainly true that if the support that is now promised by the TUC decision had been given earlier it would have shortened the strike.

And it's certainly true now that the more supportive action can be given, the better. MT: In a discussion we naa before, you described the general strike as 'an industrial short-cut to socialism' which you opposed.

But if you have spreading industrial action - trade unmın• everour Party in 1972, when the five dockers were arrested. The TUC General Council said to the government. if you don't release them there will be a general strike. As chairman of the party I put a similar motion forward. It was carried unanimously, and in those specific circumstances that is right.

But I think also that you have to take account of the strategy of the miners themselves. I don't think it is right for people to develop wholly different and parallel TB: I don't disagree with that. You're now putting a formulation very much like my own.

What you're saying is that an understanding of what is at stake is growing, and that the no-picket-line-crossing for coal and oil is important. You can see an accumulating movement:

But it's important to recognise that those who are not directly involved are in a supportive role, not running a campaign of their own which is separate from those in struggle. That's very much in line with what a good socialist should believe: that the change in our circumstances will come from working people themselves, and not from people sitting in editorial offices or MPs' offices.

You've got to provide a supportive role - and that support has got to be 100% -and also an explanatory role, an analytical role, which is what you've done and I've tried to do.

As the level of understanding grows, and more and more people are drawn in, more and more people respond to what the NUM wants, then the movement has a rolling character, as you described. I'm not sure how far your formulation and mine are different, but what I am saying is that you've got to be careful you don't sit somewhere safe and come out with plans which aren't necessarily in line with people's perceptions or the strategy of the unions which are actually involved.

JB. There's also the propag anda role. You referred to 1972. The whole campaign against the Industrial Relations Act did prepare the way for what happened in 1972.

It happened on two differTB: There's an educational and an analytical role, but I also think that it's very important when people aren't actually involved in the strug. gle themselves their prime role is supportive and explanatory, not running a separate type of strategy..

Now if the NUM itself were to decide that the point had been reached when it should issue a call, that would be a different situation.

But the situation has moved. The TUC Congress decision was a very significant step forward, The fact that the NUM was not prepared to go to the General Council and have its strategy taken over by them, but was prepared to make an appeal to the Congress. and will make another appeal to the Labour Party conference - where it will get, I think, even more overwhelming support - is an indication of the pace and timing of the struggle. It now goes well beyond the question of Cortonwood.

It's a very, very much bigger struggle. And that's why the blacks, and the gays, and the Irish, and the women, and the local authorities are all being drawn into this campaign. It's got an impetus and direction of its own.

MT: But always somebody has to say it first. Before the TƯC called for a general strike in 1972 there had to bel months of papers like ours agitating for it, raising the idea. Somebody has to come first, and it seems to me that is the role of socialists.

Obviously you've got to be careful about the way you do it, and not counterpose your self to the actual struggle. TB: I'm only sayıng that there are different roles to be

Scan page 7

basic role of the police, which and worked out what was the iciet line. coutd have a tremendous effect' OFFICIAL pICKET perfor... * Arinur Scargu and Peter Heathfield and Mick McGahey are representing the NUM executive. The strike committees are doing their work. I'm doing my work in a supportive role. You're writing as a socialist journalist and giving an explanation.

I'd also say that if the principle of not crossing pickpaganda campaign against the NUM on this issue. And it has been reflected in our own movement, including in Neil Kinnock's speech at the TUC. TB: I've taken the same view as the NUM leadership. I've given a press conference every week in Chesterfield, and I've said that the issue is the violence of government policy, the violence of the media, diverted into internal discussion about what other people in the movement are doing. The important thing is that those who support the miners should be 100% clear in their presentation of the argument.

I do not want to get diverted from a comment on the Coal Board and the government, and supporting the miners, into a secondary argument about what other people should be doing that they are not doing.

Controlling the police MT: What conclusions do vou think we should draw from the dispute in terms of the policy of a future Labour government on the police? TB. There are enormous lessons. The national police force under the Home Secretary's control is wholly unacceptable and has not been authorised by Parlia ent.

The police chiefs must be under the control of the local authorities - properly under control. I'm not suggesting that the police committee decides where to put their effort in particular operational cases, but there must be total accountability.

Indeed, I think the argument for the police authorities appointing and being able to change the local police chief is unanswerable. judges should be raised. We should look at a retirement age for judges and a Parliamentary confirmation of judges comparable to the Senate's confirmation of Supreme Court judges in the United States.

The law and order aspects of all this - including plastic bullets and water cannon and so on - are very important.

Here is a case where experience develops understanding, and bit by bit as the dispute goes on you can raise these matters and they are seen to be relevant. If at the beginning of the dispute you jumped too tar ahead , people would have said. We're fighting on pit closures, why are you raising the magistracy? Six months later people regard these issues as directly relevant.

I have no doubt whatever that a Labour government will have to deal, and will deal, with these matters. MT: It appears that the present police operation has been planned and built up for since 1972 - and the buildup was going on continuously during the last Labour government.

TB: was.

MT: Doesn't that make the is not something new TB: The issues do go well beyond local control. It is a fact that the police are there primarily to uphold the law, which is itself related primarily to the protection of property and not of labour rights.

Why weren't the police there to stop Mr MacGregor sacking 100,000 steelworkers? The right to work -where were they? If the people at Cortonwood had turned up the day after it had closed, would you rely on a big police force to get them into work?

LAURIE SPARHAM (/FL)

appropriate resolution at each stage. On the principle that we didn't want to divide the Executive on the miners' question, we've put forward as strong a resolution as we could and got it carried, culminating in the July decision to have a joint campaign.

We have to recognise that there is a majority on the Labour Party NEC of trade unionists who have to keep in step with the policy of their own unions. That's where the TUC Congress will have made a difference.

----- pull-quotes -----

{ENT' STRIKE Fund

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 199

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →