A male world
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-10-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Hearteni BEING perhaps one of the first females to write a TV review for this paper I found myself in a bit of a quandary. Would the article become marginalised, seen to be a (typical) feminist's view of gender Women on the Left are still often faced with this circular reasoning - the issues are seen to be 'women's issues' and, like the tea and sandwiches, left entirely to the women. While we need space to work some things out on our own, gender politics are, patently, everyone's business Unhappily, until most men have sussed this out it remains up to us to keep putting it on the agenda.
So here I am, asked to review Minder. Great! Love the programme - just as much as I love Corrie Street and get hooked on Brookside (how come these progs. aren't reviewed more often? Could it be that despite attempting to depict working class life and having a mainly working class audience they are seen to be silly women's programmes? No, surely not).
What makes Minder popular? And popular it must be cos it's one of the privileged few with subtitles. For me it's initially the nostalgic (illusion of) realism; the accents, the overdone jargon, the London locations, the less than legit deals done with the flashy confidence of the, supposedly, up front City.
And then again there's the humour. Dear old Arfur, what problems he lands poor old Terry with. We laugh, or is it snigger, as yet again he earnestly defends some lost cause, adding that it's his money at stake. So used to Arfur's ways are we that we know that Terry's 'sensible' protestations will prove to be correct and, of course, will end up with lovable Terry having to physically "mind' his boss.
rt Wyatt IT was heartening to read of Robert Wyatt's new songs in SO 197. However, your interviewer assumed that the readership of SO would automatically know who Robert Wyatt is!
Firstly for your younger readers, Robert recorded Shipbuilding' - the song about unemployment and the Falklands war - which was a hit for Elvis Costello who wrote the song and recorded his own version of it last year.
Secondly, for your older readers, Robert was the original drummer of the Soft Machine, Glynis Powell reviews 'Minder' (ITV, Wednesdays, 9pm)
It's the inevitability that makes the characters humorous. But it's also double-edged. It's the pathos of the loser. Arfur always loses and Terry always gets the rough bits. How many times have you seen a British cop series where the central figures always lose out? Even if in Minder the police are depicted, like the petty criminals, as lovable but stupid rogues, the message still seems to be that it doesn't pay (literally) to break the law.
But as I said it's double-edged. Watching Minder, like watching Coronation Street is not just a passive occupation. Think of all those little snide remarks, touches of satire, and little victories over the police, the bigoted and 'fate' in general. They might not constitute organised socialist resistance but it's the strengths and pleasures of these little oppositional practices of everyday life that provide the real basis for any social change. This is one of the reasons for the programme's popularity, I think. It gives us space to enjoy these practices and in seeing them on the screen kind of legitimises them for us.
I don't suppose the producers think of it in that way, but they're clever enough to know what will bring quite a few laughs from their audience.
Take this week's episode, a particularly juicy one for my purposes, all about the discovery and 'come-uppance' of a multiple bigamist. Of course decent Terry and Arfur are suitably shocked at 'Confidence' Cosgrove's caddish secret. Terry is rightly indignant at the shit the deception has put the women with children who brought the poly-rhythms of '60s jazz to the experimental 'underground music' (as it was then called) of the late '60s.
Robert's drumming was matched only by his singing style. I used to think some of the Soft Machine's material a bit twee, a sort of suburban Sittingbourne Sound'. But no-one could deny their musicality.
I read somewhere of an observation by Robert that the potential of drum kits has really still to be explored. The fact that the modern drum kit is a somewhat recent invention In musical hisBesides if it weren't seen as slightly unnatural, there'd be no pleasure in the fantasy, would there?
Again the double-edge. From the very beginning we're given the "pleasure' of seeing Cosgrove as the desired lover of a number of women who he has also set up as managers of his business (what was that about women as exchange values?) On the other hand a moral stricture is hinted at as we see these very same women as harassed and over-worked.
Later, as our heroes are trying to help Casanova to lay low tor a bit he's taken to a health club. He protests that he's not comfortable out of the company of women, "it ain't natural" to be in a totally male environment he says. Ho ho, says the viewer, that's a bịt OTT, us lads down the gym are improving our masculinity.
At this point the writers risk losing the sympathy of these new fit bodies by indulging in a bit of homophobia. On his very first visit Cosgrove is approached by a gay bloke in the sauna, horror of horrors! Beyond the cheap giggle the implications are clear. If once you stray from the constant expression of virile heterosexuality this 'unmanly' fate lies in store for you. The 'unnaturalness' of the bigamist is transformed into the 'norm' in the face of 'unnatural' homosexuality.
But Minder's world is a very male world. Usually very tew women even appear, Daley's wife is present only in the awesome phrase, "her indoors". A touch of realism here perhaps? As a woman my public life seems to be dominated by having to take men seriously. Are men's daily lives so absent of women?
In this episode the fantasy/ Les Dawson factor (voracious sex, dominating wife, etc) is. set up at one end by the title, "A number of old wives? tales" and rounded mg tory, and demands the use of four limbs, would seem to indicate that there are some remarkable rhythmic permutations around, still to be discovered.
This serious attitude to the gentle craft of drumming has been carried over by Robert into his songmaking (Robert lost the use of his lower limbs a number of years ago after an accident at a party). Try and hear his versions of the Red Flag and Guantanamera. I'd love to hear him do a version of the Internationale...
Comradely greetings, JOHN DOUGLAS off by the last scene: all the five wives are brought together in the police station. Instead of rounding on the man they are made to enact a stereotypically bitchy scene and then run down the street, seaside postcard fashion, after their husband. "Hell hath no fury like a woman scorned" and this seems to be the only reprimand meted out.
Minder might have rid itself of its racist, anti-semitic 'jokes' but it certainly hasn't questioned it's reliance on these boringly traditional cliches of the Benny Hill type.
But that's obviously still what the audience want, isn't it? A bit of fantasy in a realistic arena, an easy giggle and a bit of pathos and common sense values. A bit like a soap opera, really, that much maligned form!
Look at the adverts they show in the breaks. Two about building material suppliers, one about an exciting new magazine 'Car' and one about buying your council house. All concerns designated to the male.
Look at the opening sequence. We're not only given clues as to Daley's trade, but more importantly we're shown, via alternating shots of the two characters' faces, just exactly what kind of relationship they have. It's all really quite sentimental buddy stuff and that's why we love 'em, just like Bet, Marie and our Barry.
The advantage the 'feminine' soap opera has over the 'masculine' soap is that by openly privileging the domestic and the emotional it sometimes explores and confronts real social problems. I think the average male viewer could cope with a bit of revolutionary display of emotional interdependence between men. Or perhaps they're waiting for the revolution to do it for them. as socialist.
In my view it completely misrepresents the issues and ends up confusing socialism with state capitalist measures.
Ross's argument runs as Follows. Keynesians and socialists can agree on the first step in an economic policy to tackle the crisis: increase demand for consumer goods by more state spending and/or by redistribution of income.
Where they differ is on the way to increase demand for investment goods. The problem is that this demand depends on high profits.
A socialist policy gets round the problem by government intervention to raise fixed investment, profitable or not.
"There is of course a way out of this situation. If the capitalists refuse to invest in the way that is needed then the decision is simply taken out of their hands. If this is done then the 'reflation' of the economy can be carried through on an ongoing long term basis.
Put in its simplest terms, and reduced to pure economics, that is exactly what the Bolsheviks in Russia did, Castro in Cuba did, and the FSLN is doing in Nicaragua. All simply refused blackmail from capital. They passed simple laws. Firms or capitalists which complied with the needs of the economy in increasing investment, output, particular needs of production and so on were left owning their companies. Those that did not had the decision taken out of their hands - through being nationalised."
Intervention
But a Keynesian policy, says Ross, rejects such intervention. And so disaster.
"Increasing demand for consumer goods, increasing public spending and so on will (where there are unused resources in the economy) produce a short term increase in output. But any sustained increase in output requires new investment - and the need for that new investment increases the nearer the economy approaches full employment and the limits of its existing productive capacity.
"If the investment does not take place then the result is raging inflation - as more and more money is pumped into the economy but the number of goods and services being produced does not increase (because investment and productive capacity is not increasing). ment of all the existing pro ductive capacity!
Ross's economic analysis i completely garbled. He get just about everything wrong it would take far too long ti disentangle it all.
His description of the dift erent policies is also garbled He even gets Keyne wrong. Keynes himself pro posed "a somewhat compre hensive socialisation of inves ment" - and thus, in Ross scheme, should be placed o the socialist side of the socia ist/Keynesian divide!
Management
The best sense that can b made of Ross's article is tha he has reduced Keynesianist to a particularly crude an limited form of demand mar agement. He is therefore abl to identify socialism wit bolder state-capitalist form of economic managemen and still believe he is drawin a clear line between socialist and Keynesianism.
None of this should dimit ish our solidarity with th Sandinistas against the threa and bullying of the US. Suc solidarity need not, an indeed cannot, depend o defining the Sandinis government as socialist.
That the Bolsheviks not nationalise industry unt 1918 is not very relevan power was held by worker councils, not of a radic nationalist guerrilla mov ment.
Misplaced enthusiasm h driven Ross to a positio from which it is impossible t distinguish socialism fro radical state capitalism.
Socialism is not abou getting the existing state t force capitalists to invest ‹ be nationalised, or even aboi radically democratising th existing state. It is abor razing the existing capitali state to the ground an replacing it with new instit tions of workers' democrac - and these new institution taking control over tr planning and organising the economy and society.
The existing state is thei to be used against the labor movement - as the action c the police and the courts no have shown - and they wi resist with force any serio threat to the ruling clas The Labour Party's con mitment to nationalisatio has to be defended again Hattersley's revisions. expresses the labour mov ment's commitment to chan ing society. But it is confused commitment and limitations need to be reco nised
Scan page 10
terna tionals