Whose whose courts?
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-10-11Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
"THE HABITS you are trained in, the people with whom mix, lead to your having a certain class of ideas of such a nature that, when you have to deal with other ideas, you do not give as sound and accurate judgments as you would wish.
This is one of the great difficulties at present with Labour.
Labour says: 'Where are your impartial judges? They all move in the same circle as the employers, and they are all educated and nursed in the same ideas as the employers. How can a Rights labour man or a trade unionist get impartial justice?
It is very difficult sometimes to be sure that you have put yourself into a thoroughly impartial position between two disputants, one of your own class and one not of your class" • Lord Justice Scrutton, November 1920.
antical police Jonatisarnice Malarowo Omerci paroos ikoniestmucdla l toRsumgD o nadrenideme ci PIWE жирові d thass nes shsarke: CheyoaNe the police are highly pol ical. WAC necie mbango nor mArs - lawa n odinmmiınnem- Téxe rer t i = ä ; *=- - Ezi. E: .-.
La. m" i. Ti im • = = THE LAW is not neutral or equal. Arthur Scargill and the NUM are quite right to defy laws which, if accepted, would reduce trade unions to housetrained pets of capitalism, allowed to bark occastonally but never to-bite.
Judges are not fit people to rule on whether strikes are official or not, or how unions should run their business.
Four out of five judges are products of public schools, and of Oxford and Cambridge universities. Overwhelmingly they come from upper-class backgrounds. Even those few who don't have been barristers -members of a conservative, highly-paid profession - for many years before they become judges.
. Judges are white, male, elderly, and wealthy — and they have all the prejudices that go with their position.
Laws can be changed by Parliament, it is true. That is better LAST WEEK Leslie Curtis.
lanirneti flae bertie derRomamec aradıtmat ama poins might not be able to offer government.
ToTM dONnA in tem maar cikien anä'sis BRAMINE IN In recent years many wistre MILES - es pH James Anderton in Marchest- анен.
gajga innal siroke they have •:Ei]:
Ti ui : : :.% 2-'C "L IT than rule by decree. But it does not make the. system democratic.
Parliament as it exists today is a very limited form of democracy. Most of us just get a vote every five years. Even then, capitalist control of the media means that there is not a free. fair, responsible and informed debate on policy:
Between elections, MPs can the July dockers' strike, the pENEÇe nasmen Twero liceam kowal(n Rykne wmy theta wąrm dabr gring iten ghany .JRât Am-. ing thda anniolr. anaerontestarant. tingampo licemnikiger' _THEMICH get aca yiet ioasnon wiacieiwn conditions on those they H:An mad hore DiEE 10003 nim -nist ii I•…._ =11: =- •I-÷÷ -i' "= .
is:"= do what they like. No-one even seriously expects that they will keep election promises.
Parliament is thoroughly dominated by the government, which in turn is much more influenced by bankers and bosses and the permanent state machine — top civil servants, police chiefs. army chiefs, etc. - than by Parliament.
Laws once passed by Parliament have to be applied and interpreted by the police and judges — and application and interpretation can make a huge difference to the meaning of a The political nature of the judges' job was made clear by Lord Denning when he ruled the Greater London Council's cheap fares policy illegal. The cheap fares had been central to Labour's manifesto for the GLC election — but according to Denning his judgment stood above the voters' wishes.
Denning also said that if a Labour government tried to abolish the House of Lords, the courts should rule it illegal. Imagine what would happen if a Labour government set out to overthrow capitalism!
The law is class law. The labour movement cannot and should not passively submit to capitalist class law, but should fight for a totally different form of state where there will be working-class law and order.
Riot police at Orgreave. Photo: John Harris Trade union law is not decided by a spirit of justice standing above: classes, but by class struggle. The labour movement cannot and should not bow down to Tory law. NO RIGHTS were ever given to the working class out of goodwill and concern for justice on the part of the ruling class. All our rights were won by struggle.
By courage and defiance workers have won trade union rights. Then; time and again, as soon as militancy ebbs, judges nibble away at those rights, or Parliament itself changes the laws.
The process also works the other way: in times of rising
Scan page 7
PA."