Why the law is class law
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-10-11Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
militancy, restrictive labour become a dead letter.
What is lawful and unlawful in industrial struggle has nothing to do with any principles standing above class interests. It is a reflection of, and a tactical element in. the balance of forces.
In the early years of industrial capitalism in Britain, all trade unionism was illegal, under the Combination Acts.
In 1824 working-class pressure forced the repeal of those Acts. In 1834 the judges hit back by dredging up an old law against 'administering oaths' and using it to convict six farm workers who had organised a union in south-west England. These "Tolpuddle Martyrs' were deported to Australia.
In 1851 a judge declared that for a union to threaten an employer with a strike was unlawful 'molestation' . In 1859 the unions got the law on molestation changed. In 1872 the judges found another gambit: trade unionists organising for a strike were declared guilty of "conspiracy' Fought Again the labour movement fought back. In 1875 the law was changed to give unions some protection from conspiracy charges.
The judges retaliated with the Taft Vale judgment in 1901, stach made unions liable to be é for the financial damage Pared by an employer through asi.
Ai = 1834, in 1851, in 1872, * many occasions more ==: trade union law was Sely being changed By. adges. The judges did not. remedying their grievances"
Sir John Donaldson, Master write new laws, but they took old clauses from the vast rambling structure of English legislation and used them to restrict unions in ways previously unthoughtThe 1901 judgment, coming at a time of rising militancy, was soon reversed by the Trades Disputes Act of 1906. The next blow from the ruling class against the unions came through Parliament, in 1927, when the Tory government took advantage of labour demoralisation after the defeat of the 1926 General Strike to pass a new restrictive law:
The 1927 Act was repealed by the Labour government in 1946.
But the working-class answer to legal shackles has never been, and should not be, quietly to submit and to wait for the next election and a more sympathetic government.
The 1945 Labour government was pushed by a wave of working-class militancy. It tried to maintain an anti-strike decree from wartime — Order 1305 -and withdrew it, finally, in 1951, only after dockers had been jailed for defying it.
The next Labour government, in 1964-70, tried to initiate its own anti-union laws, with the proposals entitled In Place of unotficial strikes which had flovered in the '50s and '60s.
Trade union opposition stalled 'In Place of Strife'. but an Industrial Relations Act was introduced by the Tories in 1971. Since TUC unions refused to register under this Act, they nur lost all legal protection. Any emplover hit by a strike could sue the umon.
Few did. in practice. The employers understood that Words in the statute book were not holy writ, but oniy one element in the balance of forces between classes.
Mass strike action
Mass strike action in July ,1972, when five dockers were 'jailed under the Industrial Relations Act, crippled that Act. The ; five were freed and the Act was jused only occasionally until the Labour Government repealed it in 1974, M In 1976 and the following years, trade unien militancy nose dived."True to form, the judges took their chance, and in court cases between 1977 and 1979 almost nullified the rela'tively liberal legislation passed by the Labour government in 1974 and 1976.
Solidarity strikes and 'secondary' picketing (picketing not at _your own place of work) were Ai homies thor were not in furtherance of a trade dispute' -but only 'in consequence of it.
In the case of Reg Fall, who had an injunction slapped on him to stop picketing during the lorry drivers' strike in 1979. the judge explained his bizarre interpretation in rather candidly political terms.
Secondary 'There must be a presumption". he said. "that Parliament does not intend to legislation to bring about its own destruction". Secondary picketing, so Mr Justice Ackner felt. endangered the fabric of society: theretore, even it the law seemed to permit it. in fact it could not.
Moreover, he added. he had to bear in mind the public interest. And strikes were not in the public interest.
A gréat part of what the Tor: ies did in their 1980 and 1982 anti-union laws was simply to write onto the statute books what judges had decreed in 1977-79.
Now — with those two laws and the 1984 Trade Union Act f the Tories have a vast array of legal weapons against trade unionism. Cautiously but ruthlessly, they are trying to deploy those weapons on the battlefield.
Justice, right and wrong, moral principles, have little to do with it. The ruling class changes laws, ignores them, implements them selectively, or twists the interpretation of them, as suits tactically.
The working. class_ cannot afford a less realistic view. • nıne Me a o an Cınenha BRAZILIAN bishops last week said it was morally right for starving people in the country's poverty-stricken North-East to steal food.
Citing the medieval. theologian St Thomas Aquinas, the bishops decided that the looting of markets and warehouses was justified by extreme hunger.
Neil Kinnock, in recent months, has spoke more like a would-be bishop than a working class leader. But it seems that in Brazil even the bishops would find him too deferential to the established order.
The miners argue that their fight to saye their communitics from becoming: wastelands of unemployipent. and ; despair, justitios breaking cłass Jaw img posed bara «fory: parliament.* capitalist, courts. and, ruthless police essence their argu-" ment for chuman rights againsti propery rights is the same as that: the people in Brazil's Norte-Fast.
But' in 'capifale law, impartiality means that property must 'THE LAW fats majeste ic equality forbids the "rich ashwall as the poor to steal' bread, to sleep Anatole France.
be defended whatever the in human suffering:
Lord Denning, giving à judgment against-squatters in 1971, put it like this:
"It homelessness Were once admitted as a defence to trespass, no one's house could be sate. Necessity would open a duor which no man could shut...
"Each man, would say his need was greater than the next man's. The plea would be an excuse for all sorts of wrongdoing.
"So the courts must, for the* sake of law and order, take a firm stand. They must refüse to admit the plea of necessity to the hungry and homeless: and trust that their distress fill be relievundar annitaliom monne inormolitzr.: aperanom mcano шисучажку ?
ed by the charitable and the Capitalist * law defends property equally: But one class owns the property, and another does not.
It was against the law tor the workers at Carmell Lairds shipyard to occupy the vessels being worked on at that yard. With great impartiality the law would equally protect any property the workers owned, houses for example.
But the formal equality betore the law means actual inequality — because the private property of British Shipbuilders is also the means of livelihood for the workers, while any private property workers have is simply for their personal use.
Capitalist market economics parmit millionaires quite legally to roo the working class.. So long as an employer pays the going wage, his transaction with a worket is a marketatransaction like any other, a sale and a purchase of labour-power treely agreed to by botla sides.
In the workplace, this free and equal transaction changes into something quite unfree and unt equal. The capitalist gains control over the 'worker's productive life and ownership of the fruits of his or her labour and creativity.
One class owns the means of production and • thus wealth, power, and the ability to maintain its privilege by exploiting others. The other class, the working class. depends entirely on trying to sell. its labour-power.
The law - which detends property equally and regulates • the market impartially — protects this inequality of wealth and power.
Scan page 8
'We need to say it again and again until our black comrades in the unions get organised' Socialist Organiser no.200 October 1984 (REPORTI ANDREW WARD BLA SEC
----- pull-quotes -----
Strife. They were designed to. of the Rolls, Nov. 1983
under bridges, andata beg for food"!?