Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Mirror Why StatEd is wrong 1:90

Socialist Organiser no. 200, 11 October 1984 · scan p. 10 · about 528 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Poland's government has been sending scab coal to Britain, while Solidarnose has declared support for the NUM. But some people on the Left are using a Sunday Mirror report that Lech Walesa attacked Arthur Scargill to justify their hostility to Solidarnosc. John O'Mahony discusses the issues.

truction.

«Because whatever is destroyed has to be rebuilt.

"I Nisagree with any violencer The workers should demand the maximul, but not at the risk of bankrupting the emninver."

Walesa had a message for NUM President Arthur Soargil: "To into the matter carefully and assess how much one can squeeze, But without, des troying.

It is forbidden that ambition take precedence over logic.

"Trade union activists should lock away their ambitions.

• "They should calculate 4hnia samaritaro har THE Sunday Mirror some weeks ago printed an account of an interview by Robert Eringer with Solidarnosc leader Lech Walesa in which Walesa appeared to side with Margaret Thatcher against the miners. The Sunday Mirror headlined Eringer's piece "Why Scargill is wrong — by Lech"

Quite a lot of Solidarnosc's frierds in Britain were shocked and its-opponents, semi-opponents and outright enemies - of whom there are a very large number in the British labour movement - seized on the article. It is cited again and again by labour movement activists to condemn Solidarnosc.

What did Walesa say? That is less clear than the Sunday Mirror's headline suggests but I will quote the Sunday Mirror.

After an opening sentence by the interviewer (or the sub-editor in the Sunday Mirror office). 'Lech Walesa has condemned violent tactics in Britain's pit strike", , Walesa is quoted as saying:

• The miners should fight, but with common sense - not with destruction.

Because whatever is destroyed has to be rebuilt.

I disagree with any violence. The workers should demand the maximum, but not at the risk of bankrupting the employer."

The interviewer (or subeditor) introduces another quote like this: 'Walesa had a message for Arthur Scargill" This is the "message": "Go into the matter caretully and assess how much one can squeeze. But without destroying.

It is forbidden that ambition takes precedence over hope.

Trade union activists should lock away their ambitions.

They should calculate on their computers how much they can get but, I repeat, not at he sake ture * destroying the struc. ture.

Eringer then says that Walesa expressed "much respect" for Margaret Thatcher and quotes him: 'With such a wise and brave woman, Britain will find a solution to the strike."

Philosophising I have cited all the direct quotes attributed to Walesa about the miners' strike and about Thatcher.

Now it is by no means impossible that Walesa would condemn trade union "violence" or produce this rather vapid philosophising on realistic trade unionism. And he may well think Margaret Thatcher is wise and brave — because of her strident rhetoric against the USSR, Poland's overlord.

These views would identify him as right wing or soft left if he operated in the British labour movement.

But for many on the left it isn't a matter of disagreeing . with Walesa. They question Solidarnoso's right to exist. They seize on things like the JOHN HARRIS

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 200

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →