Workers'unity East and West spite Fleet Street's effort to use Lech Walesa against the miners
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-10-11Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
we should back Solidarnosc by ROBERT ERINGER LECH WALESA has • condemned violent tactics in Britain's pit strike.
Poland's Solidarity founder said: "The workers should fight, but with common sense - not with desSunday Mirror article to support the grotesque idea that the entire Polish labour movement is reactionary or "counterrevolutionary. They adopt soft, tolerant or even friendly attitude to the Jaruzelski regime which has been trying to destroy the Polish independent trade union.
The refusal of the Morning Star to print a paid ad or a letter condemning Jaruzelski for sending scab coal to Britain is one measure of the state of the British labour movement on this question: the Morning Star was clearly confident that, it would not suffer for this implicit solidarising with Jaruzelski against the miners.
In an interview in last week's Socialist Organiser, Tony Benn responded to a question about Polish scab coal by asking: "But what about Walesa supporting Thatcher?" And Benn didn't sign the letter to the Morning Star.
Lech Walesa may — or he may not, as we shall see — have given the Sunday Mirror the comments which were used against the miners. We know for certain that Jaruzelski has sent scab coal to help Thatcher, increasing by three times Poland's exports of coal to Britain since the miners' strike began.
So Walesa may have made a few Neil Kinnock-like comments to the Sunday Mirror criticising miners' violence and Arthur Scargill's ambition. The conclusion does not follow that Jaruzelski — who gives Thatcher scab coal — was therefore justified in banning the Polish trade unions and attempting destroy them!
Eric Heffer was right when he said in Socialist Organiser two weeks ago: 'The entire movement in this country should have given Solidarnosc total support. Free trade unions [in Poland) would not have allowed coal to come in now"
The same message came in a broadcast from Solidarnose miners in Silesia:
'The underground Provisional Coordinating Committee of Silesian miners sends you frateranl agreetings and our support and solidarity for your struggle for the right to work...
"We will do everything possible to support your struggle. including in action. The protest we have sent to the Polish government and. Parliament is an initial measure taken in support of your struggle"
In Socialist Organiser we have also published this message from the Inter-Factory Network of Solidarnose in the Warsaw area:
'The slave labour of the Polish miners serves to break the resistance of the British miners.
'British miners! In the prevailing conditions of terror, the Polish workers' movement is at present not in a position to undertake protest actions. But you may be certain that we are in solidarity with you"
David Jastrzebski, president of the Solidarnosc committee in Upper Silesia, has sent this letter "to the striking miners of Great Britain":
"Our organisation sends you full support for your struggle. We are full of admiration for your stance and your unfailing willingness to struggle. We believe you will achieve your goals.
•'Neither the British government's mounted police charges nor its truncheon biows, any more than the Polish junta's tanks or rifle fire, can break our common will to struggle for a better future for the working class.
"We appeal to all members of Solidarnosc to support your struggle. Only the international struggle of the mass of workers can decide our fate"
To Arthur Scargill personally Jastrzebski wrote:
"Allow me to send you the expression of my support and my enthusiasm. For many weeks you have represented the interests of your trade union with dignity.
"At the same time I ask you to consider our own difficult situation — activity which is clandestine and under totalitarian threats — which means that there are many things we cannot resolve rapidly, often for security reasons.
'In the coming weeks we will send you greetings from other organisations lof Solidarnosc] which support your struggle."I wish you the best. and above all victory. I ask you to send our greetings to all British miners and our best wishes.
"Personally I am convinced that thanks to the attitude of your trade union victory is within your grasp"
In any case, whatever Walesa might say against 'violence' or against Arthur Scargill is irrelevant to the right of the Polish workers' movement to exist. Our duty to defend its right to exist cannot depend on the opinions of one of its leaders - or of Solidarnosc itself.
There are many in our own unions and in the Labour Party who condemn the miners and would like to cut Arthur Scargill's throat. We denounce them of course — and we organise against them. Only a suicidal maniac would conclude that trade unions, because they are led by Eric Hammond or John Lyons or David Basnett, forfeit their right to exist. Yet that is the underlying idea of those who pounce on Walesa's interview and say "We told you so about Solidarnosc.
Walesa is quoted saying things against a section of the British labour movement -therefore it is right for the Stalinist dictatorship to destroy the Polish labour movement? It is preposterous.
Solidarnose is a great working class mass movement, which had ten million members when it was outlawed in December 1981, 18 months after coming into being.
It is a unique movement. Never before have independent trade unions emerged in any Stalinist state.
Such a movement will span an immense range of opinions, as ours does. The 11 million strong British labour movement has Labour Party right wingers, Liberals, SDPers,* Tories, racists, some fascists and Stalinist supporters of foreign anti-working class dictatorships like Jaruzelski's.
Our movement - unlike Solidarnosc — is led by a quite distinct caste of materially privileged bureaucrats. We propose to change it politically, reconstitute it, democratise it. not help the 'reforming Tories put it down.
Nor can it nake any difference that industry is nationalised in Poland and Jaruzelski can perhaps claim to be defending naionalised property (though Solidarnose did not threaten to attack it).
For socialists, nationalisation is a means to an end, not the end: the end is socialism. The Scargill should unite with Walesa against Jaruzelski liberation of the working class from capitalist exploitation and from state tyranny.
Nationalisation is necessary for socialism, but it is not socialism, nor the only condition for socialism.
In the Stalinist states nationalised property is controlled by privileged bureaucrats by means of state tyranny over the people unparalleled in history.
The Polish labour movement was born in conflict with a state tyranny much of whose power over society comes from the state's control of the means of production.
Suppose that movement were, in reaction against Stalinism, to advocate restoring capitalism — though Solidarnosc did nothing of the sort - even that could not lead working class socialists to side with a Jaruzelski standing for nationalisation and "socialism" against "counter-revolution"
Real socialism which liberates the working class, and therefore society, from both exploitation and state tyranny, can only be created by the working class itself, acting in freedom.
Parasitic
The Polish labour movement - even were it making terrible errors - is a great deal more important for socialism than is nationalised property under the control of a tyrannical bureaucracy, parasitic on the labour of the workers and holding them in a police state vice.
The right of the labour movement to live, its ability to grow and to discuss its experiences and its programme for society — nothing in Poland, or in any of the Stalinist states, has a greater value than that, for socialists
Scan page 11
Socialist Organiser no 200 October F1 1984 Page 11