Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[DECISIONS at this year's Labour Party conference indicate…]

Socialist Organiser no. 201, 18 October 1984 · scan pp. 8–9 · about 1,047 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

DECISIONS at this year's Labour Party conference indicate that the Party is recovering from the panic into which t was thrown in the aftermath of the 1983 general election. Uncritical support for the present leadership is waning.

Conference disregarded the leadership's homilies on violence in general, and picket line violence in particular, and gave its overwhelming support to the NUM. It also threw out the NEC's Kinnock-supported proposals on reselection.

These decisions, as well as that on the police, do not necessarily mean that the Party's drift to the Right has been halted. The leadership's future pronouncements on the miners may turn out to be more cautious. Its basic position, however, remains unchanged.

As for reselection, Neil Kinnock has already indicated that he intends to press on with what he claims to be the extension of franchise in Labour Party Democracy, writing in a personal capacity) contributes to the discussion on Labour's Blackpool conference with an assessment critical both of the 'soft Left' and of the 'far Left' like Socialist Organiser.

the selection of parliamentary candidates.

Above all, conference rejected the proposals for this alleged extension of franchise largely because of the ineptness of the NEC's own proposal. The more sophisticated version of it (contained in the Bolton West/Selly Oak resolution) fell because of the rigidity with which the right wing trade union block votes were cast rather than because of lack of potential support for it.

The fact that conference is of several minds is shown by the subsequent rejection by conference of the NUM emergency resolution asking for more consultations and the defeat of the Composite resolution which unequivocally sought to uphold the existing procedure.

It was to be expected that after the Labour government's defeat in 1979 the demand for MPs' accountaulty would eventually come › be felt as less urgent. lemories of Labour's record 1 office were bound to fade. ith the defeat of the Tory overnment as the overriding riority, a climate of opinion as been created within hich abandoning Labour's ›cialist objectives has ecome "acceptable"

Thus from recent statelents by leading members of Le PLP it is clear that moves › undermine the Party's ›mmitment to public ownerlip aré underway.

The current campaign to extend the franchise" for le reselection of MPs is other symptom of this end to water down Labour's blicy commitments. nfortunately a large section the Party and above all the nions regard purely formal irticipation as a sufficient isis for a genuine demoatic process. They do not e mandatory reselection id the Electoral College as echanisms vital for ensuring countability.

Of course in an ideal world all Party members would directly participate in internal Party elections. In the real world, however, only a relatively small proportion of the membership is prepared (or able) to be as active as to attend even one extra monthly meeting.

But as things are now the General Committees of CLPs are the only rank and file bodies which at their monthly meetings - can systematically monitor an MP's parliamentary performance.

Should the function of reselection be taken from the General Committees, MPs would cease to be accountable to any body but themselves. Once again they would be free to pursue policies contrary to the Party's programme and to conference decisions.

The enthusiasm shown for "one member one vote" by those who fought tooth and nail against mandatory reselection and the Electoral College should make this obvious.

The fact, however, that a section of the Party which originally supported democratic reforms - "the soft Left" ÷ has joined in this attempt to neuter the reforms they helped to promote is symptomatic of the current trend to weaken the Party's commitment to socialism.

Like CLPD, the soft left organised in the Labour Coordinating Commitlee and Clause 4 correctly perceived that once mandatory reselection and the Electoral College had been won, continued internal conflict would damage Labour's electoral prospects. But whereas CLPD held that so far as the immediate future was concerned limited progress could be made, and this only provided internal conflicts were contained within Party channels, the LCC called for an immediate halt to any further reforms.

The difference of opinion was of little practical importance at the time because even slow advance turned out to be impossible.

Caution

LCC's caution, however, proved to have other sources than just the need for retrenchment. This is revealed in the LCC's recent pamphlet Reconstruction - How the Labour Party and the Left can Win', According to its authors the struggle for reselection and the Electoral College were never really necessary. The Left could have achieved more influence had it become the standard bearer in turning the Party "outwards"

It is of course also important, as the authors argue, to emphasise the urgent need for the Party to take account both of changes in the occupational structure and the growing political consciousness among disadvantaged sections of the population, such as women and blacks This need, and the Party's reorientation towards "campaigning" however cannot take the place of the equally urgent need to fight against the forces which seek to weaken the Party's commitment to socialist policies.

The Left cannot dodge this fight without at the same time abandoning socialist objectives. It can only seek to minimise its damaging consequences.

Thus any satisfaction from the fact that the Right has failed to make progress at conference must be tempered by the knowledge that this happened largely because of the upsurge of sympathy for the miners and the ineptitude of the NEC.

The Right's advance is only temporarily checked. It is essential that the Left now mounts a major campaign in favour of the principle of accountability.

It was not just the defection of the "soft Left", how ever, which made the Right's advance possible. The Bennite and "far Left" also prepared the ground for it.

Firstly by marginalising itself within the Party when it misjudged the Party's mood following the setting up of the Electoral College. Secondly by ceasing to regard constitutional issues as being central to political class struggle.

Support for the economic struggles of the working class and the defence of municipal authorities cannot replace systematic efforts to transform the Labour Party into a socialist one.

Scan page 9

JOHN HARRIS Socialist Organiser no.201 October

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 201

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →