Science, war and peace
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-10-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
ONE of the big battles of this year's Labour Party conference was over the setting up of Black Sections. The Labour Party machine, resolutely opposed to black sections, was backed up by the Militant tendency.
Militant went so far as to second the motion against black sections put in by the right wing electricians' union, the EETPU.
Of course, Militant's reasoning is different to the reasoning of Labour leaders like Stan Orme and Gerald Kaufman. For the Labour leadership, an influx of new, radical people determined to change the priorities and way of operating of the Labour Party, is a threat to their entrenched power.
For Militant, black self-organisation, including in the Labour Party is divisive and leads black people away from the fight for socialism.
Denying rights
-But the end result was not an argument about the best way to fight racism, but Militant using their voice and their votes to help deny black people in the Labour Party a basic democratic right — the right to organise.
And that is typical of the Militant tendency. Left-wing sounding arguments — an insis- candina aronments __ an insistence on workers' unity, the need for socialist policies - are used in practice with a very right wing effect.
It's the same on Ireland -"workers' unity' means, for Militant, condemning the just struggle of the Republican movement and echoing the Tory press on 'terrorism' . Or on the Middle East - a socialist answer means refusing to recognise the democratic right of the Palestinians to choose their own representatives — the PLO.
Self organisation
Militant's apparently left wing line on workers' unity has meant opposing the self-organisation of women, or of lesbian and gay people (their general arguments even contradict the work they themselves have done in Labour Party women's sections - why aren't those 'divisive' too?)
They opposed gay rights motions in the Labour Party Young Socialists for ten vears. putting themselves to the right of the Young Liberals on this.
And this explains the cosy relationship Militant has had with the Labour Party bureaucracy and still has, despite the token expulsion of five Editorial Board members.
Rallies
Even at the neignt ot the witch-hunt Militant contented itself with rallies and propaganda for their 'bold socialist programme'!
They refused to get involved with those constituency activists - organised in Labour Against the Witch-hunt - who wanted to seriously fight the expulsions. Often they found themselves to the right of ordinary Labour Party members.
SECTION General argument for a bold socialist programme is good and necessary, but it is not the same as tackling the Labour Party leadership on the sharp issues of the day. In fact Militant pander and accommodate to the prejudices many working class people have, and which the bureaucracy relies upon. Sometimes Militant can be forced to change their minds - as they have to a large extent over the issue of lesbian and gay rights. But their basic impulse is not to fight those prejudices.
In place of a fight Militant talk blandly about 'socialism' So when the Tory government Ca ahan tha Tam anvernment went to war against Argentina, and the bulk of the Labour leadership lined up behind them, Militant informed us sagely that it was a waste of time to call for the return of the fleet, and refused to participate in the campaign against the war. Instead Militant talked about a socialist federation of Britain, Argentina ana ine raikianas.
That sort of socialism has no real meaning at all. In fact, Militant's 'bold socialist programme' is a far cry from the programme fought for by Lenin and Trotsky, whom Militant claim to follow. What Militant's programme boils down to is a whole series of reforms (many of which are good ones and should be fought for) with a call for mass nationalisation tagged on as the 'way to get them".
The programme to 'nationalise the top 200 or so monopolies' is really only a radical version of the existing programme of the Labour left. Militant put forward a strategy for socialism through Parliament, using the existing capitalist state by introducing an Enabling Act. Mass action is only a back up to what the MPs do.
And even when Militant warn of the possibility of ruling class resistance, they go on to dismiss it by insisting that it is possible to get socialism peacefully.
Workers' power
The programme of Lenin and Trotsky, on the other hand, focuses on the mass action of the working class. It is a programme to establish direct workers' control by fighting for it, not by Parliamentary edict - and the direct power of workers' concils. Its aim is to overthrow the existing capitalist state and replace it with a new one, by building on the actual struggles of workers now and trying to develop them in a revolutionary direction.
And Lenin and Trotsky realised that the ruling class will always resist any threat to their power with violence. The current police action in the coalfields gives us a taste of what the ruling class might do if their whole position were threatened.
Winning workers' power carrying out a socialist revolution - means developing workers' struggles now, like the miners' strike, and uniting all sections of the oppressed and dispossessed in society — drawing them into the labour movement and radically shaking up and transforming that movement.
The appearance of Women Against Pit Closures, the support of black people for the miners, and the work done by lesbians and gay men in support of the miners, shows what can be done. Women's sections and black sections in the labour movement are part of that fight.
And a serious battle against nationalism and pro-imperialist ideas in the labour movement is vital as well. It need not be done in a ranting or sectarian way, but Militant have barely done it at all. Les Hearn looks at the interaction of "pure" science, war and peace in the life of Sir Martin Ryle, Astronomer Royal and CND supporter, who died last Sunday.
RADIO-waves are an illustration of the power of science. They were predicted by pure theory before they were dis covered.
One hundred and eleven years ago, Clerk Maxwell proposed his famous theory that the electric and magnetic forces, hitherto thought to be separate, were aspects of each other, and that the combined electro-magnetic force was transmitted by means of light rays. Furthermore, he showed there must exist a whole spectrum of electromagnetic radiation of which visible light was just one type. These include ultra-violet, heat, x-rays and radio-waves, the latter discovered some 14 years later by Heinrich Hertz.
Radio-astronomy was born 60 years after Maxwell's breakthrough when Karl Jansky detected a "cosmic hiss" of radio-waves, but the infant science was the preserve of just one amateur, Grote Reber, until 1946.
Then several war scientists, including Martin Ryle, turned their attention to the new discipline.
Ryle had made an important contribution to the war effort, but had resolved never again to put his science at the service of war and was looking for a field with no possible military value.
Ryle had been working on another application of radiowaves - radar for night-fighters trying to detect German bombers.
When the Germans cottoned on to radar, they started trying to jam English radar. On one necasion. when anti-aircraft radars had been jammed, the enemy was found to be...the Sun!
A large solar flare and group of sunspots had given out a burst of radiowaves which "dazzled" the radar receivers.
Ryle started his post-war research on this phenomenon.
Ryle soon ran into a problem - the resolving power of his "telescope", the arrays of aerials that picked up the radiowaves, was too poor.
For a radio-telescope to have equal resolving power to the human eye, it would have to be several kilometres across, and, to equal the largest light telescopes, it would need to be as wide as the Earth.
This is because the wavelengths of radiowaves are some ten million times greater than WHEN we started our current drive to increase Socialist Organiser . sales, some comrades said. "You're living in the past. You could sell dozens of papers on the streets and on the estates in the early '70s, bitthings are different now"
Experience so far seems to show that the real difference is the other way round. Yes, on a sober estimate industrial organisation and industrial militancy today are still lower than before the downturn of the mid '70s. But paper sales are easier. The minority interested in socialist politics is those of visible light.
However, Ryle and others soon realised that small details could be resolved by having just two aerials at the right distance apart. The picture would be sharp but rather dim since not many waves would be received.
Ryle developed the technique of Aperture Synthesis in which the aperture between the two outer aerials was "filled in" with a few more intermediate aerials and a computer was used to enhance the picture.
Radioastronomers were soon producing maps of radio sources of unparalleled beauty and detail. It was soon recognised that most radio sources were outside our galaxy: for example, the intense source in Cygnus is some 1000 million light years away (its radio-waves set ou: when life on Earth was emerging onto land).
The multitude of such radio sources was recognised as strong confirmation of the Big Bang theory of the origin of the universe, and radioastronomy made possible the discovery of pulsars, incredibly dense neutron stars, and quasars distant objects pouring oui a seemingly impossible amount of energy.
A radio-map of a super-nova remnant (an exploded star) in Cassiopeia made using aperture synthesis with a telescope of width 300 metres.
In 1972, Ryle was appointed Astronomer Royal. At the same time he developed a serious illness.
He came to realise that radioastronomy was, in fact, a servant of militarism through its encouragement of better radar and sonar techniques, and this led him towards the peace movement. He wrote a pamphlet "Towards a Nuclear Holocaust"
He also campaigned against nuclear power ("Is There Case for Nuclear Power?") and for alternative energy sources and more rational use of conventional energy resources.
His answer to those who mystify with science and to those who react by rejecting science was stated in 'Towards a Nuclear Holocaust":
•We must ensure that the public is educated independently of official propaganda. bigger.
With last week's headline, "Scargill is right" , one comrade sold 17 papers in an hour at Highbury Corner. Another comrade from the Islington group decided to do an extra hour's sale there the following day, and shifted ten. Total, 27.
Meanwhile, the estate sales in Islington, Southwark and Manchester are continuing, and so are the sales at colleges - ten sold at Keele University last week, and sufficient names conectea to start Socialist Organiser student society,
Scan page 10
- In