Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Walesa is not

Socialist Organiser no. 201, 18 October 1984 · scan p. 10 · about 869 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

SRI LANKA was much in the news a month or two ago for the heavy repression being meted out to the oppressed Tamil people. The state and the government of JR Jayawardene are dominated by the Sinhalese, with a growing tradition of racism and pogroms towards the Tamil population.

After a new military administration came into effect in the mainly Tamil northern area, savage assaults were carried out by state goon squads. In one week over 100 civilians were killed and over 200 injured. The armed forces were given new powers, extending those they already have under the draconternational ian Prevention of Terrorism Act (which combines the worst aspects of both the British and South African acts). The precise number of casualties now is not known, but runs into hundreds of dead.

The Tamil Tiger guerrilla organisation claims considerable success in resistance. In September their official bulletin, •Voice of the Tigers' claimed that a recent guerrilla offensive had killed nearly 70 military and police personnel.

But the repression has continued. One spokesperson for the recently re-legalised Nava Sama Samaja Party (NSSP) is Newsı quoted in the British 'Militant" (with whom the NSSP is associated) as saying that in the mainly Tamil northern area of the island, it is a 'luxury to be alive. According to 'Militant' the NSSP waged a major campaign, winning wide support, to force the government to lift the ban on their party.

The Sri Lankan state, which has developed institutionalised Sinhala racism that gives effective official backing to antiTamil pogroms, has justified its brutal actions as a campaign against 'terrorism'. In fact. the anti-Tamil racism of the state predates the guerrilla campaign. Tamil bulding gutted in 1983 pogroms which was a response to it. And the regimes of the past fifteen or so years in particular have all carried out brutal acts of repression. The crushing of an uprising of Sinhala youth in 1971 left 8.000 dead. And a general strike in July 1980 was brutally suppressed by the security forces: following it the government sacked no less than 80,000 workers.

The labour movement internationally should commit itself to opposing the brutal, 'democratic dictatorship of Jayawardene. and to support for the oppressed Tamils and the Sri Lankan workers' movement. frienc WHILST I agree with the headline, sub-headline and much of the content of John O'Mahony's article in SO 200 on Solidarnose, I think that the article was unnecessarily generous to Lech Walesa.

It says that Walesa is the equivalent of a Tom Mann, Jim Larkin, AJ Cook or Arthur Scargill. No. He is, at best, the equivalent of Jimmy Thomas and the right wing of the TUC General Council in 1926, or of Len Murray.

Throughout the existence of Solidarnosc we have carried articles in the paper which showed Walesa to be clearly to the right of the rank and file, to be an influence holding the movement back. It was Walesa's politics, in essence the same right wing politics as Murray or Thomas, that led him to call a halt to the Polish workers' moves against the Stalinist state - just as the TUC in 1926 called a halt.

Activists In Poland hundreds of union activists have been imprisoned, or are on the run. Yet Walesa was first kept under house arrest, rather than in prison, and is now virtually a public personality in Poland, able to go about saying things for which most people would be locked up.

The reason is that the StalinWalesa our belief in the need for Trotskyist parties and a Trotskyist programme in the Stalinist states as it is for any capitalist country. It is just as vital to oppose the petit-bourgeois politics of Walesa as it is to oppose the petit-bourgeois politics of the Sandinistas.

After all, if we can "understand" "my enemy's enemy is my friend" being the reason for Walesa's bad politics then we can hardly criticise Castro or the Sandinistas for lining up with the Stalinists.

I also want to take up the point about the Polish working class deciding "in reaction against Stalinism" to restore capitalism. The whole way this is posed is unrealistic.

In such a situation there would be no unanimous view of the working class. There would be a section of the working class opposed to restoration and prepared to take up arms against it.

If only one million of Solidarnosc's ten million members took up such a position I would unreservedly be on the side of that one million, just as 1 am unreservedly on the side of the minority of Notts miners on strike, and their use of whatever force is needed against the Moreover, if civil war broke out in Poland agaisnt the restoration of capitalism I would be in favour of a united front between the working class opposing the counter-revolution and the bureaucracy, on condition that the workers maintained their independence.

Fortunately, Solidarnosc is not advocating a return to capitalism. Fortunately Solidarnosc is supporting the miners.

That is what the article should have based its argument on, without bringing in any question of defending or justifying the reactionary politics of Walesa, or the possibility of Solidarnosc advocating a capitalist restoration.

Yours comradely, ARTHUR BOUGH Stoke

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 201

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →