Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

When women worked down the pit

Socialist Organiser no. 202, 25 October 1984 · scan p. 5 · Martin Barclay · about 1,377 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

to go; They've took the bread clean oot on oor mooths, aye, every mother and maid, An all for to pleasure the menfolk, as wants to steal our trade!

Well, if it's hard an mucky, who knows that better nor me?

But I liked it, an it was my living - an so it ha d to be. Surely, a wench can choose her work!"

'Boompin Nell', 1887 THIS book is an attempt to rediscover the history of women colliery workers in Britain. They were the pitbrow lasses' - surface workers doing hard, manual jobs.

Those jobs varied from pit to pit, but generally included unloading trams or tubs of coal from the cage; moving trams and railway wagons around the pit-top; unloading coal onto sorting belts; picking out muck and dirt from the coal; and trimming or levelling down the coal in the wagons.

One third of the pit-brow women worked in the Wigan area, though they could be found in Scotland, the North East, Wales and Staffordshire.

Many of them were the daughters and grand-daughters of women miners who had worked in the pits until 1842. In that year the Mines and Collieries Act excluded them from underground work along with young children.

The British middle class was shocked rigid when it was Martin Barclay reviews *By the Sweat of Their Victorian Coal Mines' ( £4.95) revealed that not only children but women worked underground. In fact women had worked in coal mines for centuries - wives and daughters helped husbands and brothers in the shallow mines and levels.

By 1841 there were probably five or six thousand women and girls working in the pits and they provided a vital part of the family income. They were generally employed in hauling trams of coal from the face and also winding them up the shaft.

What was different by the 1840s was the level of exploitation of women workers. As the demand for coal increased so they were driven to work harder. 120 lb might be carried on a single journey with up to 24 journeys in a shift.

But what really got up Victorian noses was not that they had to work so hard -it was that these women were failing to live up to the 'Dresden China' image of the typical housewife.

In the heat they worked half-dressed. Worst of all, some wore trousers! Some drew the tubs with a leather belt or rope around the waist or shoulder. A connecting chain passed between the legs and hooked on to the tub.

These partly-clad men and women working alongside eachother gave rise to lurid Angela John's new book, Brow: Women Workers at Routledge and Kegan Paul, tales of debauchery and incest - mostly from male journalists who had never been near a pit in their lives.

Those who did visit the pits compared the subterranean surroundings to hell or to *dismal dungeons'. The colliers who worked there were described as a wild and violent race.

The women themselves complained about the long hours and harsh conditions, but the middle class reformers preferred to ban them from underground work rather than shorten the working dav.

Even this didn't work -in the whole of the nineteenth century only one man was appointed to enforce the "He not only never went underground, but he always gave notice of an impending colliery visit." (p.55).

Hundreds of women continued to work underground long after the Act was passed.

The attitude of male trade unionists was predictable. The Chartist newspaper, the Northern Star urged:

"Keep them at home to look after their families; decrease the pressure on the labour market and there is then some chance of a higher rate of wages being enforced." (p.57)

Advocate newspaper put the same argument. But, as Angela John argues, this attitude did not come from the same source as middle-class attitudes. It came from the popular idea that "a working man should earn a family wage, enough to keep his wife and children."

Even so, the results were much the same - women miners were pushed out from underground. There were exceptions, especially in the Wigan area, where some miners defended the women's right to work underground.

Reformers

The sound and the fury quickly died away - until the 1880s. Once again the middle class reformers turned to the 'pit brow lasses' as a worthy cause. But this time the main argument came from the mining unions.

Both Alexander MacDonald and Thomas Burt of the National Miners Unions campaigned for men to replace women at the pit-head - the last remaining mining job where women could be found.

Even the more militant Amalgamated Association of Miners joined in. The women were doing the work at half the rate for men and the unions wanted them out.

The bare-faced cheek of this can be seen from the fact that these unions banned women from membership and refused to fight for higher wages and better conditions for them.

Once again they argued that a woman's place was in the house, making the old Disaster at the Troedyrhiw Colliery, man's dinner. They chose to ignore the double shift done by working women when they came home to the housework and cooking.

This time though, the women were not without supporters, even if they did form an unholy alliance.

Middle class campaigners for women's right to vote saw clearly that if women were excluded from pit work they would soon be excluded from other work and pushed back to the kitchen sink. It would have been even harder to get the vote in those circumstances.

Amazons

Other allies were patronising middle-class men like AJ Munby, who had interviewed and written about pit women over forty years. Munby idealised pit-women as strong, healthy Amazons, compared to pale, weedy mill girls!

A few Tory MPs also supported the pit women -they were also coalowners who were in favour of the 'right' of women to work at half a man's wage.

There were. also honourable exceptions in the labour movement. Stephen Walsh, for example, who became Vice-President of the Miners Federation, campaigned for them. He married Ann Adamson, a pit-brow girl from Ashton. Miners in Tredegar, South Wales, also supported their right to work.

Eventually the attempt to exclude the women failed in 1887. Ironically the number of pit-brow women increased in the years afterwards, especially in World War One.

Their numbers rose from 6,500 in 1914 to 11,300 in 1918. By then their cause was firmly linked to the suffragette movement. In 1911 21 pit-brow women were present ORGANISER NOTTINGHAM 1877. Scene at the pithead. on the platform in Wigan Co-op Hall underneath the slogans We claim the right to sell our labour even as our brothers' and Working women need to vote in order to protect themselves in the industrial world'.

The Lancashire and Cheshire Miners Federation had even agreed to take women as members, though they still weren't paid as much as the men working alongside them.

It was eventually the development of power-operated machinery and gravity washing methods that put paid to women in the pits. The pit closures in the 1960s dealt the final blow and the last two women surface workers were made redundant in 1972, 130 years after they had been banned from underground.

They were helped towards extinction by the NUM which did a deal with the NCB in 1953 to replace retiring women with disabled underground workers. Wherever possible the women were pushed into canteen, cleaning or switchboard work.

Angela John's book is written from an academic standpoint, but it's still quite readable. The drawback is the price - so it's best to order it from a public library. What she has done is to show that mining wasn't always a manonly industry.

We no longer have to 1o0%. to the USA or the USSR for examples of a woman's right to work in the pits - it's in our own history.

Her book leaves you with the impression that if the women in mining communities today had the right to work alongside their menfolk, MacGregor would not have had to wait until 1984 for his downfall.

----- pull-quotes -----

"Never with your leave your leave, they tell'd

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 202

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →