CND's nationalism
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-10-25Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
I object to some of Joy Hurcombe's comments in SO 199 about the US presence in Britain. While it is true that there are over 100 bases in Britain staffed by US troops, this clearly is not an "army of occupation". When were you last stopped at an American road block? When did you last see US tanks on British roads? There is no army of occupation.
Secondly, the slogan "No US bases" is inescapably nationalist. Of course I want to see US bases shut, but the point is that British bases serve roughly the same interests. The British Stations are not "better" than American ones; the working class has about as much control over "our" bases as we do over those of the United States.
We should demand the closure of all bases and not create an artificial divide.
Thirdly, it is not true to say, in the manner of so much CND propaganda, that "US rules UK". The American presence comes with the approval of our rulung vidss. We are not dominated by America, the American state is simply more powerful.
It is very important for the labour movement to fight anti-Americanism. We must be internationalists and seek links with our allies, or potential allies in the US working class. -I saw the practical results of the "No US bases" slogan on Youth CND's Bases tour, which adopted this demand. Some comrades denied that this was the thin end of the nationalist wedge. It was ironic that two days later, outside Upper Heyford, the Socialist Action comrades took up the chant "Go Home, Yankies". No doubt they felt that this was a good Sandinista slogan and therefore (!) alright for Britain! - but it is not good enough for thought-out socialists. I am reminded of the Irish nationalist slogan "Brits out of Ireland". We use "troops out" simply because we don't want to see British people out of Ireland, we want troops out.
Comradely, MARK OSBORN York