Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Orwell's vision of a bleak

Socialist Organiser no. 202, 25 October 1984 · scan p. 9 · Edward Ellis · about 710 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

A film version of George Orwell's famous novel '1984' - published in 1949 and predicting a bleak, totalitarian future society - is showing at the Odeor Haymarket. It is written and directed by Michael Radford and produced by Simon Perry.

Winston Smith and another victim of Big Brother on their way to Room 101 IT is not surprising that someone decided to make a film of George Orwell's classic novel in the year of its title. What is, perhaps surprising is that they have made a good job of it.

Orwell's Oceania is conjured up brilliantly: it is indeed a depressing place. The hysterical meetings of the party faithful; the permanent face of Big Brother everywhere; or the voices monotonously announcing mythical statistics - production increases, a growth in the proletarian literacy rate, a fall in the infant mortality rate; or announcing mythical or semi-mythical battles in the war with Eurasia or Eastasia as times change; the film captures well the omnipresence ot the state.

The complete lack of any items of luxury; the disgusting food ("It looks like meat - but there's no meat in it at all!" rejoices a loyal party worker); the dereliction of the buildings in the blitzed city constantly lit up by bomb blasts; Radford and his film crew have managed to recreate Orwell's vision of an utterly devastated, utterly inhuman, semi-barbaric totalitarian hell-on-earth.

Working class

Without undue gore the film also captures the genuine horror of Orwell's vision and the hopelessness of Winston. Smith's predicament. The physical and psychological torture of Smith after his capture by the Thought Police is handled with great skill. What could so easily have degenerated into cheap horror, is instead a tragedy: Smith's struggle against the breaking of his will is futile, pathetic.

-John Hurt's performance as Winston Smith at this point is remarkable. He entirely broken physically and as he emerges from the notorious room 101 we can believe that he is entirely broken spiritually. And Richard Burton gives a convincing portrayal of Smith's torturer.

What is particularly impressive about this production is that it has avoided glib high-tech impressions of the future. True to Orwell's intentions, the imagery - the technology, the appearance of people - is closer to the 1940s than it is to an imagined future.

Inhuman

And, especially notable -giren that it could have been so easy to turn this into a Cold War film - the style, the uniforms, the youth movement - are more reminiscent of Nazi Germany than anything else.

its major shortcoming is Orwell's fault - a profound pessimism. Watching from his window a proletarian woman singing, Winston comments "The future is hers" "If there is any hope," he writes in his diary, "it lies with the proles." But O'Brien, his tormentor, tells him that the proles will never rise up.

There is nothing in Orwell's book, or in this film which - commendably -sticks so religiously to Orwell's text, to contradict this.

But events in the Stalinist states since poor Orwell's time - like the magnificent uprising of the Polish workers who created Solidarnosc in 1980 - prove that no totalitarian system is all powerful.

We have good reason to believe that the Stalinist rulers in the Kremlin will find that out in the not too distant future. ENGELS described the US political system as dominated by "two great gangs of political speculators, who alternately take possession of the state power and exploit it by the most corrupt means... The most successful of the gangsters - party bosses skilled in delivering the votes of the living and the dead in their city, ward or precinct -have become legendary figures.

-Since World War 2, the US has seen the rise of a new kind of operator, the "election consultant". , who specialises in putting together a package of Madison Avenue advertising techniques and image manipulation, press and media management, and "dirty tricks"

Now, these political gunsfor-hire have added a new weapon to their armouries: computer based political information systems which monitor and record the fears, anxieties and prejudices of finelybalanced samples of the electorate.

We are all familiar with newspaper polls — 24% would vote SDP, 64% oppose the miners' strike, and so on. But for the

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 202

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →