Computerising the bosses fight against socialism
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-10-25Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
to religious issues, their beliefs about their own personal prospects and their assessments of the strengths and weaknesses of the candidates.
Perry's book is an account of the world of the political programmers, and their involvement in Democratic and Republican campaigns since 1976.
It describes in detail the interactions between the candidates and the consultants. Thus we learn that Wirthlin, Reagan's favourite operator, is a Mormon, drinks only fruit juice and gets on well with Nancy; and that Patrick Caddell, the Democrats' programmer, tends to put on weight and tell dirty jokes.
If you want the "dramatic inside story" as the bookcover proclaims, this is the book for you.
Sometimes the details are fascinating; often they are plain boring. Even more unfortunate - despite this grinding attention to detail, we actually learn little about how the computerbased systems actually work. (A Gerry Ben-Noah reviews "The Programming of thi President: The Hidden Power of the Computer in World Politics Today' lished by Aurum at £7.95.
single page extract from it, which appeared in the Sunday Times on April 29, contained all the useful information in the book). This is a shame, because it makes it easy to dismiss Perry's claims for the effectiveness of tnese systems as so much hype — as socialists are often keen to dismiss all opinion surveys as "fixed" by the capitalist media.
Moreover, the book concentrates on US politics, where questions of technique, image and personalities tend to obscure what we would consider the real politics. We learn a lot about how the Reagan campaign was run, but not much about why, or who paid for it.
This is not Perry's fault -the computer based systems have hardly been used in Britain as yet — but it does make for an overwhelming emphasis on the nuts and bolts of campaigns, with little about what they are fought for.
There is only one chapter on Britain, which describes how the Tories made use of the new technology both in their campaign against CND (a special computerised direct mail unit known as DS19 was set up in the Ministry of Defence) and in their election campaign of 1983.
For me, this was the most interesting part of the book. It showed how the techniques developed in America - the use of image-marketing skills and opinion research, and the coordinated recomposition of the political "audience" -could really work to marginalise socialist politics.
Batons
And Perry's book is invaluable in one respect: it illustrates that, in a developed capitalist democracy, the apparatus of class domination does not consist of police batons alone. A revolutionary socialism which fails to recognise this, and which refuses to recognise that the political strategy of the bourgeoisie is also the subject of a continuous transformation, is doomed to hecome as irrelevant tomorrow as the Jacobins are A response is needed; but a response which merely seeks to improve the marketing and organisation of "our side" will not halt this process - it will accelerate it. A slickly-packaged, image-conscious Labour Party which seeks only to improve its "market share" and its brand profile will lead to the elimination, not the victory. socialism.