Scrapping the Bomb
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-10-25Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
How can we get rid of the bomb?
We need a government that will scrap it.
There are real problems with that though. The Labour Party — the existing real alternative to the Tories - has a commitment to unilateral nuclear disarmament - but it is a commitment the Labour leaders are always fudging.
Only a political infant would rely on them to carry out that commitment.
And this year's Labour Party conference maintained its commitment to NATO - as if scrapping the bomb was possible whilst remaining in NATO!
In reality, the bosses and the military chiefs in Britain and the US would fight very hard to stop Britain from disarming.
Only a government prepared to fight them would be capable of carrying through its policy. And that would have to be a government based upon working class rank-and-file organisations and relying on the strength of working class action. Shouldn't we just focus on direct action, then?
We obviously do need to start now with demonstrations, peace camps, action like that of the Greenham women. And we need political strikes against the bomb - and more action like that of the Rolls Royce workers who blacked parts for Trident.
But only enormous mass action of general strike proportions could hope to actually defeat the centralised state machine. But 'general strike to scrap the bomb' is not a very "plausible' slogan. And if the Bonner fairly senior officers" were talking about a military takeover in 1974.
We would need defence if a government scrapped the bomb: defence against the army; against our own bosses and their state forces.
"Realistically' we would have to organise some sort of labour movement/community militias — against the present state, the basis for our own kind of workers state.
When the bosses - or the Labour leaders - talk about 'defence, they mean the defence of their interests, not the interests of ordinary workers. And there is, as we have seen, nothing defensive or "peaceful' in what they do to protect their interests.
But don't we need to have some defence against, for example, the USSR?
There is much more to be afraid of from the British ruling class and army and their allies in NATO than there is from the USSR. In NATO we have real oppression now, not a hypothetical oppressor in the future.
And the Soviet bureaucrats are far too busy oppressing their own working class and helping their stooges in countries like Poland, to risk taking on the working class of Western Europe as well.
But in the event of any invasion of Britain that threatened the lives or liberties of workers - be it from the USSR or the US — we would need to rely on our own strength to defend ourselves. Military forces tied to the ruling class would be no defence at all — we'd probably be fighting them too.
We would need a people's militia, democratically controlled by the labour movement and local communities and based on universal military training.
Isn't that conscription?
In the sense that a picket rota, or a closed shop is conscription — yes. But it's different from conscription to professional armies of strike-breakers and uniformed thugs. And it's different from proposals like Peter Tatchell's which advocate a 'citizens' army'. He proposes just reforming the existing state machine, to make it more democratic. What we need is to take on and defeat the existing state machine and to replace it with a new one.