NUM and Libya M and
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-11-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
'OR THE Tories and their police, it's a bare-knuckle fight agThe bosses and the government are fighting like people who know that this is the battle of their political lives. And it is. The outcome of the miners' strike will shape industrial - and, probably, political - life in Britain for a long time to come.
So, for the Tory propaganda machine, anything goes.
Since NUM official Roger Windsor visited Libya, the press has piled in on the miners' leaders, kicking, spitting, biting, butting and eye-gouging like the gang of ruling class hired The politicians have joined the scrum, and Neil Kinnock has vied with the Tories to denounce Arthur Scargill.
Norman Willis, the TUC's general secretary, who should be organisine support for the miners took the chance to have a go and crack the TUC's whip over the NUM. He announced:
"I have asked for, and been given, Mr Scargill's categorical assurance than no financial support has been sought for, received by, or will be accepted by the NUM from the Libyan regime, which he, like myself, regards as an odious tyranny"
The purpose of the Tory hate-mongering against the NUM is to turn other workers against the miners, and - they hope -turn rank and file miners against Arthur Scargill.
The miners could win a complete victory in a very short time if enough workers took action in solidarity. The propaTony Benn pointed out in the House of Commons that the Coal Board itself has contracts with Libya, making money by training Libyan technicians. Other British businesses continue to have lucrative links with Libya. The Tories' close allies in the US capitalist class have big oil interests in Libya, and US firms together with South Koreans have just started a huge The hypocrisy is worse than that. Of course it is true that there is nothing in Libya deserving of the name 'trade union'. The so-called Libyan trade unions are rubber stamps for the government. It is a pity that Arthur Scargill allowed himself to talk as if trade unions exist in Libya independent of the government, with which the NUM could have links.
But who is Thatcher to condemn the NUM for this when she depends so heavily on scab coal from Poland to break the miners' strike? Thatcher weeps public tears for the banned and outlawed Polish trade union movement, Solidarnosc, but she is very happy to use the coal produced by Polish miners under martial law conditions described by some of them as slave When Thatcher uses the lack of free trade unionism in Libya as a weapon in her battle to beat down the miners and destroy effective trade unionism in Britain, the labour moves Socialists should also be clear on the political issues involved. Two things need to be separated out when we discuss the rights and wrongs of a British trade union having links with Libya. Two types of links' need to be distinguished.
Hard-pressed trade union leaders looking for material help wherever they can get it: that is one thing. Pretending that Gadaffi is politically on the workers' side, or his regime is In principle it would be perfectly legitimate for the NUM to get help - without strings, without illusions, and without pretending that there exists a real Libyan labour movement -rom Libya. Eight months into the strike, with the union's funds seized by the courts, it can be readily understood that Arthur Scargill might be in a mood to 'try anything'.
The Tories have no right to protest: but when we discuss the issue within the labour movement, other things have to be balanced against the material aid that might come to the miners from Libya, and in the first place the effect of NUM links with Libya on rank and file miners and on other workers whose sympathy and solidarity is vital to the miners.
The contact. with Libya was politically mistaken and inept. It played into the hands of the Tories. It has allowed scabherding police in Notts to needle miners on the picket line about a regime for which they have no sympathy.
There are those on the fringes of the labour movement who glorify Libya and its 'great man', , Gadaffi - notoriously the 'Workers Revolutionary Party', which is widely believed to be subsidised in some way by Libya, but also Labour Herald; and Ron Brown MP, leader of a recent delegation of Labour MPs to Libya. In fact Libya is what Kinnock, Willis and others say.
The independent trade unions that existed under the monarchy overthrown in 1969 have been rooted out. Dissidents are condemned without trial and hanged in the streets. Reactionary Islamic fundamentalism sets the norms for public life. Gadaffi's international activities range from having his opponents assassinated in London, through helping the Ethiopian regime to suppress liberation fighters in Eritrea, to petty Of course there are nastier things in the international jungle than Gadaffi — some of them supported by the US, like the regime in El Salvador. But Gadaffi's regime is the opposite of socialism. To be an advocate of Gadaffi's "socialism' or 'anti-imperialism' is to part company with working class poliArthur Scargill plainly does not believe that Libya is a socialist state. It is regrettable, however, that he has talked as if there are real trade unions in Libya. Labour MPs have tabled a motion in the Commons asserting the NUM's right "to receive aid from trade unionists anywhere in the world". Yes, indeed. But the official trade unions in Libya fire government fronts - like the official unions in Stalinist states like the USSR and Eastern Europe, with which the TUC shamefully After all the hullabaloo, the Tories have their own prob. lems. The sequestration of the NUM's funds has not cowed the miners or their leaders. The Coal Board is openly split. The revival of militancy among car workers shows that the example The crescendo of denunciation against Arthur Scargill is designed to cover that over. But it won't work. The miners FOR THE Tories and their police, ainst the miners. thugs that they are. ganda war is aimed to stop that.
The Tories are disgustine hvpocrites.
$11 billion man-made river project there. labour.
ment must rally to the NUM. socialist, is another.
In principle