Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Stop the millions starving!

Socialist Organiser no. 203, 1 November 1984 · scan pp. 6–7 · about 1,966 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

72 76 "78 '80 82 84 Asia, 110 '68 72 '76 278 agriculture to advance was put down to the Inherent Inferiority of the African. It would be mach truer to say that it was due to the white Intruders, although the basie oxplanation is to be found not in the personal ill-will of the and repression In the organised viclousness of the capitalist/ Failure to improve aer cultural tools and methods on behalf of African peasants was not a matter of a bad decision by colonial policy makers. It vas an inescapable feature of colonialism as a whole, based on the understanding that the international division of lahour aimed at skills in the metropoles and lor level manpower in the dependencies. It force (including taxation) in Afric "Hov Europe Underdeveloped Africa be saved. the most needy. Some of it is military aid. The rest is mostly tied to exports from the donor countries.

Big construction projects, which draw in a lot of exports from the industrial countries but may or may not be appropriate for the recipient country's needs, are just the sort of thing the donor countries like. Small-scale, modest projects of essential assistance for peasant villages are not.

The USSR, with which Ethiopia has been closely allied in recent years, is not much better than the capitalist powers in this respect. It does not have the huge food surpluses that the US and the EEC have, but it has enough to help Ethiopia. Instead it has sent massive military aid to preserve its political alliance.

The problem, however, is not just the governments.

Labour front-benchers

now criticising the Tories for BRITTA Tarathe Walter Rodney: giving too little aid, too late. True: but why weren't those Labour leaders campaigning on the issue before? They didn't have to wait for a television programme to know what was happening in Africa.

Blaming the established leadership isn't the end of the story, either. The Left has not been campaigning to make the leaders speak out. Hardly a word was said about the issue at the Labour Party conference in September.

Most of the left press has blandly ignored the developing catastrophe in Africa. Socialist Organiser has had more coverage than other papers, but even ours looks feeble in hindsight.

Perhaps there are inbuilt limits in human psychology which compel us to shut out certain horrors from our mind for more than brief spells. For sure, capitalist society - a society that. throws us all into the market economy as individuals and warns us that the devil takes the hindmost - reinforces these limits.

Even socialists who consciously reject capitalist rat-race economics find it difficult to keep the terrible reality in focus. Something like eight hundred million people live on the edge of malnutrition or starvation: but we push that fact to the corners of our minds and concentrate on matters that seem more manageable and close to hand.

In a television interview about Ethiopia, Dennis Healey pompously declared that starving children were "far too important for party politics"

True, Labour leaders like Dennis Healey have reduced party politics to an affair of Parliamentary debating tricks — and the rest of us have allowed them to do that. That, in a sentence, is the reason why children still starve.

For a working class party that deserves the name, starvation in the Third World should be absolutely central to "party Socialism is not about Neil Kinnock's television commercials or Roy Hattersiey's drought-affected per capita Sub-Saharan Africa schemes for slightly rejigging the capitalist management of the British economy. It is about replacing a world of starvation and hopelessness and luxury and waste and cynical individualism with a world of equality and comradeship.

The capitalist class lives by d repre ETHIOPIA is one of the most underdeveloped countries in the Almost alone of the countries of Africa, it resisted all attempts to make it a colony. It remained, however, a weak and dependent unit in the capitalist world economy, further held back by the medieval social structure headed by the Emperor, Haile Selassie.

Haile Selassie was overthrown after a previous famine, in 1972-4. It was a genuine people's revolution, which opened with a general strike by Ethiopia's tiny working class.

But power came into the hands of the army - the only sizeable body of people in the country who were technically skilled and more or less attuned (kg)

ODUCTION America •100 the rule of grabbing profits as it can. The working class, insofar as it stirs itself as a class, lives by the rule of solidarity. Socialism means establishing that rule of solidarity across the world.

It is futile tinkering to fight for anything less.

revolution to the needs of development.

Like other state-capitalist regimes in the Third World -Syria, or Egypt under Nasser, for example - the Ethiopian military has allied with the USSR and declared itself It has introduced land reforms and greatly expanded services like education.

But autonomous socialist groups which developed during the revolution have been crushed. And the regime has thrown huge military resources into trying to suppress the fight for independence in Eritrea - a fight which started decades ago but was given a new boost by the overthrow of Haile Selassie's empire. Ethiopia is not untypical.

One person is dying from starvation there every 20 minutes, and some seven be at risk.

Similar horrors exist in almost every country of black Africa, and also in north-east Brazil and Bangladesh.

mozamoique - were railways and roads have been cut off by the South African backed MR guerrilla movement - parts of Angola, and the countries Biggest export as 0 % 20 Uganda /COFFEE Zambia COPP Somalia LIVE ANIMALS Burundi COFFEE Niger URANIUM Rwanda COF Botswana PIAMOROS Mauritius laugan Ethiopia COFFE Banglade: JUT. on 1 the cact lizal vati mor fetc Nati milli 0-41 sevi ano less

Scan page 7

system prosperous cities _ 50,000 compiled by a white profeschildren die of hunger each sor of medicine. he southern edge of Sahara Desert, are icularly hard hit. Brazil, people eat s, or hunt rats and country with gleaming, year, according to figures DROUGHTS in 1983 and pret vious years are the immediate cause of the mass starvation.

But the reason why droughts have this effect is the social system of exploitation and inequality.

There is no world shortage of food. Very often there is not even an overall shortage of food in countries suffering famine.

But capitalism recognises no human need unless it is expressed in hard cash. If you are penniless, then, as far as the capitalist market economy is concerned, you do not exist. If you have plenty of the printed tokens called "money" , then you can have whole industries pampering your tastes and urging you on to consume more and more.

Droughts and famines killed many people before capitalism ever existed. But the technical progress generated by capitalism has made it possible for humanity to conquer droughts and famines.

We have fertilisers, machinery, and irrigation techniques to increase food production massively. We have transport and communications to identify areas of need quickly and get supplies there promptly. We have medicines to conquer previously deadly diseases.

In many parts of the world, though, capitalism has made people less able to deal with problems like drought. Within a system where relations between people are reduced to cash exchanges, they are the people without cash.

When the European powers seized parts of Africa as their colonies and introduced the elements of capitalism there, they did so mainly by developing cash crops.

The European capitalists, usually, did not employ the African peasants as wageworkers. The peasants remained, on the face of it, independent small farmers, working on the land individually or collectively.

Colonial

But the colonial administration demanded taxes from the peasants in cash. To get cash, the peasants had to produce the crops that the colonial trading companies wanted to buy. In many colonies, this economic compulsion was backed up by physical compulsion - the use of forced labour.

Thus the best land was taken away from subsistence farming and put to producing cash crops for the European market. The trading companies made fat profits by paying low prices to the peasants and keeping them in constant poverty. Agricultural methods remained primitive.

Different African countries crop economy at the expense of subsistence farming has continued. And most African countries have been unabled to shake off their dependence on a narrow range of exports.

The problems are linked. Black African countries have seen the prices they get for their exports declining relative to import prices in the long term, and varying wildly in the short term. They had an especially bad period during the severe recession in the richer capitalist countries in the early '80s.

So they have balance-ofpayments problems. They run up debts with the international banks, and then the debt service payments make the balance-of-payments problem worse.

Bigger, more developed, Third World countries like Brazil or even India have become major manufacturing exporters. But the African nations, as smaller countries with limited resources, are not easily able to develop new industries on a scale to compete in world markets.

Therefore the only short-term option is to try to increase exports of the traditional cash crops. The international debt crisis is perhaps even more devastating for Africa than it is for Brazil or Mexico.

Though many of the problems in Africa exist also in the rest of the Third World, neither in Asia nor in Latin America are they so stark, so concentrated and so severe.

Uganda gets almost 100% of its export earnings from coffee, and Ethiopia 60%. Senegal depends on peanuts, Chad depends on cotton.

As an Oxfam report puts it, "while people starved, production of crops for export went from strength to strength" after independence.

As a result of the priorities both of local governments and international capitalism, the bulk of the funds available for Unequal distribution of wealth, power and income within the poor countries make things worse.

Overstaffed and inefficient bureaucracies eat up a big proportion of the national income and waste more on bungled projects. The inefficiencies, and poor communications and transport, also allow private traders to make big profits.

"In Upper Volta this year" the UN Children's Fund reports, "the harvest has failed completely in the north, while in the south barns are overflowing. The surplus, however, is not feeding the hungry northerners because they cannot afford to buy it from the private traders."

Imported food - which is already 20% of the cereals eaten in black Africa, despite the region being mainly agricultural - goes mainly to the cities. Miserable though. the condition of the millions in shanty-towns outside the big cities of Africa is, they are at least a concentrated force, able to strike, riot or demonstrate to win concessions from the government.

The peasants, dispersed across the countryside, do not have the same power.

The way out of this horror depends on the growth of an independent workers' movement in the cities of Africa. That movement could make links both with the poor peasants and with the labour movement in the richer capitalist countries.

Compensation

Massive aid without strings tr Africa from the West - or, tr give it a better name, compensa tion for the damage done by imperialism should be demanded by the internationa labour movement.

In most of Africa there are few large landowners. There -in contrast to Latin America, for example — the problem is not sc much to redistribute the land but to give the peasants, organ-

----- pull-quotes -----

Nature has brought drought to Africa. Capital ism brought the famine. But even now, lives could

ODU capita

million of the country's 33 million people are said

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 203

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →