Whose Poland?
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-11-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
CONNUENCYJOHN O'Mahony (SO, October 11) needn't worry. There is no lack of "active support for Solidarnosc". Nor, despite the whitewash job of almost all Trotskyist groups, is there any mystery as to the source of most of it.
No less a figure than Radio Free Europe director James Buckley has obligingly revealed that "whenever Solidarnosc issues a declaration we broadcast it" It is true that since I only learned of this from the April 12 issue of Verde Olivio (journal of the Cuban armed forces) the disclosure may not have reached the ears of Socialist Organiser's editors, for whom learning a foreign language is an unbearable imposition, and reading any Cuban publication, even in the English language, is nothing less than a torture session.
The gist of the article seems to be that the Polish authorities are enemies of the NUM and Solidarnosc is its ally, therefore Scargill owes Lech Walesa and Solidarnosc basic working class solidarity".
The first two claims are more than dubious. If large amounts of Polish coal were being sent here directly (it is, or should be clear, that the Polish authorities have no responsibility for the considerable amount sent here from third countries); if, contrary to the statement of its central leader, Solidarnosc actually supports the miners; and if Solidarnosc has anything like the "10 million" members it claims; the shipments would long ago have ceased.
Progressive
That any figures in Solidarnose have issued statements of support for the NUM is due to their (utterly unfounded) expectations of assistance from it for their own struggle. In the far more numerous cases where Solidarnosc has entertained no illusions as to the possibility of gaining assistance from progressive forces, its attitude to these forces has been clearly and unambiguously hostile.
This was made clear by the demand of the September 1981 Solidarnosc Congress for a cutoff of all Polish aid to Cuba, the support voiced in the same congress for US intervention in El Salvador and the declarations by Pretakiewicz, the top Solidarnosc representative in the Western hemisphere, denouncing the US air traffic controllers' strike (**I would not like to be involved in this kind of STIRLING DISTRICT TRADES 1769 COUNCIL FELINE LA B PROTT RICK MATTHEWS (IFL)