Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Assessing Contadora

Socialist Organiser no. 203, 1 November 1984 · scan pp. 9–10 · Edward Ellis · about 497 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Sandinista leader Daniel Ortega ITHINK on balance 1 agree with Martin Thomas's assessment of the decision of Nicaragua to sign the Contadora Pact, rather than with Paul Muddle's (SO 202).

Paul argues that we are not opposed in principle to compromises with bourgeois governments; and that the success of the Salvadorean revolution depends not upon arms supplies from Nicaragua, but upon international working class solidarity.

The Sandinistas signing the Contadora pact, says Paul, will "call Reagan's bluff" and "expose his hypocrisy" — since Contadora calls for all foreigni military personnel to be withdrawn, and an end to support for organisations seeking to aestabilise' Central American governments. Obviously, Reagan will not be able comply. -This may well be true. But it seems to me that our judgement on the Sandinistas' decision depends upon its real effects on the struggle in El Salvador. If it has no effect, there can be no major objection; but if it has a demoblising effect, I think it must be judged a wrong decision.

It seems likely that there is a connexion between the Sandinistas' action and the negotiations now taking place in El Salvador between the government and the FMLN. Again, negotiations are not ruled out in principle, but I think - on the basis of previous articles he has written in SO - Paul will agree that a 'negotiated settlement with the present regime is the policy of the bourgeois right wing in the FMLN, rather than the Left.

Wider international solidarity is certainly needed. But it is also true that allies within Central America itself are vital to each other's success. The FMLN may not, as Paul says, need Nicaraguan guns, but they do look to Nicaragua for political assistance and as a model for their own future.

They do need some base outside El Salvador: and a declaration by Nicaragua that it wll dissociate from any moves to 'destabilise' ElSalvador's rulers cannot help.

Paul writes: "If the FSLN are not Marxists...this isn't because they don't export arms...but because they have not attempted to build an international party." I think this poses the issues wrongly. The FSLN are not Marxists because they do not have a working class pro: gramme. And tactical compromises by people fighting for a different programme cannot simply be assessed in the same way as tactical compromises by people fighting for our programme. They are compromising for different ends.

An agreement between the Sandinistas and various bourgeois regimes seems to me potentially more than just a compromise. The wheelings and dealings of Reagan are one thing: but what about the aims of the Mexican, Venezuelan, Colombian or Panamanian bourgeoisies who worked the plan out?

The relatively powerful Mexican ruling class surely aims for a consolidated bourgeois alliance in the region — under their own domination. Nicaragua's support for Contadora strengthens their aims; and their aims conflict with ours.

EDWARD ELLIS WORKERS!

SochAlist Back the miners.

Scan page 10

November SEVENTY years ago this autumn, the First World

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 203

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →