The SWP's U-turn
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-11-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Recently the Socialist Workers' Party - the largest, after Militant' ', of the far-left groupings in Britain - has made a 'turn' From a stance which they themselves now describe as 'splendid isolation', they have moved to enter miners' support committees and trade union Broad Lefts. and thev have called No. 4, out now, includes articles on Afghanistan, on the Northern Ireland Protestants, and on the theory of imperialism in the light GENERAL STRIKE! for united action with the comments.
A COUPLE of weeks ago Socialist Worker carried an interesting article on the Birmingham Trades Council Miners Support Committee.
It was informative and generally accurate but most interesting was its tone. It was quietly enthusiastic about the Committee, and indeed held it up as "one example of a support committee which has had some success in raising support for the miners and taking their case to local workplaces in Birmingham."
Trades Council secretary Mick Rice, and Geraldine Egan, Chair of the Trades Council Women's Group (who organise most of the local food collecting), are quoted approvingly.
Yet for the first five of six months of the strike, the SWP played virtually no role in the committee. A couple of individual SWP members turned up to the meetings, but the organısation itself took no part in the work of the committee and leading members privately dismissed its work as "left-wing Oxfam" (a reference to the food collections) and suggested that the leaders of the Trades Council were "minor bureaucrats" using the strike to further their careers.
Suddenly, all that has changed. SWP members now turn up in force at the Committee's meetings, and generally play a constructive role, taking on quite a lot of the day to day leg-work.
And it is the same with SWP members elsewhere. The paper now carries frequent articles praising the work of the oncedespised "baked beans brigade" (food collectors), and emphasised the need for patient presentation of the miners' case to other groups of workers, using the TUC resolution where necessary.
In the Birmingham area, SWP members have been to the fore in establishing support committees linked to the Trades Council in NALGO, the NUT and amongst students.
All this is to the good. The more comrades who work constructively in united front support committees, (while, of Labour 'Left. Jim Denham course, continuing to argue for their own politics) the better.
But what about some honest accounting for this dramatic change of position? And what implications does it have for the SWP's hitherto ultra-pessimistic perspectives for the class struggle.
Tony Cliff may privately say that some of the members took his pronouncements "too literally" , but sometimes it does no harm to simply admit, "we were wrong"
Perhaps there was nothing very revolutionary and Bolshevik about the SWP's previous splendid isolation and lordly contempt for the rest of the Left. For instance, they always shied away from raising the general strike, even propagandistically, as "too advanced"
Several SWP members in Birmingham were genuinely surprised to discover that, once they got stuck into the support committee, they found themselves arguing for exactly. the same perspectives as the "bureaucrats" of the Trades Council - patient, systematic presentation of the miners' case to other workers, using food and money collections to prepare for blacking and solidarity action, setting up support committees in particular unions and workplaces, etc., etc.
Now the SWP has "come in from the cold" what effect will it have on their overall politics? A cynic might point to the Socialist Worker sales report carried in the same issue as the article on Birmingham: "Birmingham SWP are actively involved in the miners support group. When they first started they used to sell eight papers a week.
"Now that they have been working alongside other activists for a considerable time the sale has increased to 15." Good grief! Can the "upturn" be on the way?
Meanwhile, however, we should welcome the comrades in from the cold, and try to convince them on some other issues — like why they should be in the Labour Party, pursuing a united front approach on broader political issues, too.
Advert of the South Atlantic war.
75p plus postage from PO Box 135, London N1.