Socialist organisation and socialist theory
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-11-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
How should socialists organise? What relation is there between the theoretical arguments on the Left, and day-to-day trade union battles? Stan Crooke reviews movement Party. The British Communist War began - and the international socialist movement, as it was then, fell apart.
Almost all the Social Democratic and Labour Parties built up over decades of working class efforts supported their own capitalist governments in the war.
Ever since then, socialists have been fighting to rebuild the movement.
The first great attempt was the creation of the Communist Parties after 1917. Within a very few years the CPs had been corrupted, and by the 1930s they had been completely wrecked as instruments for socialism, by the rise of the Stalinist bureaucracy in the USSR.
Value
Nevertheless the work and the discussions of the first few years of the Communist movement are still of great value. Especially important was the Second Congress of the Communist International, in 1920, where the basic issue of how socialists should organise was argued out.
Trotsky declared:
*I proceed from the assumption that there is a rather sharp contradiction between the march of historical events and the opinion expressed here with such Marxist magnanimity (by Paul Levi of the German CP) to the effect that the broad masses of workers are already excellently aware of the necessity of the party.
*It is self-evident that if we were dealing here with Messrs Scheidemann, Kautsky [the German reformist leaders] or their English co-thinkers, it would, of course, be unnecessary to convince these gentlemen that a party is indispensable to the working class. They have created a party for the working class and handed it over into the service of bourgeois and capitalist society...
*Just because 1 know that the party is indispensable, and am very well aware of the value of the party, and just because I see Scheidemann on the one side and, on the other American or Spanish or French syndicalists who not only wish to fight against the bourgeoisie but who unlike Scheidemann, really want to tear its head off - for this reason I say that 1 prefer to discuss with these Spanish, American and French comrades in order to prove to them that the party is indispensable for the fulfilment of the historical mission which is placed upon them - the destruction of the bourgeoisie.
Party "I will try to prove this to them in a comradely way, on the basis of my own experience, and not by counterposing to them Scheidemann's long years of experience and saying that for the majority this question has already been settled."
The class struggles in Russia At the 1 ETEN OT D RE C lessons from history.
and Hungary proved, in different ways, the need for a revolutionary party. The October Revolution and the overthrow of capitalism in Russia would have been impossible but for the existence of the Bolshevik Party.
"If we had not had a centralised, military, iron-disciplined party, which we organised for twenty years, we would have been beaten twenty times over," said Zinoviev.
In Hungary, on the other hand, the numerical and politicRosa Luxemburg al weaknesses of the party had led it to rely on the trade unions, with fatal consequences. The unions had been entrusted with tasks such as the reorganisation of production, the formation of a Red Army, the distribution of food, etc.
"But," the Hungarian Communist leader Rakosi recounted, "it emerged that these questions could not be solved by them. They did indeed take on these tasks, but in no area did they achieve a satisfactory solution to them. Not only because they were mostly reactionary, but also because they were not created to solve political questions. After a few months we were faced with the absolute necessity of forming, a strong new Communist party.
The Stalinists in later years presented the question of a Leninist party almost entirely as an organisational matter of the need for a "centralised, military, iron-disciplined" movement.
In fact the Bolshevik party never had the organisational rigidity credited to it in Stalinist myth. It was a party of lively internal controversy and often ramshackle organisation.
What distinguished it was its relentless struggle for theoretical and political clarity - its determined rejection of muddy consensus thinking, and its will to follow the principles later summed up by Trotsky: "To face reality squarely; not to seek the line of least resistance; to call things by their right names; to speak the truth to the masses, no matter how bitter it may be...
Because the bourgeoisie controls all the means of propaganda, culture and information in capitalist society (schools, mass media, the church, etc.), the thinking and actions of the working class come to be dominated by bourgeois ideology. Only a party which has purged itself of all bourgeois influences and is a concrete embodiment of revolutionary socialist struggle can break the working class from bourgeois ideology and organise it to overthrow capitalism.
For the Third International the Communist Party was not just a collection of industrial militants. The party was a part of the working class, but also differed from the whole working class in that it had "an overall view of the whole historical road of the working class in its totality". It was "the organisational and political lever with whose help the advanced part of the working class can steer the whole mass of the proletariat and the semi-proletariat onto the correct road.
Creativity and power The working class has tremendous resources of power; creativity and courage. The basic forms and methods of the struggle for socialism - trade unions, mass strikes, factory occupations, workers' councils - have been developed not by any elite but by the masses of workers in struggle.
And the liberation of the working class must be the task of the workers themselves. The socialist revolution means the direct democratic rule of the working class through workers' councils (a sort of workers' parliament, with accountability and the right of recall over delegates) — not the rule of a party.
But spontaneous, uncoordinated struggle will not be enough to defeat the capitalist class — a cunning, centralised and wellequipped opponent. Time and again in working class history, promising broad movements have been sidetracked and dissipated for lack of a coherent and politically clear hard core.
Committed socialists need to continue in a coherent, effective movement which can integrate the struggle on all fronts, from the most complex theoretical debates to the most basic trade union battles.
In its approach to semirevolutionaries and confused but militant leftists, the Third International combined absolute firmness of principles with flexibility of tactics. In his pamphlet, Left Wing Communism' written just before the Second Congress, Lenin argued: "Attacks of the German Lefts on the Central Committee of the Communist Party of Germany for entertaining the idea of a bloc with the 'Independents' (USPD)... appear to us to be Leon Trotsky utterly frivolous and a clear proof that the 'Lefts' are in the wrong.. "The German Independent Social-Democratic Party (USD) is obviously not a homogeneous body: alongside the old opportunist leaders.. there has arisen in this party a Left, proletarian wing which is growing with remarkable rapidity...To fear a compromise with this wing of the party is positively ridiculous.
On the contrary, it is obligatory for the Communists to seek and to find a suitable form of compromise with them, such a Lenin ing of many workers who have although made up of workers, it joined the trade unions because is led by reactionaries and the their workmates are trade worst kind of reactionaries at unionists, and to share the that." friendly benefits... Even so, the Communists *We must not dissipate our should join it in order to reach energy in adding to the strength the workers in the Labour Party of the Labour Party...We must and the millions in the trade concentrate on making a com- unions affiliated to the Labour munist movement that will vanquish it." Party could be a real workers claimed that affiliation "would At the Congress itself Tanner party only if it really linked up with the masses and fough do great damage to the British against the reactionary, corrupt Party, for the whole British leaders of the British labou the tactics of the Labour Party." working class is sick and tired of movement. And it was possible to attac these leaders from inside the Affiliation Labour Party: "a party affiliater to the Labour Party is able, no But Lenin argued, success- only to severely criticise, bu fully, in favour of affiliation. only and specifically to mentior Pankhurst's argument was the old leaders by name and cal based on a superstitious fear of them social traitors...In suc what might happen to revolu- circumstances it would be tionaries in the Labour Party and mistake not to join the party." therefore wanted Communists to The British Communist Part keep a healthy distance from it. was not to be a party of propa Lenin, - on the other hand, gandists, but a combat organisa wanted communists to fight for tion fighting to win support fo the leadership of the British their ideas and drive the agent working class inside the Labour of the bourgeoisie out of th Party. labour movement. "When com Lenin agreed that The munists enjoy such freedom, i Labour Party is a thoroughly is their duty to join the Labou reactionary party, because, Party:"
----- pull-quotes -----
Gs-uin arm Snieralt WEE BERENATE LONG LIVE THE Wed INTERNA