Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Socialist energy policy Too much coal? -while millions are cold and hungry

Socialist Organiser no. 204, 8 November 1984 · scan p. 6 · about 1,040 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

sources oil, gas. coal, ton for lack of very small nuclear, solar, wave, wind, supplies of energy. wood. It could provide energy Arthur Scargill has suggested free or at low cost right across that if there is a surplus of coal the world - particularly to the in Britain, it should be supplied Third World peasants at present free to old age pensioners. It driven into poverty or starva- is no less reasonable to supply Britain's "uneconomic pits should be used to provide energy to help feed the millions starving througnout th THIS week's article continues the discussion of a socialist energy policy that I began several weeks ago, and looks at the international aspects.

In Britain we have old people dying from cold each winter while the Coal Board protests that it has "too much" coal. But the irrationalities of capitalism are even more glaring on an international scale.

The poor of the Third World frequently experience energy drought or famine. This lack has several causes:

1. The removal of energy (as oil or wood) to the "advanced" countries. _2. The high cost of fuel to countries without their own resources.

3. The loss of energy production through erosion and land being turned into desert, as the Third World poor are forced onto unsuitable land.

4. Increased dependence on fuel-hungry machines or energyrich fertilisers resulting from capitalist development.

Let's see how these causes interact in practice.

Food is the most basic form of energy in the Third World. And as capitalism spreads more and more into Third World agriculture, energy supplies for food production are also crucial -fertiliser and fuel for tractors.

The basis for the Green Revolution (GR) was laid some 40 years ago with the development of high yielding varieties of maize in Mexico by Rockefeller Foundation plant scientists.

Later, the Rockefeller and Ford Foundations developed high yield rice (or "miracle" rice) in the Philippines.

"Miraculous"

These new varieties became widely used in many countries from the late 1960s and they did increase yields. Unfortunately, as Susan George says* , the new varieties are miraculous only in so far as it was protected against disease and received appropriate fertilisers, irrigation and drainage," and GR varieties often needed five times as much fertiliser as well as weed-killers.

The GR greatly sharpened class differentiation in the countryside. Rich peasants who could afford fertilisers and irrigation became richer. Poor peasants became poorer or had to become wage labourers.

} Lester Brown of the Rockefeller-funded Worldwatch Institute predicted that increased output would make it profitable to mechanise agriculture, and he thought that the machinery and chemicals could only be supplied by multinational agri-businesses who thus had a vested interest in famine'.

the GR.

But the rise in oil prices and consequent quadrupling of prices of chemical fertiliser (mostly made from oil and gas) put the boot into the GR as a way of easily raising Third World food production.

The picture is always complicated by local historical and political factors as we can see by looking at the case of Zambia analysed by Rene Dumont and Marie-France Mottin** British colonialism Here, British colonialism caused rural underdevelopment by taking labour from the land for the copper mines and the big capitalist farms in the south (now Zimbabwe).

Atter independence, the ruling elite tried to "modernise" agriculture by subsidising fertilisers and encouraging better-off peasants to hire tractors.

This slowed down the spread of ox-drawn transport, discouraged the use of organic manure and crop rotation to revitalise the soil, all self-sufficient practises. Zambia became more dependent on fossil fuels and their by-products (nitrate fertilisers).

GR varieties of maize were encouraged, and other prestige crops requiring high energy inputs.

The main local energy resource, wood, is being squan: dered. Tractor cultivation is easier without trees in the way, but the felled trees are burnt where they are in the absence of the means to take them where they might be used.

Where the poor need wood for fuel, they take it from hillsides, resulting in erosion and loss of soil fertility:

Industry in Zambia is frequently most • profligate of energy. One sugar refinery uses imported machines and technicians to make white sugar at $2000 a tonne. instead of better-tasting unrefined sugar at a few dollars a tonne.

The energy for such industry is imported together with the fuel for the 100,000 plus cars belonging to the city-dwelling elite. More economic public transport is neglected.

Such dependence on imported energy is punished with oilprice increases at the same time as the price of the major currency earner, copper, drops.

Even if they escape dependence on energy for agriculture, Third World people still need energy for cooking. Anil Agarwal***, showed that in India, the world's tenth industrial power, half the energy consumed is for cooking.

Nearly nine-tenths of this was "renewable" wood, crop wastes and cow dung, but because of erosion, deforestation and the neglect of "non-commercial" energy by planners, there is an energy crisis.

Country women and children walk for miles daily collecting firewood, since kerosene, coal and gas are too expensive.

This exacerbates loss of forests already caused by logging for profit and encourages erosion and flooding.

Lack of energy for cooking results in less digestible food and the spread of parasites and disease.

The solution is a political change so that existing resources, technology and knowledge are used to benefit the majority.

A socialist energy policy in a single country, area or continent would take very different forms depending on whether it was Zambia or Algeria, Britain or Japan. But energy issues are perhaps one of the clearest proofs that modern national borders are economically irrational and that socialism cannot be properly developed in the framework of a single country.

Modern industry and agriculture depends on huge international flows of energy. Not only the profit priorities of capitalism, but also the different national interests of states with vastly differing energy endowments, make rational planning of those flows impossible.

An international economy could make rational plans about combining different Nigerian wells Lewis Myrthyr colliery. Photo, John Harris the

----- pull-quotes -----

The Tories say that Britain? collieries are producing too much coal, and pits must close. But millions world- wide suffer from fuel

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 204

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →