When Africa was 'backward'
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-11-08Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
surplus energy (as well as the EEC food mountains) free to the needy wherever they are.
A socialist world would also relate energy use to resources. It would not squander resources as if there were no tomorrow. It would increase use of renewable sources, and, as necessary, cut down on present-day waste of energy Vast amounts of energy are wasted, for example, by private cars being used instead of public transport in the richer countries.
The socialist answer to energy famine in the Third World is not to try to find some way of living with tiny supplies of energy, but to give the peoples of the Third World a more just share of the world's resources.
But there is also a place for small-scale energy projects to give Third World villages more autonomy and control over their development. research resources of the West were devoted to the task, surely it would not take them long to devise small, robust solar energy units usable by Third World communities with lots of sun but few other energy sources.
*How The Other Half Dies. **Stranglehold on Africa. ***New Scientist, Feb. 1983. IN the Middle Ages Ethiopia was not underdeveloped.
Walter Rodney - a black Marxist historian assassinated in 1980 as he tried to build a working-class party in his native Guyana — writes: "The kings distinguished themselves by building several churches cut out of solid rock. The architectural achievements attest to the level of skill reached by Ethiopians as well as the capacity of the state to mobilise labour on a huge scale...
"Fine illuminated books and manuscripts became a prominent element of Amharic culture. Equally fine garments and jewellery were produced for the ruling class and for the church... Craft skills were developed in a number of spheres"
Other countries today stricken by poverty - Egypt, for example - were once the world's greatest centres of civilisation.
When Portugal first established itself as a colonial power in what is now famine-stricken Mozambique, the local ArabAfrican city states there, with their "fine stone houses and the air of elegance in the local courts and markets" , were "a world comparable, if not superior, in material culture to Portugal" (James Duffy, 'Portugal in Africa').
The European powers had certain advantages over the peoples of Africa and Asia - a more dynamic economic system, more centralised state power, and better military technology - that enabled them to make their conquests. But overall there was no great superiority.
Francois Quesnay, a Frenchman, wrote of China in 1767: *No one can deny that this state is the most beautiful in the world, the most densely populated, and the most flourishing kingdom known". Scientific discoveries in China reached a remarkable level.
In Zimbabwe, when the 19th century white colonialists found the ruined buildings after which the country is now named, they assumed that they must have been built by previous white invaders. They could not believe that black Africans were capable of such achievements.
When Britain first took control of India, in the 18th century, the country was thought of not as a sea of poverty, but as a fabulous treasure-house in the Orient. The ordinary people were somewhat poorer than in Britain, but by a factor of perhaps 2:3 rather than 1:20 today. The luxury of the ruling class was probably Tunisians hanged by Italian colonialists, 1912 greater than that of Europe's ruling classes.
The economics of colonialism were responsible for today's economic gap between the average living standard in Britain and in India. At independence in 1947, the conditions of the Indian peasantry were roughly the same as they had been 200 years earlier — maybe a little bit better, maybe a little bit worse.
The colonial era which had enriched thousands of British investors and administrators left the Indian peasants stuck in absolute poverty.
Underdevelopment is nothing to do with a lack of talent or energy by the people of a country. Like modern industrial development, it is the product of an economic system: capitalism.
Before the 18th century or thereabouts economic differences between parts of the world were much smaller than today. Or, to be more accurate, they were differences of a different sort.
Some societies ancient Egypt, ancient Greece, ancient China - reached a much higher level of culture than others. But this was a difference that mostly concerned the ruling class.
Whatever happened in the wealthier spheres of society, the mass of the people did little or nothing more than scratch a bare living from the land.
The technical level varied, and the social relations through which the ruling class extracted the surplus product from the working population were different from society to society. But the living standards of the mass of the people never rose much above the bare minimum of filling their bellies and keeping out the cold and the rain.
Inverse Today we have the inverse situation. In the capital of Ethiopia, according to the press reports, the wealthy classes live not very differently from the wealthy in Europe or America. A luxury hotel in Addis Ababa provides the same service as a luxury hotel in New York. Even in Ethiopia - one of the half-dozen most underdeveloped countries in the world - such industry as there is can use recognisably similar technologies to those in the advanced countries. -Yet for millions of Ethiopian peasants life is as primitive and brutual and precarious as it was 500 or 1000 years ago, if not more so.
There were great Egypt - now 'underdeveloped', once empires before capitalism. But capitalism was the first social system to create an integrated world economy:
Also, capitalism has a drive towards expansion which far exceeds that of any previous In Imperial China, in Moghul India, in ancient Egypt or in medieval Europe, economic advance meant only an increase in the luxury and religious or military display of the ruling class. It was thus inherently limited.
Luxury
Capitalism, too, •features ruling class luxury and military display. But those are not fundamental.
As against "the old view, in which the human being appears as the aim of production" ,in "the modern world" , as Karl Marx put it, "production appears as the aim of mankind and wealth as the aim of production"
By making everything measurable against money, capıtalısm creates a torm of wealth - capital, constantly turning trom money into other forms and back agaın - which by its very nature seeks unlimited expansion.
Thus capitalism makes possible both unprecedented material advance and terrible inhumanity and inequality under the cloak of the impersonal laws of the market economy.
The story of development and underdevelopment is the story of how capitalism's drive to expand production has worked its way through unevenly, creating huge material advances in Western Europe and the US and also in some areas in the centre of civilisation Third World, while simultan eously it creates ruin elsewhere, It is a complicated story. In later articles I will look at how underdevelopment was generated in different areas — Africa, India, Latin America. Each history is different in detail. There are, however, some common factors.
1. Capitalism developed in Western Europe out of feudalism. Feudalism, like other pre-capitalist forms cf society, was fundamentally a system whereby a class owning or controlling the land won power and privilege by extracting tribute from the peasantry.
Unlike other pre-capitalist forms of society, however, it also allowed for the growth in the towns of a merchant and craft-worker class which was relatively independent from the ruling class - and which became the bearer of a new form of society.
When the European powers established economic and political domination over Africa, Asia and Latin America, they destroved the local craft industries. They implanted some new capitalist enterprise — but in the midst of ruin.
2. Centralised state power plays a crucial role in promoting capitalist development. But the colonies had no state power of their own. They were ruled by the state powers of Europe.
Tariffs, taxes and communications were designed to suit the needs of European capitalism.
The early years of capitalist development in Europe were boosted by vast plunder from the Americas and Asia. The peoples of the Third World, far from being able to plunder others, were themselves plundered.
3. To maintain their colonial rule, the European powers *had to find their allies more and more among Indian princes, Egyptian pashas, or African paramount chiefs" (Robinson and Gallagher, "Africa and the Victorians').
Pre-capitalist forms of exploitation of the peasantry, forms which inherently limited economic development, were modified but also solidified by the backing of colonial power.
The colonialists created, to justify themselves, an ideology which said that the peoples of Africa and Asia were naturally •backward" . They then set up a system calculated to make them 'backward"
Scan page 8
Socialist Organiser no. 204, November 8 1984 Page 8
----- pull-quotes -----
cli Martin Thomas "Why Poverty?' origins of world
begins our new series with a look at the poverty.