Riots in India
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-11-08Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
BY Saturday November 3, the official death toll in the aftermath of the assassination of Indira Gandhi had passed 500. Exactly how many people have died is not yet clear - but it runs into hundreds more.
Rioting by Hindus directed against the Sikh minority — held to be collectively responsible — has spread across the country. There could be Sikh counterviolence in the Punjab, where there are approximately eight million Sikhs out of a population of 16 million.
The slaughter last week echoes similar events last year when over 2,500 Muslim immigrants in Assam died in Hindu rioting, and thousands of refugees fled the state in terror. There were also attacks by Hindus on Moslems in Bombay earlier this year.
Communalism - inter-community sectarian conflict - has grown in India recently. And there is no doubt that Gandhi's Congress (1) Party is partly to blame.
Opposition
Gandhi's rule - since she returned to power in 1980 — has increasingly been challenged by movements in India's regions hostile to central government authority. Local and regional elections in 1982 and 1983 revealed a growth of various opposition forces - or more accurately, a regrowth, since Steve Gandhi was soundly defeated in 1977 after the end of the State of Emergency she imposed in 1975.
In 1983, Gandhi's party was heavily defeated in the election in Andhra Pradesh by a film actor, NT Rama Rao. And in Karnataka, the Congress Party suffered a defeat. Tripura and West Bengal remained in he hands of the Communist Party (Marxist).
Sikhs
The opposition force that has hit the international headlines this year, however, is the Sikhs.
Last June, there was fierce fighting between Sikhs and the Indian army in the Punjab, with thousands of Sikhs detained and killed. The conflict culminated with the army seizure of Sikh holy places in Amritsar on June 6, when 1000 people were killed.
The level of repression was typical of Gandhi's regime. But the Sikhs are not an oppressed people, and their movement is not a progressive one. Many of their demands are for special privileges rather than against oppression: And the call for a Sikh state ("Khalistan') in Punjab can only lead to sectarian conflict: the Sikhs are only just over 50% of the population and are closely intermingled with Hindus.
Two-thirds of all Sikhs live in Puniab. They are distinguished from Punjabi Hindus only by their religion. Many Sikhs are better off than the average Indian. Punjab itself is the wealthiest of India's states; and within the Punjab, Sikhs are about 90% of the large farmers (though the city merchants are more often Hindus).
Many Sikhs occupy leading positions in Indian public life, and are over-represented in the army (between 10% and 15% as against 2% of the population as a whole).
The fact that Sikhs were in Indira Gandhi's bodyguard to be in a position to assassinate her is itself instructive.
The fires of communalism in India have been stoked both by British colonial and by post-independence politicians. The British followed a deliberate policy of encouraging a separate Sikh identity after the Indian Mutiny in 1857, when the Sikhs remained loyal, and recruited them disproportionately into the army.
Identity
The Sikhs - who are a 16th century break from Hinduism -did not historically view themselves as a distinct community. That separate identity was created.
After independence, the major political parties all used communal loyalties to win support. In particular, Hindu Gandhi sectarianism was whipped up by chauvinists (like the fascist RSS and condoned by Congress. The weakness of working class parties helped this process by default. The Moscow-line Communist Party of India supported Indira Gandhi's Emergency decrees; the breakaway (but larger) Communist Party (Marxist), and now also the CPI, tailed the capitalist opposition.
Communalism has not been fought with class politics. The Congress Party has been accused of encouraging the recent violence. Khushwant Singh - a Sikh politician allied with Gandhi' prior to the storming of the Golden Temple in June - claimed that the Hindu "mobs were led by members of the Congress (I).
*In my neighbourhood [they] were led by the president of the local Congress (I) committee." (Guardian, November 6). India has seen a large number of major strikes over recent months. And although communal loyalties are obviously extremely powerful, there have been reports of joint HinduSikh 'peace committees' being set up in many areas. (Financial Times, November 5).
A struggle against communalism and for working class unity is the way out.